Page URL:

DNA profiling of newborns rejected for now

4 April 2005
By BioNews
Appeared in BioNews 302

The UK's Human Genetics Commission (HGC) and National Screening Committee (NSC) have published a joint report on the potential testing of newborn babies to detect genetic variations with health implications. The document, entitled 'Profiling the newborn', concludes that routine newborn genetic profiling is not likely to be affordable for at least another 20 years. It also cautions that newborn profiling raises important social, legal and ethical issues, which need to be addressed before such a scheme is launched.

The government asked the HGC and NSC to consider newborn profiling in its Genetics White Paper: 'Our inheritance, our future - realising the potential of genetics in the NHS', published in June 2003. The resulting joint working group's report concludes that while some newborn genetic profiling is already possible, it cannot be launched as a national screening programme 'in the near future'. However, it points out that such tests are likely to become commercially available in less than 20 years.

Advances in genetic technology mean that scientists can now look at many different genetic variations at once, using DNA microarrays, or 'chips'. Given the rapidly increasing knowledge about genetic differences that affect a person's risk of developing common diseases, such tests could one day be used to screen newborn babies for a wide range of potential health problems. Last year, the US National Institutes of Health (NIH) invited research proposals to find ways of producing a '$1000 genome' - a way of looking at someone's entire genetic make-up in one test - by 2014. It also sought to fund interim research to develop a '$100,000 genome', which is thought to be achievable within five years.

The new HGC/NSC report identifies 'a pressing need' for further research into the costs and potential benefits of newborn genetic profiling from a public health point of view, and says the topic should be considered again in five years. The potential benefits of genetic profiling include the identification of DNA variations that affect reactions to certain medicines, or the risk of conditions such as heart disease - information that could eventually lead to 'personalised healthcare'. But the report also identifies potential concerns with this approach, such as discrimination in areas such as employment, insurance and education. It concludes that before population genetic profiling is considered, 'steps would need to be taken to preclude any misuse of information derived from it'.

Helen Wallace, deputy director of pressure group GeneWatch UK, welcomed the recommendations. 'The government's proposal was always bad for health', she said, adding 'genes are poor predictors of most illnesses, so most children would get misleading information about their genetic risk'. Health Minister Lord Warner praised the report, saying that 'it covers many complex issues we will need time to consider carefully'. The document is available to download from the HGC's website.

DNA profiling of babies rejected
BBC News Online |  31 March 2005
Profiling the newborn
Human Genetics Commission |  30 March 2005
Watchdog attacks plans for genetic tests on babies
The Daily Mail |  1 April 2005
Watchdog rejects genetic profiling of babies
The Guardian |  1 April 2005
16 August 2010 - by Dr Lux Fatimathas 
Newborn babies showing signs of liver disorders will be screened for 92 genetic conditions, as part of a trial launching next month at Birmingham Children's Hospital. Newborns will be screened for multiple conditions with a single test using gene chip technology....
17 May 2004 - by BioNews 
The UK's Human Genetics Commission (HGC) has considered the issues surrounding the testing and storing of DNA samples from all newborn babies, at a meeting held in Bristol last week. The event was a follow-up to a government commitment to look at genetic profiling of newborns, made in the White...
1 March 2004 - by BioNews 
The US National Institutes of Health (NIH) is inviting proposals to develop new, cheap genome sequencing technologies, aimed at developing a '$1000 genome' by 2014. The entire human genome sequence, the first draft of which was published three years ago, cost an estimated $3 billion, with mammalian genome projects today...
18 August 2003 - by BioNews 
Baroness Helena Kennedy, chair of the UK's Human Genetics Commission (HGC) has said in an interview with the UK's Financial Times that the HGC is likely to reject proposals to genetically screen all newborn babies. In a White Paper issued in June 2003, the government proposed new measures to strengthen...
27 June 2003 - by BioNews 
The UK government unveiled its plans for genetics in the National Health Service (NHS) last week, in the form of a white paper entitled 'Our inheritance, our future - realising the potential of genetics in the NHS'. The document lays out new measures for strengthening existing genetics services, and for incorporating...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.