Page URL:

Australian parliamentary committee calls for national surrogacy regulation

9 May 2016
Appeared in BioNews 850

A federal parliamentary committee in Australia has recommended that commercial surrogacy should remain illegal in the country, but that altruistic surrogacy should be regulated at a national level. 

The House of Representatives Standing Committee on Social Policy and Legal Affairs has said that commercial surrogacy – defined as being where the surrogate is remunerated for financial gain – could lead to economic pressure on the surrogate and the expectations of intended parents undermining a surrogate's free and informed consent. However, it did suggest that providing 'appropriate reimbursement' to surrogates could be reasonable.

Its report recommended that Australian surrogacy laws should be harmonised and that altruistic surrogacy be regulated at a national level. At present, surrogacy in Australia is mostly regulated by individual states. While they all prohibit commercial surrogacy, the laws dealing with altruistic surrogacy can vary in scope and application. This can make it difficult for some intended parents to find a surrogate and means that checks and protections are inconsistent across the country, the committee noted.

The committee's inquiry into surrogacy, entitled 'Surrogacy Matters', was adopted at the request of the Attorney-General in December 2016 to consider harmonising surrogacy laws, international surrogacy and the provision of information to those engaged in surrogacy. Its report acknowledges that surrogacy is a 'complex field of examination', and regulation must deal with the fact that today children are born from varied sources of genetic material.

'Society now recognises many different forms of blended and adoptive families that are not based solely on genetic connections, expanding the models of family formation and familial relationships,' the report states.

In an effort to produce a national model to regulate surrogacy, the committee has asked the Australian Law Reform Commission (ALRC) to look into developing a draft legal framework, with particular consideration being given to the best interests of the child, legal clarity around resulting parent–child relationships, and ensuring that surrogates can give free, informed consent and are free from exploitation.

It has also asked the ALRC to consider if measures including mandatory counselling, background checks, the provision of legal advice, reimbursements for surrogates and the creation of a closed register of surrogates and intended parents, should be introduced.

In addition, the committee has asked the ALRC to look into whether a child's birth certificate should contain the details of all parents, including the gestational, genetic and intended parents, and record that the birth followed a surrogacy arrangement.

The report follows a number of highly publicised overseas surrogacy arrangements, including that of Nareubet Minjaroen, known as 'Baby Gammy', born to a Thai surrogate and whom his Australian intended parents had allegedly left behind – a version of events disputed by the couple and a recent Australian court decision (see BioNews 765 and 847).

'A number of high-profile offshore surrogacy cases involving Australians have highlighted these ethical issues, the possibilities for exploitation, and the importance of ensuring that at all times it is the best interests of the child that is paramount in any regulatory response to surrogacy,' the report states.

In respect of offshore surrogacy arrangements, the committee said that such arrangements should be subject to 'detailed scrutiny'. Recommendations include conducting an audit of host countries to see if practices are consistent with an Australian national model, and also screening Australians wanting to return with a child born to an oversees surrogate to ensure that no national or international rules relating to surrogacy have been breached.

It also urged the Australian Government to promote the development of an international convention dealing with surrogacy, currently under consideration at the Hague Conference on Private International Law.

Meanwhile, speaking at a meeting organised by the Surrogacy Law Reform project in London last week, Baroness Mary Warnock, chair of the committee whose 1984 report led the introduction of regulation for assisted conception, said that the UK's position on surrogacy was now 'outdated' and needed to change.

Rejecting commercial surrogacy, Baroness Warnock also told BBC Radio 4's Woman's Hour that 'the birth certificate ought to tell the truth' and, rather than naming the donor or surrogate, it should state if a child has been born through gamete donation or surrogacy. Otherwise it leaves it open for the parents to 'deceive' the child about who their biological mother and father is, she said. 

Australian govt report backs ban on domestic commercial surrogacy
BioEdge |  7 May 2016
Surrogacy Matters: Inquiry into the regulatory and legislative aspects of international and domestic surrogacy arrangements
Parliament of Australia |  4 May 2016
25 September 2017 - by Dr Iain Brassington 
The implausibilities of this series ought not to detain us too long. For there are deep and troubling questions that the series raises. What is it to be a 'real' mother?...
17 October 2016 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, a human rights organisation, has voted to reject a proposal to introduce international guidelines on surrogacy and children's rights...
4 July 2016 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
A surrogate has been allowed to keep a baby after refusing to hand the child over to the intended parents after birth...
13 June 2016 - by Stephen Page 
A parliamentary inquiry into surrogacy laws in Australia has just reported its recommendations, but they don't go far enough and the country is likely to remain the world's largest exporters of intended parents...
18 April 2016 - by Julianna Photopoulos 
A court in Western Australia has ruled that the twin sister of Baby Gammy, who was born to a Thai surrogate in 2013, should remain with her parents in Australia...
1 February 2016 - by Dr Kirsty Horsey and Dr Sue Avery 
Last November, we accepted an invitation to have coffee and a chat with Mary Warnock. We had no real brief – we just looked forward to a tour through her life and her thoughts on what she had done for the world of assisted reproduction...
7 December 2015 - by Dr Kirsty Horsey 
The results of the Surrogacy UK survey are in. Following an unprecedented response, the overwhelming message is that surrogacy law in the UK needs to be reformed...
23 November 2015 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
A report calling for reform of surrogacy laws in the UK has revealed that the majority of arrangements are conducted on an altruistic basis and do not take place abroad, contrasting with what it claims are commonly held misconceptions...
27 April 2015 - by Professor Jenni Millbank 
Surrogacy has received vastly disproportionate attention in Australia given its infrequent occurrence. In less than 30 years we have seen 27 public inquiries and at least 17 different laws passed. Many thousands of media articles and current affairs stories have been penned and filmed...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.