Page URL:

Singapore woman wins damages from IVF sperm mix-up

27 March 2017
Appeared in BioNews 894

A woman in Singapore has been awarded damages after an IVF clinic fertilised her eggs with a stranger's sperm instead of her husband's.

The mistake only came to light after a baby girl was born from the resulting conception. Tests revealed that the child had blood group B, which meant she could not be the genetic child of the couple, who are groups O and A. Further tests revealed the child was biologically related to the mother but not the father.

The Singapore Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the High Court rejecting the couple's claim for the expenses occurred in raising the child: 'The duty to maintain one's child is a duty which lies at the very heart of parenthood, and thus the expenses which are incurred... are not capable of characterisation as a loss.'

However, the Court of Appeal departed from the High Court's judgment by deciding that the woman could be compensated for the loss of 'genetic affinity', and could recover damages of 30 percent of the cost of raising the child.

'The ordinary human experience is that parents and children are bound by ties of blood and this fact of biological experience – heredity – carries deep socio-cultural significance... And when, as in the present case, a person has been denied this experience due to the negligence of others then she has lost something of profound significance and has suffered a serious wrong,' the court ruled.

The mother is ethnically Chinese and the father is Caucasian, and they have an older biological son. The sperm used was from an Indian man, and the court recognised that the difference in appearance between the girl and her family drew unwanted attention: 'This loss of "affinity" can also result in social stigma and embarrassment arising out of the misperceptions of others, as was the case here.' 

Singapore is a common-law jurisdiction, and a precedent exists that a healthy child is always a blessing – even if the couple had sought to avoid pregnancy – and cannot be a cause for compensation. The High Court had further noted that in this case the couple had 'had wanted a second child all along' so it was 'not be said that [she] and her husband were not contemplating having to expend money to bring up a child'. 

15 November 2021 - by Dr Holly Barker 
A California couple is suing a US fertility clinic for transferring the wrong embryo during IVF treatment...
15 November 2021 - by Michaela Chen 
A Utah couple is suing their IVF clinic after discovering that sperm from another patient was used to conceive their son...
16 September 2019 - by Georgia Everett 
A New Jersey couple is suing a fertility clinic after another man's sperm was accidentally used during their IVF treatment...
12 August 2019 - by Sarah Gregory 
A couple in Ohio is suing a fertility clinic and associated organisations after a genetic test given as a Christmas present revealed a sperm mix-up in their IVF treatment...
15 July 2019 - by Dr Rachel Montgomery 
A couple are suing a US fertility clinic after an IVF mix-up resulted in the woman giving birth to twin boys unrelated to them - or each other...
10 October 2016 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
The latest data from the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority has shown that the number of adverse incidents in UK fertility clinics has increased slightly...
26 September 2016 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
An Australian woman has been wrongly listed as the biological mother of a child born following IVF treatment...
3 May 2016 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
A woman is suing a sperm bank in the USA for the second time, alleging that it provided sperm from the wrong donor...
18 April 2016 - by Cait McDonagh 
A clerical mistake at a Sheffield IVF clinic meant that a father's status as his child's legal parent was put in doubt...
11 April 2016 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
The President of the Family Division, Sir James Munby, has criticised as 'insensitive' the handling of a claim brought by the biological mother of twins who was the victim of an administrative error at a fertility clinic...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.