Page URL:

Out-of-court settlement for girl conceived with abnormal donor sperm

3 February 2014
Appeared in BioNews 740

A London fertility clinic has settled a claim over a 4-year-old girl who was born with a genetic defect after a mix-up in the sperm used in her conception.

In 2009, the girl's mother, ARL, underwent IVF at the London Women's Clinic using donated sperm and gave birth to a girl in October of that year. During her pregnancy, the woman was told that a scan had showed a rare genetic defect in the fetus, which she later claimed was due to a mix-up of the sperm being used. The woman's solicitors said that clinic had used sperm during the IVF treatment that had been initially screened and noted to be abnormal, but was labelled as normal.

The genetic defect, called balanced reciprocal chromosomal translocation, is rare and leads to a higher chance of a miscarriage and of giving birth to a disabled child. When choosing to start a family of her own, ARL's daughter will most likely be require to undergo IVF and the use of assisted reproductive technologies to screen out the abnormalities.

Nico Fabri, solicitors for the London Women's Clinic, admitted to a breach in duty and apologised to ARL. An undisclosed out-of-court settlement was reached between the clinic and ARL, which was approved by a judge in the London High Court. The settlement is to help compensate ARL's daughter for the fertility challenges she will face in her future, her solicitors said.

Speaking after the settlement, ARL said: 'Choosing to undergo IVF with an anonymous sperm donor was not a decision I made lightly, but I believed the London Women's Clinic was one of the leading fertility centres in the country and I spent £30,000 with the clinic expecting a high-level service'.

'I'm left worrying about what the future holds for my daughter and the problems she may face in later life. Every parent wishes the best for their child but knowing that she may face such heartache and agonising decisions is incredibly difficult to live with and the source of much anguish', she added.

Matthew Waite, of law firm Irwin Mitchell and who acted for the woman, said: 'This is a shocking case that begs the questions, how on earth was it possible for this mix-up to happen and could it have happened more than once'?

'Whilst we welcome the settlement from the clinic, we would like to know what systems failed to allow the mix-up to happen – why was the abnormal donor sperm not destroyed, could it have happened more than once and what action has been taken to ensure the same mistake can never be made again?', the statement said.

Girl awarded £35,000 after sperm donor mix-up
ITV |  27 January 2014
London Women’s Clinic Gives Mum Abnormal Donor Sperm In ‘Shocking’ Label Mix-Up
Irwin Mitchell (press release) |  27 January 2014
Sperm donor mix-up girl awarded £35k in damages
BBC News |  27 January 2014
10 November 2014 - by Jenny Sharpe 
An Australian woman has become engaged to the sperm donor who fathered her one-year-old daughter...
14 July 2014 - by Chee Hoe Low 
Hundreds of adverse events occur in UK fertility clinics each year, according to a report from the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority...
6 January 2014 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
The High Court of Australia has awarded damages under contract law to a doctor who purchased assets of a fertility clinic, including a stock of cryopreserved sperm, after almost two thirds of straws provided were unusable...
12 November 2012 - by Nishat Hyder 
The parents of a child with serious disabilities caused by an inherited rare genetic condition who died shortly after birth are suing St George's Hospital, London for failing to test for and identify the condition before birth....
3 September 2012 - by Rosie Beauchamp 
Italy has violated the rights of a couple carrying cystic fibrosis by preventing them from screening embryos using PGD, the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) has ruled. The Strasbourg-based court ordered the Italian government to pay the couple 17,500 euros in damages and expenses....
31 October 2011 - by Dr Lux Fatimathas 
Increasing numbers of Israeli children with birth defects are suing medical professionals for failing to detect abnormalities and allowing them to be born, says the New Scientist. The magazine reports that such is the Israeli Government's concern over the rise in 'wrongful life' lawsuits it has launched an investigation into the validity of the claims....
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.