Page URL:

First in-body genome editing trial delivers mixed results

11 February 2019
Appeared in BioNews 986

The first in vivo genome editing therapy has been successful in editing patients' DNA, but has not shown a clinical benefit.

US biotech firm Sangamo Therapeutics used genome editing to introduce a working copy of a faulty gene into patients with a rare inherited disorder, Hunter syndrome. In two patients, the gene was successfully introduced into the DNA of target liver cells, and it did not cause adverse effects. However, it had no effect on symptoms.

'This is a first step,' said Dr Joseph Muenzer of the University of North Carolina, who was involved in testing the treatment. 'It's just not potent enough.'

Hunter syndrome is caused by mutations in the IDS gene, which codes for the enzyme IDS, also known as I2S, which metabolises carbohydrates known as glycosaminoglycans (GAGs). With the body unable to process GAGs, toxic by-products slowly build up, leading to progressive and widespread organ damage. 

The standard treatment involves weekly infusions of the missing enzyme. Seeking a permanent cure, the researchers used zinc finger nucleases in a viral vector to deliver a functioning copy of the IDS gene to the patient's liver cells, spliced specifically into an active region of the genome (see BioNews 927).

Similar approaches have been used on cultured cells, but this is the first time the technique has been successfully deployed in the bodies of human patients. In contrast to the recent controversy over the Chinese scientist Dr He Jiankui – who claimed to have edited genes in embryos (see BioNews 977) – the DNA alterations do not pass down to future generations.  

Sangamo presented their results to the WORLDSymposium conference on 7 February 2019. Liver biopsies confirmed that the IDS gene had been introduced into two patients' genomes, but levels of IDS enzyme in blood and GAG breakdown products in urine were unchanged. One patient did show increased IDS activity, but the response was short-lived – and may have been caused by an immune response to the viral delivery mechanism used to transport the genome editing components into cells.

Reaction to the news was mixed. Share prices for Sangamo fell significantly, suggesting that investor expectations may have got ahead of the technology. 

However, Dr Tyler Reimschisel of Vanderbilt University, Tennessee – who was not involved with the study – said: 'It's not discouraging, it's just early and on a small amount of people… This is definitely a novel and innovative treatment.'

The company also released data for a similar trial on Hurler syndrome – a related metabolic condition caused by a different gene. This trial is at an earlier stage, and although no adverse effects have been detected, it is too early to say if the treatment has been effective.

19 July 2021 - by Joseph Hawkins 
Base editing, a form of genome editing, has been used in preclinical model to correct a lysosomal storage disease known as Hurler syndrome...
9 March 2020 - by Charlotte Spicer 
A team of researchers in the US has become the first to use the genome-editing tool CRISPR directly on a person's body...
25 February 2019 - by James Close 
A new gene therapy is being developed to treat the rare genetic condition Angelman syndrome in while the affected foetus is still in the womb...
4 February 2019 - by Dr Sam Sherratt 
Last November, Dr He Jiankui, a former associate professor of the Southern University of Science and Technology in Shenzen, China, made the announcement that he had created the first ever genome edited human children by using CRISPR to create mutations designed to make the children more resistant to HIV...
3 December 2018 - by Professor John Harris 
The announcement that Chinese scientists had genetically edited two embryos resulting in genome-edited human babies has occasioned outrage. My first reaction is that this action (if true) is both premature and reckless...
26 November 2018 - by Charlotte Spicer 
Scientists have successfully used genome editing in the kidneys of mice for the first time...
10 September 2018 - by Charlotte Spicer 
Preliminary results from the first clinical trial to use genome editing directly in the body suggest that the technique is safe...
20 November 2017 - by Jen Willows 
A new clinical trial in California marks the first time that genome editing has been used inside the body, rather than on cells such as blood or skin which can be extracted, edited outside the body, and then replaced...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.