Page URL:

Australian couple denied IVF on child welfare grounds

24 August 2015
Appeared in BioNews 816

An Australian couple have been denied access to IVF after a court ruled it would not be in the best interests of the child.

The couple, known only as TRV and TPW, have 10 children between them but sought IVF following the death of their seven-week-old daughter from Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) in 2010. The couple, who plan to marry in December, wanted IVF before TRV turns 46 in September and becomes ineligible on age restrictions.

In Victoria, the Assisted Reproductive Treatment (ART) Act of 2008 dictates that all patients requesting any form of ART must undertake a Victorian Criminal (Police) Record Check and Child Protection Order (CPO) Check before starting treatment.

However, TRV previously had four of her children removed from her custody by the Department of Child Protection due to physical and psychological abuse, resulting in a 'presumption against treatment'. The couple had therefore been denied IVF by a patient review panel, prompting them to appeal to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT).

The VACT panel of three, led by Judge Pamela Jenkins, heard how there were substantial concerns specifically regarding TRV, including a history of physical and emotional abuse against her children, as well as medical and environmental neglect.

Clinical psychologist, Dr Georgina Swinburne, who assessed the couple, also concluded TRV was suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder following the death of her daughter. She added, that this grief could impact on a parent's capacity to 'bond with the future child and respond to their unique needs'.

When asked by the tribunal, TRV argued she didn't see any challenges arising from the birth of another child and that there was no conflict in her current relationship.

 While the VCAT panel took into account positive changes in TRV's life, including her relationship with TPW, they raised concerns about her lack of insight into the experiences of her children. They added she also refused to accept any responsibility for past harm experienced by her children, and showed an inability to acknowledge parenting challenges.

The panel therefore concluded: 'There are significant and continuing risks to the welfare and interests of a child to be born to the Applicants by means of ART and at this stage the Tribunal cannot be satisfied that it is in the best interests of a child to be born for such treatment procedure to be made available'.

The ruling does not prevent the couple attempting to conceive naturally.

Mother banned from IVF treatment after her horrific record of bad parenting - including saying her sons were 'dead to her' - is revealed
Mail Online |  17 August 2015
TRV v Department of Health and Human Services (Human Rights)
Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal |  5 August 2015
VCAT bans 'bad' mother from conceiving IVF baby because of poor parenting record
Herald Sun |  16 August 2015
Vic mother of six refused IVF treatment
Sky News Australia |  17 August 2015
Victorian couple denied IVF because of fears they would harm child
The Guardian |  17 August 2015
21 September 2020 - by Michelle de Souza 
Until recently, people seeking fertility treatment in the state of Victoria, Australia had to undergo criminal record and child protection checks. If a criminal record check revealed that the woman, or her partner (if applicable), had been convicted of a sexual or violent offence, or a child protection order had been made and a child had been removed from the care of the woman or her partner, a presumption against treatment was triggered...
8 June 2015 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
The Family Court has refused a man contact over a child raised in a complex set of family relations, to whom he has no biological connection or legal parenthood...
11 May 2015 - by Ana Ilic 
A legal battle over the custody of a baby girl born through a disputed surrogacy arrangement has resulted in an order to remove the child from her mother and place her into the care of her father and his partner....
11 August 2014 - by Sascha Callaghan and Ainsley Newson 
The story of the baby with Down's syndrome 'abandoned' in Thailand, which has dominated the news, illustrates how the international surrogacy industry has been booming...
3 February 2014 - by Chris Hardy 
Fertility experts have warned that IVF is overused and is too often recommended to couples who may not need it...
6 January 2014 - by Nishat Hyder 
The South Australian Supreme Court has granted a woman permission to use her deceased husband's sperm for IVF treatment....
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.