Page URL:

Womb transplants – is surrogacy safer?

16 November 2015
By Dr Natasha Hammond-Browning
Lecturer in Law, University of Southampton
Appeared in BioNews 828

The recent news that the Health Research Authority has given approval to a UK charity to conduct a clinical trial for womb transplants is seen as welcome news for women without wombs (1). Womb Transplant UK, led by Dr Richard Smith, a consultant gynaecologist at the Queen Charlotte's and Chelsea Hospital in London, has been given approval to conduct a clinical trial involving ten womb transplants (2).

The donated womb will come from a brain-dead organ donor, and the health of the woman and the womb will be closely monitored for one year before an embryo will be implanted in the womb. The embryo will be created from the recipient's own egg and her partner's sperm and, if a pregnancy occurs, the fetus will be delivered at approximately eight months' gestation by caesarean section. When possible, couples will be given the option of trying for two pregnancies. The transplanted womb is to be removed six months after birth, negating the need to take immune suppressants for life (3,4).

Generally, transplants and advances in transplant procedures are to be welcomed as they can drastically improve the length and quality of life of patients. For example, kidney transplants allow people to live free of lengthy and life-consuming dialysis procedures. While organ transplants are usually carried out for life-lengthening reasons (i.e. without an organ donation, many people would die sooner than, if they received one), womb transplants are not performed for life-lengthening purposes. However, I believe that the potential benefit of womb transplants needs to be more closely examined. The sole purpose and benefit of a womb transplant is to provide the recipient with an opportunity to become pregnant and carry a child and, in this particular trial, any children produced will be genetically related to the woman who received the womb.

The pain and suffering of the involuntarily infertile is not to be underestimated, and neither are the effects upon their lives and those around them. However, what makes this case study interesting is that the women who would be eligible for this clinical trial do have other options that will allow them to become parents, as they can choose to adopt a child, or utilise gestational surrogacy. Therefore, without a womb transplant, they are not denied the opportunity to be a parent but rather the opportunity to carry a child.

While adoption may not be the preferred option of the involuntarily infertile, particularly when the woman without the womb has functioning ovaries, gestational surrogacy would produce the same result as a womb transplant in this clinical trial – a genetically related child.

Of particular concern is that the potential recipients of a womb transplant will be putting themselves and their bodies through substantial risk and stress in order to achieve something that can be achieved via a far less risky route. The recipients will undergo major surgery at least twice, to receive the womb transplant and to remove it, as well as up to two planned caesarean sections, in addition to taking anti-rejection drugs (and the associated risks) throughout the period that they have the transplanted womb.

However, in both the gestational surrogacy and the womb-transplant option, the recipient will need to take drugs to stimulate her ovaries for the production of eggs for the creation of embryos for the IVF procedure. This is a process that cannot be avoided in either scenario.

I do not deny that there are problems with surrogacy* – not least asking another woman to run the risks of pregnancy on your behalf – but when compared to the extensive surgeries required for a womb transplant, is it not the safer option? Where the gestational surrogate has freely and voluntarily consented to carry a pregnancy on behalf of another woman, surrogacy must be preferable to the multiple risky procedures to transplant a womb in order to (potentially) carry a high-risk pregnancy. Recipients of donated wombs are at risk of far greater harm by choosing to undergo a womb transplant due to the extensive, and currently experimental, surgery required.

On one hand, pregnancy is a uniquely feminine experience, and one that I can understand that women without wombs may want to experience for themselves, but is it an experience that they will deem life-changing enough to put themselves through surgery? On the other hand, if the goal of the women eligible for this transplant is to have a genetically related child, why not achieve that goal through surrogacy? And if the UK law on surrogacy is reformed to recognise genetic/intended parents as legal parents from birth, this would be another incentive to avoid needless surgery.

There is far more to consider than just the potential future children and the scientific advances that are being made – the health and well-being of the women involved must also be taken into account.


*The problems with surrogacy are well documented and include concerns around the exploitation of women, the commodification of children, consent, financial inducements, unenforceability of contracts (in the UK context at least) and the legal status of intended parents. Examples of literature include S Wilkinson 'Bodies for Sale: Ethics and exploitation in the human body trade' (Abingdon, Routledge 2003), K Horsey 'Swept Under the Carpet: Why Surrogacy Law Needs Urgent Review' in N Priaulx and A Wrigley (Eds) 'Ethics, Law and Society Volume V' (Ashgate, Surrey, 2013), R Ber Ethical Issues in Gestational Surrogacy (2000) 21 Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 153-169.


1. Meet Sophie Lewis: the 30-year old hoping to have a womb transplant
The Guardian |  30 September 2015
2. UK Womb Transplant Research Team receives go-ahead to begin operations
Womb Transplant UK |  29 September 2015
3. Womb Transplants given UK go ahead
BBC News |  30 September 2015
4. Everything You Need to Know About Uterine Transplantation
Womb Transplant UK |  30 September 2015
25 March 2019 - by Ana Hallgarten 
The Progress Educational Trust (PET) symposium event 'Revolutionising Reproduction: The Future of Fertility Treatment' took place at the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh on the 19th March 2019...
21 November 2016 - by Dr Natasha Hammond-Browning 
Sixteen uterus donations have occurred worldwide, and so far only a research team in Sweden has carried out transplants that successfully produced live births. The Swedish trial involved donations from living persons...
17 October 2016 - by Dr Nicola Williams 
This symposium was organised to facilitate in-depth discussion as well as international and interdisciplinary collaboration between academics and clinicians with an interest in uterus transplantation (UTx), which would allow women who lack a functioning uterus to become pregnant and give birth to their own babies...
18 April 2016 - by Dr Natasha Hammond-Browning 
The first US uterus transplant was carried out in February, but before we continue down this route we need to ask whether the risks outweigh the benefits of these procedures...
12 October 2015 - by Nina Chohan 
Ethical approval has been given for clinical trials involving ten womb transplants in the UK to go ahead....
21 September 2015 - by Dr Nicola Williams 
There are currently good arguments for allowing living donors to be used in uterus transplants, but as research continues there may come a time when only deceased donors will be justifiable...
13 October 2014 - by Dr Barbara Kramarz 
A boy has become the first baby to be born to a womb transplant recipient....
13 October 2014 - by Dr Amel Alghrani 
Following the first baby born after a womb transplant, the time has come to debate uterus transplantation. How will it be regulated in the UK and what social, legal and ethical issues does it raise?
10 March 2014 - by Dr Barbara Kramarz 
Four women who had womb transplants have had embryos transferred in an attempt to become pregnant...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.