Page URL:

HIV no barrier to parenthood

11 June 2012
By Catherine Murphy
Head of parliamentary and public affairs, Terrence Higgins Trust
Appeared in BioNews 660
As the UK's largest HIV, human immunodeficiency virus, charity, Terrence Higgins Trust warmly welcomes the decision by the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) last month to consult on an updated version of its fertility guideline. The new approach outlined by NICE holds the potential to transform fertility services for men and women living with or affected by HIV in the UK who want to become parents, and goes a long way towards demystifying some crucial issues surrounding HIV, fertility and conception.

For the first time NICE recommends an approach that not only acknowledges mother to baby transmission of HIV is preventable, but also states clearly that natural conception is now a real possibility for couples where the male partner is HIV positive and that this should be recommended in certain circumstances.

The new guideline explains that the process of 'sperm washing', used where the male partner is living with HIV, is no longer an essential requirement if the man meets a number of criteria in relation to managing the infectivity of his HIV.

The availability of Highly Active Anti-Retroviral Treatment (HAART), which reduces the levels of the virus in the body and strengthens immune response to infection, has revolutionised pregnancy and motherhood for women living with HIV. Combining HAART with bottle feeding has allowed mothers living with HIV to reduce the risk of transmission to their baby from around 26 percent to less than one percent in the last 15 years.

Sperm washing has been the only option for HIV positive men who want to become fathers without risk to their partners. The process involves separating sperm from seminal fluid where HIV may be present, which can then be inseminated using either intrauterine insemination or IVF.

However, recent studies and announcements by the HIV scientific community clarifying the impact of HAART on the transmissibility of HIV during sex, is offering men living with HIV an opportunity to conceive naturally with their partners without risk of HIV transmission.

In 2008, a group of Swiss scientists produced a consensus statement that concluded an HIV positive person who is taking effective HIV medication, who has an undetectable viral load and who does not have any other STIs (sexually transmitted infections), has only a negligible risk of passing the virus on to others. Since that time a number of subsequent studies have been undertaken that have produced similar results, most notably a 2011 study involving nearly 2,000 serodiscordant couples which found a 96 percent reduction in the risk of infection through sex where HIV treatment was being taken successfully.

NICE has shown initiative in acknowledging this scientific consensus and has used its new guideline to recommend that sperm washing is no longer necessary if a man is adhering to HIV medication successfully, has a low viral load and has no other infections. In these circumstances NICE now recommends that couples can try to conceive naturally when the woman is ovulating and that in these circumstances the risk of transmission remains very low. The guideline also states that it should no longer be necessary for women to have to take post exposure prophylaxis in order to avoid infection when trying to conceive with an HIV positive partner who is undergoing treatment.

This decision is a hugely positive one for people living with HIV who can unfortunately still encounter confusion and lack of knowledge about their condition within the NHS. Terrence Higgins Trust regularly supports people who have encountered difficulties in accessing good advice around fertility issues or who have been unable to access fertility services on the NHS. This can be the result of inconsistencies in approach across the country, but equally may be the result of poor knowledge or outdated views around conception and HIV risk. The new NICE guideline offers a clear and unequivocal approach to these issues that we certainly hope will improve the experiences of couples living with HIV across the UK who want to conceive.

Medical advances mean that an HIV diagnosis should no longer be a barrier to parenthood and we will be working to ensure that NICE's stance on this issue this is broadly recognised and adopted across the NHS.

The consultation closes on 3 July.

2 December 2019 - by Dr Kimberley Bryon-Dodd 
The first sperm bank in the world for HIV positive donors has been launched in New Zealand...
17 September 2012 - by Jennie Bristow 
In the 80 hours of Parliamentary debate given to the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill in 2008, a full ten percent were devoted to a heated discussion of the clause on the 'welfare of the child' that might be born as a result of treatment...
30 July 2012 - by Dr Daniel Grimes 
Scientists have discovered that an anti-cancer drug can revive dormant HIV thereby allowing therapies to act upon the low level inactive virus particles that hide in patients' immune cells and have, until now, been unsusceptible to treatment...
26 September 2011 - by Dr Louisa Petchey 
The success of a new gene therapy trial represents a significant step towards a 'functional cure' for HIV, US researchers announced this week. By mimicking the effects of a naturally occurring gene mutation that makes an individual resistant to infection, this therapy aims to reduce or eliminate the dependency of HIV patients on antiretroviral drugs....
4 July 2011 - by Mehmet Fidanboylu 
New research has revealed that a group of generic anti-HIV drugs may be linked to premature ageing. The study, which was carried out by UK scientists at the Institute of Genetic Medicine at Newcastle University, could explain why people treated with this class of drugs sometimes show signs of age-related conditions, such as heart disease and dementia....
28 April 2003 - by Juliet Tizzard 
This week's BioNews reports on a doctor's plea to make sperm washing for HIV positive men available on the National Health Service (NHS). Is it reasonable to ask that health authorities assist individuals or couples to become parents when they have such a serious health status? Once upon a time...
28 April 2003 - by BioNews 
Dr Carole Gilling-Smith, from the Chelsea and Westminster Hospital in London, has called for the UK government to support the use of a 'sperm washing' technique for HIV patients. The technique, which involves the use of fertility treatments, may enable HIV positive men to have children with less risk of...
3 December 2001 - by Juliet Tizzard 
A short paper in this week's British Medical Journal (BMJ) suggests that UK IVF clinics are discriminating against HIV positive men and women. A spokesman for the Terrence Higgins Trust, a UK AIDS charity, was quick to agree: 'We do not know on what grounds these clinics are refusing to...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.