Page URL:

US court grants woman right to disputed frozen embryos

29 June 2015
Appeared in BioNews 808

An Illinois appeals court has reaffirmed a decision to grant a woman 'custody and control' of frozen embryos created with the sperm of her ex-boyfriend, despite his objections, giving her the right to use them to have children. 

The embryos were created five years ago when Karla Dunston and Jacob Szafranski - then a couple - agreed to create embryos for cryopreservation using Dunston's eggs and Szafranski's sperm. Dunston had been diagnosed with lymphoma, treatment for which often results in infertility.

As fewer eggs were retrieved than expected, their doctor recommended fertilising all eight eggs, rather than storing some of them unfertilised, which would have provided an option of using alternative sperm at a later date.

However, shortly after the procedure the relationship ended, and the couple disagreed on whether Dunston could use the embryos. Szafranski started legal proceedings to prevent the use of the embryos in 2011, but an Illinois county awarded Dunston sole custody and control because it found her interests in using the embryos outweighed Szafranski's objections to their use.

An appeal of the decision resulted in the appeals court sending the case back to the lower court, which again ruled in 2014 in favour of Dunston (reported in BioNews 724 and 755).

The most recent ruling from the Illinois Appellate Court upheld this decision, finding that there was a pre-existing oral agreement between the couple. Although a co-parenting agreement drafted at the time to clarify Szafranski's role was never signed, the court ruled that they had formed an oral contract. It also held that Dunston's interests prevailed, as the embryos are her only chance to have a biologically related child.

Delivering the judgment of the court, Justice Liu said: 'The sole purpose for using Jacob's sperm to fertilise Karla's last viable eggs was to preserve her ability to have a biological child in the future at some point after her chemotherapy treatment ended. The parties both recognised this when they agreed to create the pre-embryos together.'

A document signed at the clinic prior to creating the embryos stipulating that they could not be used without the consent of both partners was held to only prevent the fertility clinic taking action without both parties consent, and was not part of the contract between the couple.

Abram Moore, Dunston's lawyer, said that she was not seeking financial support from Szafranski.

'After winning a tough battle with cancer, these three embryos represent Dunston's last chance to have children that share her genetic material,' he said. 'Szafranski agreed to create these embryos for one purpose: so that Dunston could use them to attempt to have children if she survived cancer.'

Brian Schroeder, Szafranski's lawyer, told the New York Times, 'This case raises fundamental issues about the need to have both parties consent to the use of embryos to create human life.'

'No one should be forced into parenthood if that is not something they want. We believe consent should be required in order to procreate.'

The ruling could set a precedent for future legal disputes over the use of stored embryos in the USA. Szafranski will now seek to appeal the ruling at the Illinois Supreme Court.

Appellate Court Sides With Chicago Woman In Landmark Embryo Case
NBC News |  13 June 2015
Chicago Court Gives Woman Frozen Embryos Despite Ex-Boyfriend's Objections
New York Times |  12 June 2015
Court gives frozen embryos to Chicago woman over ex-boyfriend's objection
Chicago Tribune |  12 June 2015
In Battle Of The Exes, Appeals Court Sides With Woman Who Wants Frozen Embryos
CBS Chicago |  12 June 2015
Jacob Szafranski v. Karla Dunston
Illinois State Supreme Court (opinion) |  12 June 2015
14 March 2016 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
The US Supreme Court has declined to hear a man's appeal against a ruling that gave his ex-partner a right to use embryos the couple had created together...
23 November 2015 - by Dr Julia Hill 
A San Francisco judge has ruled that the frozen embryos of a divorced couple should be destroyed, despite the protests of the ex-wife...
10 August 2015 - by Dr Rosie Morley 
Adolescents or young adults with cancer may not be aware of available options to preserve their fertility, according to a study published in the journal Cancer...
22 June 2015 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
The High Court has ruled that a decision not to allow a mother to take her deceased daughter's eggs for fertility treatment overseas was lawful...
5 May 2015 - by Dr Victoria Burchell 
The ex-fiancé of Sofía Vergara, star of TV show Modern Family, is suing her for custody of their frozen embryos...
20 April 2015 - by Simon Hazelwood-Smith 
A baby boy has been born using sperm collected 48 hours after the fathers' death. The healthy child was conceived through IVF after a lengthy legal process in Australia, following the death of the father in a motorcycle accident in 2011....
28 May 2014 - by Patricia Cassidy 
An Illinois county court has granted a woman control over embryos created with her ex-boyfriend's sperm, despite his objection to their use....
30 September 2013 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
A woman in the USA is embroiled in a legal battle with her former partner over the use of cryopreserved embryos...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.