Page URL:

Call to end US federal funding ban on chimera research

9 November 2015
Appeared in BioNews 827

A group of researchers have called for an overturn of a recent decision by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) to suspend funding for research on human–animal chimeras.

The current debate concerns the inclusion of human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) in an early animal embryo, such that the embryo incorporates the human cell at an early stage of development.

The NIH already withholds funding for research involving the creation of human–primate chimeras or breeding of animals where hPSCs could enter the germline. However, it announced in September 2015 it would start a process to review the science, ethical issues and animal-welfare concerns around the use of hPSCs to produce chimeras and abruptly stopped considering funding applications for such research.

The researchers, primarily from Stanford University, California, argue in a letter to Science that chimeric research has considerable benefits. These include the potential for developing human-specific models for better understanding drug actions, living models for understanding inherited diseases, and the possibility of developing replacement human organs using pig or sheep models.

'We believe that this notice poses a threat to progress in stem cell biology, developmental biology, and regenerative medicine,' they write.

'A continued dialogue between scientists and bioethicists regarding human/non-human chimera studies is critical for advancing human health through basic science.'

Associate Director for Science Policy at the NIH, Dr Carrie Wolinetz, told NPR the decision to suspend funding was prompted by an increasing number of applications in the field. The NIH wanted to 'make sure that we are fully prepared from a policy and guidance point of view' before making decisions about such research, she said.

One ethical concern is that animal brains could contain human cells, raising the possibility that 'this will somehow give the animal a human consciousness', said Professor Hank Greely, a bioethicist at Stanford.

But the authors of the letter argue that numerous studies introducing human neurons to mouse brains have found no evidence for this. 'There's been nothing like a mouse with human thoughts,' co-author Dr Sean Wu, told STAT.

A further issue is the possibility of stem cells creating human eggs and sperm in the animals. Professor Greely told NPR, 'If you had a male mouse that had human sperm in it, that's going to be a concern to some people, especially if it's anywhere near a female mouse that has human eggs in it.'

The NIH is not the only source of funding for regenerative medicine of this nature. However, as a federal funding body it is very influential. The authors of the Science letter argue that withdrawal of NIH funding 'casts a shadow of negativity' over chimerism research and threatens scientific progress.

On 6 November the NIH held a workshop in Bethesda, Maryland, involving researchers, bioethicists and lawyers to begin their process of policy evaluation.

Human-animal chimeras face new ethical scrutiny
STAT |  5 November 2015
Human-animal chimeras: Stanford scientists condemn funding ban
San Jose Mercury News |  5 November 2015
Lift NIH restrictions on chimera research
Science |  6 November 2015
Researchers urge lifting of NIH funding restrictions on chimeric research
Stanford Medicine (press release) |  5 November 2015
Should Human Stem Cells Be Used To Make Partly Human Chimeras?
npr |  6 November 2015
19 April 2021 - by BioNews 
The director of the Progress Educational Trust is interviewed by 5 News about embryos containing material from both monkeys and humans...
5 September 2016 - by Anneesa Amjad 
A prominent bioethicist in the USA has suggested that most of the ethical concerns surrounding the creation of animal-human chimera embryos using human pluripotent stem cells could be reasonably addressed...
8 August 2016 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
The US National Institutes of Health is considering lifting a ban on the funding of research to create human-animal 'chimeras' and replacing it with an ethical review process...
20 June 2016 - by Dr Anna Smajdor 
The recent of creation of pig embryos with human DNA blurs the boundaries between animals and ourselves, giving us a chance to consider whether our moral categories are correct...
13 June 2016 - by Dr Jane Currie 
Scientists have used CRISPR to create part-pig, part-human embryos in an attempt to grow human organs for transplant...
11 May 2015 - by Dr Tamara Hirsch 
Scientists have identified a new type of stem cell that shows distinct advantages over those discovered to date, and which could potentially be used to grow human organs in animals such as pigs or cows...
7 January 2013 - by John Brinsley 
Mythical ideas of 'chimera', or animals formed or forged of parts derived from various different organisms, have endured throughout history, from Greek folklore and Homer's Iliad through to contemporary science fiction. In fact, organisms arising from human-nonhuman genetic combinations are already with us...
9 January 2012 - by Suzanne Elvidge 
Three chimeric rhesus monkeys born in the USA have been described as the world's first primate chimeras...
10 October 2011 - by Tara Camm 
In 2008, important changes were made to the legislation governing the use of human embryos in research, the UK Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act (HFE Act) 1990. The legislation was extended to five categories of 'human admixed embryos' containing human and animal cellular or genetic components, which were brought within the licensing regime of the HFE Act...
28 April 2008 - by Fiona Fox 
Should scientists enter the media fray on the most controversial aspects of stem cell research when the row is clearly about much more than the science? This is a question that many in the scientific community have raised over the past year in relation to the furore over human-animal hybrid...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.