Page URL:

Mothers advised to reject private cord blood banking

15 October 2006
Appeared in BioNews 380

UK obstetrician Leroy Edozien has called for new mothers to be discouraged from privately banking their babies' cord blood immediately after birth. Writing in the British Medical Journal, Mr Edozien, of St Mary's Hospital Manchester, warns that consenting procedures and collecting blood for private banking puts further strain on already overstretched midwives and other hospital staff. Mr Edozien writes, 'time spent on collecting cord blood is time away from the care of this mother, the baby, and, critically, other patients'. He continued, pointing out that problems with private blood banking do not apply to altruistic donation of cord blood as, in this case, 'the blood is collected by specially trained staff who are not involved in routine care and there is no imperative to obtain a sample from any particular woman'. Mr Edozien believes that mothers should be encouraged to donate altruistically to public blood banks rather than to store the blood for their own possible future use. According to the BBC news website, the chance of an individual using personal cord blood for a blood cell disorder before the age of twenty is estimated to be between 1 in 20,000 and 1 in 37,000.

Umbilical cord blood is a rich source of stem cells which can be used to treat blood disorders such as childhood leukaemia. The NHS has been collecting and storing cord blood donated for general use since 1996. It has now collected over 17,000 samples, which may be accessed by those in need. But some commercial companies are claiming that, through advances in stem cell science, storing cord blood could protect the child's 'future health', and could potentially be used in the event of the child suffering from diseases such as Parkinson's. Private cord blood banks charge up to £1500 to store samples for up to twenty years. In June the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG) issued an updated version of its Scientific Opinion Paper on Umbilical Cord Blood Banking, which, having investigated the claims of private cord blood banks, found that there is little evidence to recommend the practice.

According to Mr Edozien, 'Storing cord blood at birth as insurance against future disease may sound like a good idea to parents, but it has worrying implications for NHS services and little chance of benefit. Increasing numbers of women in maternity units across the United Kingdom are requesting collection of umbilical cord blood at delivery to enable storage of stem cells for possible autologous transfusion in the future. Such commercial banking of cord blood has important implications for National Health Service maternity units. The debate on whether commercial cord blood banking should be encouraged has mostly been limited to the scientific merits, but risk management, medicolegal, and ethical issues also need considering'. A spokeswoman for the commercial firm UK Cord Blood Bank (UKCBB), a leading private bank in the UK, told the BBC, 'Private banks in the UK have an important role to play, particularly as the NHS has limited resources'. She also said that the UKCBB had taken steps to address some of the concerns mentioned by Mr Edozien, including offering the services of an independent nursing agency to carry out the collection.

Plea to women banking cord blood
BBC News Online |  13 October 2006
Warning Over Umbilical Cord Blood Storage
Life Style Extra |  13 October 2006
19 December 2011 - by Professor John Galloway 
We inherit our biological identity at conception but our humanity in a process beginning at birth. Nothing reminds us of this more than the rites and rituals surrounding birth and the way our rights change as we stop being a part of our mother and become a 'person'...
18 November 2007 - by Dr Karen Devine 
As a consumerist society, we are fast becoming familiar with the idea that for a price, we can bank our stem cells in case they are needed in the future to potentially fight disease, grow replacement body parts and help develop clinical therapeutic options. First came the commercial cord blood...
18 November 2007 - by Dr Karen Devine 
The storage of stem cells as a 'biological insurance' for the future is once again hitting the headlines of the popular press. This week, American based company, Cryo-Cell, announced the launch of their new stem cell storage initiative - the opportunity for women to bank their menstrual blood...
23 October 2007 - by Dr Karen Devine 
The prospect of being able to store your own stem cells as a form of future 'biological insurance' is for many, very tempting. Since the late 1990s, and in spite of the reportedly low odds that they will ever be used, parents have seized the opportunity to...
13 March 2007 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
A hospital in the US has teamed up with a biotechnology company to allow pregnant women to bank their baby's cord blood and placental stem cells in what is thought to be the first official programme to encourage stem cell banking in the country. The Saint Barnabas...
20 October 2006 - by Dr Karen Devine 
Once again, umbilical cord blood (UCB) stem cell collection and storage has been in the headlines of the popular press. UCB can be collected at birth and stored for the future use of the donor, its siblings or donated for public use. There are two main types of banking - public...
18 June 2006 - by Heidi Nicholl 
The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG) has issued an updated version of its Scientific Opinion Paper on Umbilical Cord Blood Banking. The report finds that there is little evidence to recommend the practice whereby private companies collect and store umbilical cord blood for up to...
15 June 2006 - by Dr Karen Devine 
This week saw the long awaited report from the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG), which stated its latest position on the public and private banking of umbilical cord blood stem cells. Essentially, their stance remains unchanged from the one taken in their previous opinion paper published in 2001...
25 May 2006 - by Dr Kirsty Horsey 
Doctors have discovered that a sperm donor in the US has passed on a rare genetic disease to five children born to four couples who used his sperm to conceive. The disease, severe congenital neutropenia (SCN), can be fatal in children if untreated but is so...
31 August 2005 - by BioNews 
A couple living in County Londonderry have spoken to the press about their decision to collect stem cells from their newborn baby's umbilical cord. The cells are to be stored for possible use later in his life, to help treat a number of diseases or conditions he might develop. The...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.