Page URL:

Baby born with genetic disease after embryo test 'mistakes'

12 January 2015
Appeared in BioNews 785

A baby has been born with a genetic condition after a laboratory used by a Nottingham fertility clinic reportedly made a mistake interpreting PGD results.

The parents were patients of CARE Fertility Nottingham and had opted to use PGD to screen for neurofibromatosis type 1, a genetic disorder that causes tumours to develop along nerves and can reduce life expectancy by up to 15 years. Around 50 percent of people with neurofibromatosis also have learning difficulties.

Minutes from the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA), which investigated the incident, outline how the couple had undergone a highly specialised type of PGD that is more technically demanding than normal PGD testing. However, a staff member at Genesis Genetics Europe (GGEu), the genetic lab used by CARE Fertility Nottingham, misinterpreted the results giving an incorrect diagnosis, resulting in an affected embryo being transferred to the woman.

The patient, whose healthy embryos were destroyed, was informed about the mistake after she became pregnant. The couple decided to continue with the pregnancy and the baby was born with the condition intended to be avoided in the first place. The HFEA's Licence Committee concluded that evidence confirmed earlier conclusions that misdiagnosis was the result of operator error and that corrective actions proposed by the laboratory would likely minimise the risk of it happening again.

In a separate incident involving another couple who were at one stage patients at the same clinic, a baby was born with sickle cell anaemia, a blood disorder that can lead to strokes, high blood pressure and breathing problems, despite having undergone screening for that condition.

The PGD screening for the disorder took place in 2008, but treatment resulted in an unsuccessful pregnancy and the remaining embryos were stored for future use. The mother became pregnant in 2012 following treatment at another clinic using one of the stored embryos, but a heel prick test done following the child's birth revealed sickle cell anaemia.

The HFEA explains that the incident may have occurred because of the type of testing available at the time being less robust than newer diagnostic tests, although it was not possible to confirm the original diagnosis.

'These two incidents are very serious and have no doubt been devastating for the couples involved,' a spokeswoman for the HFEA told the Daily Mail. 'They had treatment to have a healthy child but may now have children affected by a serious genetic condition,'

The incidents were highlighted in a recent HFEA report outlining a number of adverse incidents that have occurred across all UK fertility clinics (reported in BioNews 762). It has also grouped together other 'grade A' incidents at various clinics on its website.

In a statement made to BioNews, Professor Simon Fishel, managing director of CARE Fertility clinics, said: 'Although we are very upset that a misdiagnosis occurred, we have to recognise PGD is not totally risk-free, and patients are professionally and intensively counselled.'

'This [less than one percent risk of misdiagnosis] needs to be put in context of those families who have as high as a 50 percent risk of conceiving a child with the genetic disease [...] Couples are counselled and informed that the risk of having a child with an inherited condition is significantly reduced but not eliminated.' He adds, 'We believe it is positive medicine, albeit with still an attendant small risk.'

Both the incidents have since been reviewed and closed by the HFEA's Licence Committee, which is satisfied that 'the necessary corrective actions have been taken'. CARE Fertility Nottingham has also confirmed that it will continue to use the laboratory services provided by GGEu, which was inspected and approved by its accrediting body, the Clinical Pathology Accreditation. 

IVF mothers screened for disease gave birth to babies with genetic defects... after horror mix-up at fertility lab
MailOnline |  4 January 2014
Licence Committee Meeting - Minutes Item 7 (pdf)
Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority |  9 January 2014
Two couples left "distraught" after their babies are born with diseases due to mistakes in IVF treatment at Nottingham clinic
Nottingham Post |  5 January 2014
6 April 2020 - by Louisa Ghevaert 
A legal watershed occurred on 1 April 2020 when the UK Supreme Court handed down its judgment in the case of Whittington Hospital NHS Trust v XX. In doing so, it marked an important development and intersection of medical negligence, fertility and surrogacy law in the UK...
6 April 2020 - by Jen Willows 
A UK woman has won her case in the UK Supreme Court against an NHS hospital for the cost of surrogacy in California...
30 November 2015 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
A woman is suing a fertility clinic in Australia for failing to detect that she was a carrier of a genetic mutation during pre-pregnancy testing, after her sons were later born with an inherited condition....
21 September 2015 - by Dr Mary Yarwood 
The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority has released its second annual report into adverse incidents at fertility clinics in the UK, showing a slight reduction in the overall number of reported problems following fertility treatment...
6 July 2015 - by Kirsty Oswald 
In a national referendum, a majority of Swiss voters have supported allowing preimplantation genetic diagnosis to screen for genetic diseases...
14 July 2014 - by Chee Hoe Low 
Hundreds of adverse events occur in UK fertility clinics each year, according to a report from the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority...
1 November 2010 - by MacKenna Roberts 
The European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE) has published an updated set of best practice guidelines for fertility clinics on the use of preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) and preimplantation genetic screening (PGS) techniques...
13 September 2010 - by Rose Palmer 
A new technology used by Hull IVF unit to prevent clinical mix-ups when sperm and eggs are combined in the laboratory is to be rolled-out for use across the UK, and has been nominated for an award...
9 June 2008 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
A British couple has successfully used pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) funded by the NHS to create a baby free from neurofibromatosis type 1, a potentially serious genetic condition. This is reported to be the first time PGD has been used for this condition. The baby's father, Peter...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.