Page URL:

Canada sperm property case to settle for $6.2 million

1 June 2015
Appeared in BioNews 804

The University of British Columbia has proposed to settle a class action involving the accidental destruction of sperm for $6.2 million, reports The Province. The case represents the first time sperm has been recognised in law as property in the jurisdiction.

Around 400 men, mostly cancer patients, had deposited their sperm with the UBC's Andrology Lab before undergoing cancer treatment, which can affect fertility. However, in 2002 the freezer housing the sperm malfunctioned after a power interruption, and most of the sperm was damaged or destroyed. For some of the men it represented their last chance to have a genetically related child.

A class action against UBC and others was launched in 2003 in negligence and breach of contract. Lawyers for UBC tried to argue that under its contract with the men it was exempt from liability, but the claimants countered that this could not be relied on because of statutory provisions governing the storage of goods that rendered such exemptions unenforceable. The issue was whether frozen human sperm could be defined as 'property' under the statute.

On this point, the Court of Appeal of British Columbia in January decided in the claimants' favour, ruling that human sperm could be 'property' and therefore considered as goods under the statutory provisions.

Referring to a case against North Bristol NHS Trust in the UK in 2009, where the Court of Appeal said that sperm could be property for the purposes of claims brought by cancer patients after their sperm was accidentally destroyed in a storage malfunction, Justice Elizabeth Bennett held that the men in this case had also deposited their own sperm with the intention of future use by arrangement with the storage facility.

For these reasons, and because the men retained 'control' over the sperm - being able to terminate its storage or donate it to others - the sperm was regarded as their 'property'.

Commenting on the proposed settlement, which is yet to be approved by the state's Supreme Court later this month, Sandy Kovacs, a lawyer for the claimants, said: 'It provides fair compensation for men who have suffered the loss of ability to have children of their own.' 

A spokesperson for UBC said: 'The university recognises this was an unfortunate incident and we empathise greatly with the men and their families involved in this case.'

Sperm recognized as property in B.C. case; donors win $6.2M settlement
National Post |  20 May 2015
UBC, about 400 donors reach $6.2-million settlement over destroyed sperm
The Province |  19 May 2015
30 September 2016 - by Dr Linda Wijlaars 
Twelve families in South Australia have lost embryos after a power outage compromised the incubators that the embryos were being stored in...
27 July 2015 - by Arit Udoh 
Alibaba, the China-based e-commerce firm, has offered its male users up to £525 in exchange for their sperm...
18 May 2015 - by Dr Kamal Ahuja 
For the first time, a British sperm bank has sufficient stocks and donors to begin supplying clinics registered by the HFEA. The move marks a shift in the dynamics of UK sperm donation and would suggest that the perception of any shortage of donor sperm in Britain is no longer true...
27 April 2015 - by Ari Haque 
A man who provided sperm to a female friend who then used it to conceive without sexual intercourse has been awarded parental rights by the Virginia Court of Appeals in the USA...
27 January 2014 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
The Outer House of the Court of Session in Scotland has allowed a claim for compensation brought by a man whose sperm may have been damaged by a failure of a storage vessel to proceed to a full trial....
16 April 2012 - by Dr Daniel Grimes 
Italian Health Minister Renato Balduzzi has ordered an investigation of a fertility clinic at the San Filippo Neri hospital in Rome after a mechanical failure led to the destruction of 94 frozen embryos, 130 eggs, and five sperm samples....
28 November 2011 - by Julianna Photopoulos 
Another blunder at IVF Wales in Cardiff destroyed a batch of 'exceptional' eggs only hours after they were donated, leaving a couple devastated...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.