Page URL: https://www.bionews.org.uk/page_95528

Controversial Italian fertility specialist denies stealing woman's eggs

23 May 2016
Appeared in BioNews 852

A controversial Italian fertility doctor has been arrested after being accused of taking a woman's eggs without her consent.

Seventy-year-old Dr Severino Antinori, who attracted media attention in the 1990s for helping a woman give birth at 63, denies the claims. He told the AGI news agency: 'I have pains in my chest, I could have had a heart attack, I am very ill because of this unjustified arrest. Do they want me dead? I am an honest man. I've never robbed eggs from anyone and while all this is going on the embryos that have been sequestrated are dying.'

The allegations were made by a 24-year-old Spanish woman who had recently started work at Dr Antinori's Matris clinic in Milan. Speaking to Italian investigators, the woman said she had been due to undergo a procedure to remove an ovarian cyst but that before the treatment began, her mobile was taken and she was forcefully restrained, anaesthetised and then operated on - with her eggs harvested against her consent.

Following the surgery, the woman filed a complaint and Dr Antinori was arrested at Fiumicino airport in Rome soon after. He is now under house arrest, suspended from practicing for one year, and faces charges of aggravated robbery and personal injury.

According to The Guardian, Dr Antinori's lawyer said that his client was being extorted and that the alleged victim was 'conscious of the choice she was making', adding that she had signed consent forms for the procedure.

In 1994, Dr Antinori became well known for helping Rosanna Della Corte to conceive at the age of 63 through IVF treatment using donor eggs (2). Thereafter, in 2006, he also helped a British woman, Patricia Rashbrook, give birth to a son at the age of 62 (see BioNews 366).

The controversial fertility specialist is also known for supporting the use of human reproductive cloning. In 2002, Dr Antinori claimed that three women had given birth to babies following the implantation of embryos created using CNR, a practice that is banned in most countries including Italy (see BioNews 257). His claims have been widely met with scepticism. 

Italy has some of the most restrictive rules on assisted conception in Europe, with IVF using donated eggs and sperm only made available in limited circumstances after a court ruling in 2014 (see BioNews 750).

Donata Lenzi, a member of Prime Minister Matteo Renzi's Democratic party, commented: 'The arrest of Severino Antinori is extremely serious because it indicates the existence of a market in eggs that will not stop at anything.'

SOURCES & REFERENCES
Controversial Italian fertility doctor accused of stealing patient's egg
The Guardian |  15 May 2016
Italian IVF doctor suspected of stealing patient's eggs
The Local |  14 May 2016
Top Italian fertility doctor Severino Antinori arrested
BBC News |  14 May 2016
RELATED ARTICLES FROM THE BIONEWS ARCHIVE
7 November 2016 - by Ryan Ross 
A Canadian fertility doctor is facing a class action lawsuit by the families of some of his former patients, who allege that he used his own sperm in donor-conception procedures without their knowledge or consent...
19 September 2016 - by Annabel Slater 
A retired fertility doctor in the US has been accused of using his own sperm to fertilise the eggs of patients at a fertility clinic...
26 May 2009 - by Dr Sarah Spain 
The record for Britain's oldest women to give birth will be broken next month by 66 year old Elizabeth Munro, from Cambridge. It is thought that Ms Munro, who is single and a successful business woman, travelled to the Ukraine to become pregnant using donor eggs and...
14 December 2008 - by Sarah Pritchard 
An Indian woman has given birth to a baby girl by Caesarean section at the age of 70, after receiving fertility treatment in her home state of Haryana in India. Rajo Devi and her husband Bala Ram remained childless during 55 years of marriage before they heard...
16 September 2008 - by Sarah Pritchard 
A 59-year old woman has given birth to triplets in a Paris hospital after receiving fertility treatment abroad. The woman, believed to be of Asian origin, travelled to Vietnam to be treated by a private clinic willing to overlook her age; the usual upper age limit...
18 May 2005 - by Professor David Oderberg 
Professors David Oderberg and Julian Savulescu recently discussed the ethical issues surrounding human cloning in a London debate, entitled 'Severino Antinori should not be condemned for pushing back the boundaries of parents' right to choose'. Here, Professor David Oderberg puts forward his arguments against all forms of cloning: 'I would...
HAVE YOUR SAY
Log in to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions


Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.