Page URL:

Supergran surrogacy

2 February 2004
By BioNews
Appeared in BioNews 243

A 43-year old grandmother has given birth to her own daughter's IVF twins. Lata Nagla, a 26-year old Indian woman living in the UK with her husband, has Rokitansky syndrome, a rare congenital condition where the uterus does not develop normally. This meant that she was unable to carry or give birth to her own children. However, she has normally functioning ovaries and was able to produce eggs to be used in IVF treatment with her husband's sperm, creating embryos that were later transferred to her mother's womb.

The couple looked into fertility treatments in the UK when they first found that they had problems conceiving. While undergoing fertility investigations, it was discovered that the woman's womb was absent. The couple then looked for a woman to act as a surrogate for them - in both the UK and in India - with no luck. They then approached Dr Nayana Patel, an Indian fertility expert, who suggested that the woman could ask her own mother to be the surrogate. Eventually, her mother, Rhadha Patel, who has three other children, agreed to carry the babies. In an interview with an Indian newspaper last month, she said that it took her a month to make up her mind.

The fertility treatment was carried out at a private fertility clinic in Gujarat, India, by Dr Patel. A first cycle of IVF was started in May, but was unsuccessful. A second attempt produced five embryos, which were all transferred to the grandmother's womb. Commenting on the situation, Dr Patel said: 'The IVF was technically more difficult in this case because [the daughter] didn't have a uterus'. 'But the grandmother had no complications and was totally healthy during the pregnancy', she added. The twins - a boy weighing 4.4 pounds and a girl weighing 4 pounds - were born last week.

The couple, who originally asked not to be named, are expected to return to the UK with the children in two months. Mrs Patel had said she feared a 'backlash' against the family if their names became known, including the fact that the publicity might jeopardise the marriage prospects of her other two daughters. 'We were not sure about the kind of reaction we would get from society', she said. 'It's a fear we are living with, but our daughter's happiness will help us over this'. Now, Mrs Patel has spoken to a UK Sunday newspaper, saying that being a surrogate for her daughter was the 'best thing' she had ever done.But the surrogacy arrangement has inevitably been attracting some criticism. Josephine Quintavalle, the founder of the group Comment on Reproductive Ethics (CORE), said that 'grandmother surrogacy' has some 'very uncomfortable aspects', adding that the social roles of grandmother and mother would be mixed up and when the children found out the circumstances of their birth they may be confused. 'We should always be looking at what is the ideal situation, and what is not ideal is for a grandmother to give birth to her grandchildren', she added. Nuala Scarisbrick, from the charity Life, said 'this case will disturb most right-minded people', adding 'the welfare of these baby twins has been put last, after the wishes of the parents, the grandmother and the IVF doctor involved'. But Professor Lord Robert Winston, a UK fertility expert, said that he had no problems with the arrangement, calling it 'an act of remarkable altruism'.

I'm proud to bear daughter's twins, says surrogate mother
The Sunday Telegraph |  02/04
Twins for surrogate grandmother
BBC News Online |  30 January 2004
Woman gives birth to her grandchildren
The Daily Telegraph |  30 January 2004
Woman gives birth to her own grandchildren
The Times |  30 January 2004
23 November 2020 - by Tsvetana Stoilova 
A 51-year-old grandmother offered to act as a surrogate for her daughter and gave birth to a healthy girl...
11 April 2011 - by Dr Lux Fatimathas 
A British woman has given birth to her cousin, as part of a surrogacy arrangement to help her aunt. The 29-year-old mother of three became pregnant from sperm donated by her aunt's husband, to whom she was not related by blood. This resulted in the birth of a baby girl who is both her biological daughter and cousin....
31 October 2005 - by BioNews 
A British woman who became infertile after treatment for cervical cancer has had a baby with help from her two sisters. Her identical twin sister donated the egg that was used to create the pregnancy and the other had the resulting IVF embryo implanted into her and carried the child...
3 October 2005 - by BioNews 
A 53-year-old UK woman has given birth to a child she was carrying for her daughter, leading many in the media to exclaim that she 'has given birth to her own grandchild'. Annie Casserley acted as a surrogate for her daughter, 35-year old Emma Hattersley, who has a...
2 February 2004 - by Juliet Tizzard 
A number of IVF related stories have hit the headlines this week, giving newspaper columnists much to contemplate at the weekend. One case the commentators have concentrated upon is the case of a couple who have become parents to IVF twins. The twist to this particular tale is that the...
3 July 2003 - by BioNews 
BioNews reporting from ESHRE conference, Madrid: Research presented at the annual conference of the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology in Madrid shows that women who act as surrogates suffer no severe emotional problems during pregnancy or after giving up the child. In what the researchers say is the...
1 July 2002 - by BioNews 
Research presented at the annual conference of the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE) in Vienna indicates that the parents of children born following the use of a surrogate have better parenting skills and show more warmth towards their children than those in non-surrogacy families. The research shows...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.