Examen
Page URL: https://www.bionews.org.uk/page_94513

High Court rules that widow can keep husband's sperm

10 March 2014
Appeared in BioNews 745

A widow has won a legal battle to keep her late husband's sperm preserved for future use.

Mr Warren Brewer had stored his sperm in 2005 before receiving radiotherapy treatment for cancer. Although he had consented to his wife, Mrs Elizabeth Warren, using his stored sperm in IVF treatment if he died and to being named as any resulting child's legal father, he did not specify to his sperm being stored beyond the ten-year statutory period as required by the law.

The applicable Regulations state that a provider of gametes must give written consent to storage beyond ten years, up to a statutory limit of 55 years. A medical practitioner must also certify that the donor 'is... or is likely to become prematurely infertile' every ten years. Interpreted strictly, this means that such a certificate could only be provided in a man's lifetime and could not be renewed after his death.

For Mr Brewer, the statutory storage period was due to expire in April 2015. To become pregnant, Mrs Warren would need to commence treatment in early 2014 but she told the court how she was not yet ready to have children.

Mrs Warren sought to persuade the judge to make a declaration that it would be lawful for the sperm to be stored beyond April 2015 for up to 55 years (reported in BioNews 734). The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) argued that the Regulations and the safeguards provided by them should not be 'diluted', however.

Mrs Justice Hogg ruled in favour of Mrs Warren, saying that a strict interpretation of the relevant Regulations could produce a 'very restrictive outcome' when Mr Brewer's wishes and his intention to give consent was clear. 'Both Mr Brewer and his wife were in agreement. He wanted her to have the opportunity to have his child, if she wanted, after his death', the judge said.

She found that Care Fertility (Northampton) Ltd, the clinic that preserved Mr Brewer's sperm, did not give Mr Brewer enough information, depriving his opportunity to give consent to storage beyond ten years and that this produced 'a great and conspicuous unfairness'.

Mrs Justice Hogg went on to say that the State should not interfere in Mrs Warren's right to make decision as to her future family life protected by Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. She said that there was no conflict of individuals' right in the dispute and that overriding the Regulations would not 'involve large numbers of the population'.

'I must interpret the statutory provisions in a purposive way and if possible interpret those provisions in a way which is compatible with Mrs Warren's Convention right under Article 8 to decide to seek to become a parent by her deceased husband', the judge said. In particular, she said that the Regulations be interpreted to include the words 'was, or may have been likely to become prematurely infertile'.

Mrs Justice Hogg concluded that it was 'right and proper, and proportionate'  to declare that Mr Brewer's sperm could be stored up until April 2023, and subsequently up until April 2060 if proper medical opinion that proves Mr Brewer's infertility in life could be obtained.

Speaking to the press outside the courtroom, Mrs Warren said she was 'over the moon' and that the judgment means everything to her.

'Warren was my life. I know we didn't get that life we wanted, so we made this plan. Now I feel I can just move on in my life, with what I want to do, with this chance Warren left me'.

The HFEA is also seeking permission to appeal and says it will consider the implications of the judgment before it decides whether to pursue an appeal.

In a statement, it said: 'We had hoped that the court could find a way for Mrs Warren to store the sperm for longer without having wider implications for the existing consent regime.

However, because the judgment acknowledges that written consent to store the sperm beyond April 2015 is not in place, the judgment may have implications for other cases in which the sperm provider's wishes are less clear'.

SOURCES & REFERENCES
Beth Warren waits on sperm legal fight result
BBC News |  6 March 2014
Warren v Care Fertility (Northampton) Ltd & Anor [2014] EWHC 602 (Fam) (
Bailii.org |  6 March 2014
Widow wins frozen sperm legal fight
BBC News |  6 March 2014
Widow wins high court fight to preserve dead husband's sperm
The Guardian |  6 March 2014
Widow wins High Court legal battle to store her husband's sperm
The Independent |  6 March 2014
RELATED ARTICLES FROM THE BIONEWS ARCHIVE
20 June 2016 - by Chee Hoe Low 
The parents of a dead Australian man whose sperm has been cryopreserved have said that they will block any attempts by his fiancée to use his sperm in an IVF attempt...
29 February 2016 - by Antony Blackburn-Starza 
A woman who is in a legal bid to use her deceased daughter's eggs has been given permission to take her case to the Court of Appeal...
5 May 2015 - by Dr Victoria Burchell 
The ex-fiancé of Sofía Vergara, star of TV show Modern Family, is suing her for custody of their frozen embryos...
23 March 2015 - by Marisa Allman 
The recent case of X v Y v CRM highlights the potential legal difficulties for children born via assisted conception of clinic error. A recent audit by the HFEA discovered that 50 out of 75 clinics nationwide reported anomalies in respect of the signing or keeping of forms for legal parenthood...
28 May 2014 - by Patricia Cassidy 
An Illinois county court has granted a woman control over embryos created with her ex-boyfriend's sperm, despite his objection to their use....
9 December 2013 - by María Victoria Rivas Llanos 
A woman is seeking an extension in the storage of her late husband's sperm at the UK's High Court...
7 January 2013 - by Jessica Ware 
A Western Australian judge has granted a newly widowed woman the right to retrieve sperm from her dead husband, although a further court order will be required before it can be used for any purpose....
12 November 2012 - by Ayesha Ahmad 
A recent battle by the parents of a teenager who was critically injured in a car accident to obtain and store his sperm for future use has ended following his death last week...
31 May 2011 - by MacKenna Roberts 
A widow has been granted possession of her late husband's sperm in an 'exceptional' Australian court ruling last week...
HAVE YOUR SAY
Log in to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions


Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.