The Fertility Show, Manchester Central, 24-25 March 2018
Page URL:

Indian surrogate mothers underpaid, unprotected in an unregulated industry

29 July 2013
Appeared in BioNews 715

Indian surrogate mothers are frequently underpaid and insufficiently cared for, a report from an Indian charity claims. The Centre for Social Research (CSR) in New Delhi says there is little protection for surrogates in a growing industry without an adequate legal framework.

'Due to the commercialisation of surrogacy, the plight of the surrogate mother and the unborn child is often ignored', said Ranjana Kumari, the director of the CSR. 'There is a need for a concrete legal framework to monitor and regulate the existing surrogacy system to safeguard the interests of surrogate mother and the child'.

The CSR, supported by the Ministry of Women and Child Development, conducted a survey of 150 surrogate mothers and 50 commissioning parents in Delhi and Mumbai. It found that most of the surrogates surveyed were only paid one to two percent of the fee that commissioning parents usually pay for a child. In Delhi, only 26 percent of surrogates said they earned more than four lakh rupees (around £4,400). Commissioning parents - the majority of whom were from the USA or European countries, the study found - can expect to pay around 40 to 45 lakh rupees (£44,000 - £50,000) for surrogacy arrangements. The rest of the fee is usually kept by the agents who arrange surrogacy transactions, the CSR says.

The study showed the surrogates were mostly between 26 and 30 years old, married and educated up to primary level. Surrogates who were employed (68 percent in Delhi and 78 percent in Mumbai) mainly worked as housemaids or in domestic roles. Poverty and education of their children were given as reasons for entering into surrogacy arrangements and the majority had not experienced surrogacy before.

The study also found that surrogates were often poorly informed. Surrogacy agencies were the main source of information for surrogates, who were often not provided with a copy of the written contract. In cases where the intended parents did not wish to continue the pregnancy because of fetal abnormalities or sex preference, the fetus was aborted often without consulting the surrogate, the report says.

The practice of repeat IVF sessions was also commonplace. While the Indian Council of Medical Research, which publishes guidelines to fertility clinics in India, recommends that a maximum of three sessions take place, the 'vulnerable position' of the women involved means that this guideline is 'easily violated', the report claimed.

The study also highlighted the practice of 'twibling' - using more than one surrogate mother at a time for the same commissioning parents - to increase success rates. This often happens without the surrogate's knowledge, the CSR claims. 'In the case of unhealthy pregnancies, abortion pills are given by the doctor to terminate the pregnancy and the surrogate simply thinks that she had a spontaneous abortion', said Kumari.

The surrogacy industry in India is worth an estimated US$2.3 billion. Yet despite the scale of the industry, which is largely being fuelled by foreign demand including from the UK, the area remains unregulated. 'Despite the fact that India is becoming a hub for surrogacy, we don't even know if it is legal or illegal because there is no law', Kumari said.

The CSR says that the proposed regulation of surrogacy under the Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Regulation Bill 2010, not yet passed into Indian law, does not go far enough to safeguard the rights of the surrogate and is mainly concerned with the role of clinics and the protection of commissioning parents.

Not enough safeguards for surrogate mother, child, says study
The Hindu |  17 July 2013
Surrogacy Motherhood: Ethical or Commercial?
Centre for Social Research (press release) |  18 July 2013
Surrogate mothers underpaid, uncared for
Times of India |  20 July 2013
Unregulated surrogacy industry worth over $2bn thrives without legal framework
Times of India |  18 July 2013
23 June 2014 - by Dr Molly Godfrey 
A woman has been jailed for fraud after cheating couples out of thousands of pounds by pretending to act as a surrogate mother for them...
17 February 2014 - by Professor Eric Blyth, Dr Marilyn Crawshaw and Professor Olga van den Akker 
As the surrogacy industry grows, so too do calls from parts of the consumer lobby, fertility industry and others for a loosening of international and domestic restraints on surrogacy arrangements...
16 December 2013 - by María Victoria Rivas Llanos 
The Israeli Health Minister, Yael German, has announced the introduction of a new measure to allow unmarried and homosexual men and women access to surrogacy services in the country...
4 November 2013 - by Rebecca Carr 
A recent order from the Indian Ministry of Home Affairs has stipulated that foreign nationals seeking to enter India for the purposes of commissioning Indian surrogacy services must now apply for a medical visa to do so....
7 October 2013 - by Dr Kirsty Horsey 
I'm not sure how a television documentary manages to be saddening, heartwarming, uplifting and worrying all at the same time. BBC Four's House of Surrogates, which focused on one provider of paid-for surrogacy in India, where all the women acting as surrogates for one Gujarati clinic spent 'their pregnancy away from home in dorms', managed it...
30 September 2013 - by Dr Amel Alghrani and Dr Danielle Griffiths 
Surrogacy law is a mess and no longer fit for practice. As increasing numbers resort to the use of international surrogates or the 'murky waters' of the World Wide Web to find a surrogate, the law is relegated to cleaning up the aftermath...
5 August 2013 - by Susan Imrie and Vasanti Jadva 
The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority intends to update its guidance on surrogacy for clinics, and while we welcome this clarification, it is also important to consider how surrogates feel the law shapes their experiences...
21 January 2013 - by Nishat Hyder 
The Indian Home Ministry has issued strict visa guidelines making it more difficult for commissioning parents to obtain visas for entry to India for surrogacy arrangements...
6 June 2012 - by Natalie Gamble 
Indian surrogacy is a hot media topic, with several stories over the past week about couples being stuck in India waiting for British passports for their biological children. As far as we are concerned, this isn't really news – it is the shared experience of every British parent who has had a child through surrogacy in India, and something we deal with on a daily basis....
4 July 2011 - by Professor Anne Kerr 
Zippi Brand Frank's documentary 'Google Baby' gives us a fascinating insight into the global business of making babies. The programme follows an Israeli business man as he recruits commissioning parents via the internet, US brokers and egg donors, Indian assisted conception clinics and gestational surrogates ....
14 March 2011 - by Rachel Lloyd 
The feature-length documentary 'Made in India' tackles cross-border surrogacy head-on by going beyond the sensational headlines to uncover for the first time the personal lives and choices of the surrogates and infertile people involved. The film follows an American couple, Lisa and Brian Switzer, on their quest to have a baby...
Log in to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.