Page URL:

Human rights court upholds Italy's prohibition on donating embryos to science

7 September 2015
Appeared in BioNews 818

The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) has ruled that Italy's prohibition on donating IVF embryos to science is not contrary to a right to private and family life.

Adelina Parrillo had sought to donate five embryos created for IVF treatment with her partner, who died in a bomb attack while reporting on the war in Iraq before any of the embryos were implanted. She had decided not to pursue a pregnancy and instead chose to donate the embryos to science to promote research into incurable diseases.

Italy prohibits research on human embryos, however, and Parrillo's requests for the embryos to be released were refused by the storage clinic. She sought to challenge this decision on the grounds that it violated her rights under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. 

The Grand Chamber of the ECtHR ruled that although Article 8 was applicable in this case – as Parrillo's embryos contained her DNA and therefore constituted part of her identity and 'private life' – Italy had a wide margin of appreciation on human embryo research, which was of a sensitive and controversial nature and one on which there is no European consensus.

Furthermore, as the case did not involve parenthood, the court said it did not concern a crucial aspect of Parrillo's existence and concluded that the ban was 'necessary in a democratic society'.

It also noted that there was no evidence that Parrillo's partner had consented to the embryos being released for research. By 16 to one it held there was no violation of Article 8.

Dissenting, Judge András Sajó said that given the clear choices made by the applicant, the judgment lacked a proportionality analysis and that a wide margin of appreciation did not permit a government to act arbitrarily.

'The applicant's interest in donating her embryos to scientific research, rather than allowing them to remain unused, is a deeply personal and moral decision. This choice is driven by her desire to honour her late partner and to further invaluable medical research with the potential to save lives,' he said.

'The law disregards the interest in preventing actual human suffering through scientific research in the name of the protection of a potential for life which, moreover, cannot ever materialise in the circumstances of the case.'

Other aspects of Italy's law on assisted conception have been struck down both by its national courts and by the ECtHR. In April, Italy's constitutional court declared a ban on using donated gametes in fertility treatment was unconstitutional (reported in BioNews 750) and in 2012 a ban on screening embryos using PGD for cystic fibrosis was held to be in violation of Article 8 by the ECtHR (reported in BioNews 671).

However, in 2011 the ECtHR held that Austria's ban on the use of donated gametes was not a violation of Article 8 (see BioNews 641).

ECtHR rejects Parrillo embryo appeal
Gazzetta del sud |  27 August 2015
Parrillo v Italy - 46470/11 - Grand Chamber Judgment [2015] ECHR 755 |  27 August 2015
Parrillo v. Italy (application no. 46470/11)
European Court of Human Rights |  27 August 2015
21 December 2015 - by Wendy Suffield 
At PET's recent conference, Professor Azim Surani claimed that permission to carry out experiments on embryos beyond the 14-day rule could make a huge difference to research. It may be time to review the ethical reasoning behind this time limit...
6 July 2015 - by Kirsty Oswald 
One of France's highest courts ruled on Friday that children born to surrogates abroad have the right to have their births and citizenship recognised by the state...
14 April 2014 - by Siobhan Chan 
Italy's constitutional court has lifted a ban on the use of donor sperm and eggs for assisted conception, saying it was 'unconstitutional'...
19 November 2012 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
A Romanian woman has argued, unsuccessfully, that a decision to relocate her stored embryos to another clinic, denying her a choice of a doctor, amounted to a breach of her private and family life with regard to her ability to have a child through IVF using those embryos...
23 January 2012 - by Professor Richard Storrow 
Procreative liberty and the right to legal recognition of parent-child relationships continue to be prominent themes in disputes between individual citizens and government over access to assisted reproduction. The judiciary has been largely reluctant to state whether resort to reproductive technology is a human right...
14 November 2011 - by Jessica Ware 
IVF using donated egg or sperm other than from a spouse will remain banned in Austria. This was the final decision made by the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights (the Court) on 3 November in the closing of the case SH and others v Austria....
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.