Call for papers - Reproduction, Technology and Society, a new section in Reproductive BioMedicine Online
Page URL: https://www.bionews.org.uk/page_94315

Illinois courts consider embryo dispute

30 September 2013
Appeared in BioNews 724

A woman in the USA is embroiled in a legal battle with her former partner over the use of cryopreserved embryos.

Karla Dunston was diagnosed with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma in 2012. After she was informed that her chemotherapy treatment would likely result in a loss of fertility, Dunston decided to store embryos created using her own eggs and the sperm of her partner at the time, Jacob Szafranski, at Northwestern Hospital in Chicago. Dunston then later lost the ability to have her own biological children after the cancer treatment.

The couple signed an informed consent document that stated the embryos would not be used without the consent of both parties, but that in the event of the relationship breaking down the rights to the embryos would be a matter for settlement.  A co-parenting agreement that stipulated control over the embryos would reside with Dunston upon separation was never signed by the couple.

When the relationship broke down, Szafranski sought to enforce his rights over the embryos to prevent their use. In response, Dunston claimed sole custody and control over the embryos.

In September 2012, a circuit court gave judgment in Dunston's favour and ordered that she should have full custody and control of the embryos. However, Szafranski appealed, claiming that his rights of privacy and liberty under the US and Illinois constitutions required his consent to the use of the embryos.

The Illinois appellate court said the proper test to apply in a situation such as this was a contractual one – an approach which had already been endorsed in other US states.

'We believe that honouring the parties' agreements properly allows them, rather than the courts, to make their own reproductive choices while also provided a measure of certainty necessary to protect family planning', explained Justice Quinn. The judge also said that such agreements will 'promote serious discussions' between couples prior to undergoing IVF and embryo cryopreservation.

In the absence of such an agreement, then the relative interests of the parties must be weighted. It was not an 'ideal way' to resolve the dispute, Justice Quinn said, but it was preferable to giving an 'antagonised ex-spouse' the power to block the other's parentage.

However, Justice Quinn highlighted that no US court that had endorsed a balancing exercise had awarded one party the right to implant an embryo in face of an agreement that required both parties' consent.

The court decided to vacate the lower court's judgment and ordered it to reconsider the case to determine if Dunston and Szafranski had reached an agreement on the use of the embryos.

SOURCES & REFERENCES
Contract Law to Govern Cryopreserved Embryos' Fate
SmithAmundsen |  12 July 2020
Doctor, 42, who froze embryos with boyfriend after she was diagnosed with cancer battles him in court after he dumps her and says he no longer wants children
Mail Online |  18 September 2013
Szafranski v. Dunston , 2013 IL App (1st) 122975
Illinois Official Reports |  12 July 2020
RELATED ARTICLES FROM THE BIONEWS ARCHIVE
14 March 2016 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
The US Supreme Court has declined to hear a man's appeal against a ruling that gave his ex-partner a right to use embryos the couple had created together...
23 November 2015 - by Dr Julia Hill 
A San Francisco judge has ruled that the frozen embryos of a divorced couple should be destroyed, despite the protests of the ex-wife...
29 June 2015 - by Dr Julia Hill 
An Illinois appeals court has reaffirmed a decision to grant a woman 'custody and control' of frozen embryos created with the sperm of her ex-boyfriend, despite his objections...
5 May 2015 - by Dr Victoria Burchell 
The ex-fiancé of Sofía Vergara, star of TV show Modern Family, is suing her for custody of their frozen embryos...
16 February 2015 - by Chee Hoe Low 
A same-sex couple from New Jersey, USA, is challenging a sperm donor's visiting rights over their son conceived by artificial insemination...
17 May 2010 - by Peter D Sozou, Geraldine M Hartshorne and Sally Sheldon 
Embryos created by IVF can be cryopreserved (stored) for possible future use. All couples who have embryos stored in the UK are currently bound by law to a single form of agreement, allowing each genetic parent to withdraw consent at any time before the embryo is transferred. This article makes the case for allowing an alternative consent agreement...
17 May 2010 - by Dr Anna Smajdor 
When Natallie Evans lost her case to prevent the destruction of her embryos in 2007, many people were moved by her plight. The letter of the law had been followed, but with tragic consequences for her...
22 November 2006 - by Dr Jess Buxton 
The UK woman fighting to use stored frozen embryos created using her former partner's sperm made a final appeal last week, to the Grand Chamber of the European Court. Natallie Evans started fertility treatment with Howard Johnston in 2001, but he withdrew his consent for the...
7 March 2006 - by BioNews 
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has issued its judgment in the case of Evans v the United Kingdom. Natallie Evans, a British woman seeking the right to be able to use her own frozen IVF embryos, asked the court last September to rule whether UK law preventing her...
HAVE YOUR SAY
Log in to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions


Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.