Page URL:

Israel's high court rejects prolific US sperm donor's petition

18 February 2019
Appeared in BioNews 987

Israel's High Court of Justice has ruled that a woman may not use the sperm of a prolific US donor to become pregnant. 

Israeli law requires complete anonymity in gamete donation, except where two people plan to co-parent the resulting child. Ari Nagel, a mathematics lecturer from New York, who has fathered at least 35 children through sperm donation agreed to sign documents saying that he intends to co-parent with the woman, but this was challenged by the Ministry of Health (see BioNews 955).

The court, delivering its judgment on 13 February, expressed a 'real and serious concern about the ability of the petitioner to actually serve as the father to over 38 children, both financially and in the essence of what a father's rule is within the family.' 

Seven Israeli women wanted to use Mr Nagel's sperm to conceive. Six of them have already have the donations held in sperm banks within Israel, but have not been allowed to use them by the Department of Health, who told one of the women:

'Considering the number of women whom Mr Nagel impregnated with his sperm... it is our position that the claim of an intention to perform true joint parenthood with Mr Nagel is not sincere or reasonable.'

Nagel, known as 'the Sperminator' in his home city, donates his sperm for free, and intends to continue even though five US women who he donated to have sued him for child support. He also has three children with his wife.

High Court tells serial sperm donor 'enough'
The Jerusalem Post |  13 February 2019
Israel High Court Rejects Woman’s Request for Superdonor’s Sperm
Haaretz |  14 February 2019
Israeli court bars woman from receiving sperm of US serial donor
The Times of Israel |  14 February 2019
4 November 2019 - by Dr Laura Riggall 
A woman has taken a sperm bank to court after giving birth to a child with dwarfism despite choosing a 6-foot-tall donor on its website, according to Russian reports...
1 April 2019 - by Hugo Wolfe 
Italy violated a woman's right to health after the country's fertility laws led to a forced pregnancy, the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights reported on Wednesday...
11 February 2019 - by Dr Brian Tobin 
A recent survey involving 90 countries reveals the overwhelming popularity of international surrogacy arrangements among many Irish couples...
5 November 2018 - by Jen Willows 
Israel's parliament, the Knesset has rejected a bill to allow single men and gay couples equal access to surrogacy...
22 October 2018 - by Georgia Everett 
Watching this film truly brought me into the shoes of a donor-conceived child. As an embryologist, I’ve been trained to be empathetic and well-counselled on the rollercoaster that is fertility treatment, but film-maker Sara Lamm’s search for her donor father opened a world of emotions I had yet to consider...
25 June 2018 - by Jen Willows 
A US sperm donor who has already fathered over 30 children has been prevented from impregnating women in Israel...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.