Page URL:

DNA ancestry tests not to be trusted, say experts

11 March 2013
Appeared in BioNews 696

Commercial DNA tests claiming to reveal people's ancestors are little better than 'genetic astrology', according to scientists.

From a sample of DNA, genetic testing companies report on a person's possible links to famous historical figures or groups such as the Vikings. A public guide produced this month by campaign group Sense About Science says DNA cannot be read 'like a book or a map of a journey'.

'Ancestry is complicated and very messy. Genetics is even messier', said Mark Thomas, professor of evolutionary genetics at University College London (UCL), UK and co-author of the guide. 'The idea that we can read our ancestry directly from our genes is absurd'.

Every gene in the human body has its own history. Genetic ancestry companies cannot tease the various possible histories apart without statistical tests. Researchers therefore produce genetic histories on a general, population level and it is not possible to determine an individual's history accurately.

'With every generation you (nearly) double your number of ancestors because every individual has two parents. [...] We don't have to look back very far in time before we each have more ancestors than we have sections of DNA, and this means we have ancestors from whom we have inherited no DNA', states the Sense About Science guide.

Mathematical models suggest the most recent ancestor of all people alive today lived an estimated 3,500 years ago. Professor David Balding, also of UCL and co-author of the guide, said: 'Genetic relatedness isn't very meaningful beyond a handful of generations away'. 

Steve Jones, emeritus professor of genetics at UCL who was not involved in writing the guide, added: 'On a long trudge through history [...] very soon everyone runs out of ancestors and has to share them. As a result, almost every Briton is a descendant of Viking hordes, Roman legions, African migrants, Indian Brahmins, or anyone else they fancy'.

Recently, a Hungarian company attracted widespread condemnation for using genetic tests to characterise a politician's 'racial purity' (see BioNews 661).

David Nicholson, director of genetic testing company DNA Worldwide, told the BBC: 'DNA cannot tell you that your ancestors were Viking, simply that your ancestry came from a part of the world common to the Vikings based on historic facts. It's important to talk to the company who provide the testing to make sure your expectations are realistic'.

Expensive tests claiming to trace person's ancestry are as dubious as astrology, warn scientists
Mail Online |  7 March 2013
Sense About Genetic Ancestry Testing
Sense About Science |  7 March 2013
Some DNA ancestry services akin to 'genetic astrology'
BBC News |  7 March 2013
We are all 'related' to Romans, Vikings, Egyptians and Attila the Hun
Sense About Science (press release) |  7 March 2013
16 September 2019 - by Dr Maria Botcharova 
Seventeen former employees of a genetic testing company, Orig3n, have accused it of not meeting scientific standards and returning inaccurate results...
9 July 2018 - by Dr Melanie Krause 
Over 2500 migrant children, who were separated from their parents at the US-Mexican border, will be genetically tested to reunite them with their families...
8 June 2015 - by Matthew Thomas 
'Genetics is messy and history is foggy. We are a species that is mobile and horny.' That is how Adam Rutherford quite accurately sums up the quest for understanding the human story in his documentary...
12 May 2014 - by Matthew Thomas 
Is it possible to trace your DNA back through time, up to a millennium ago, to find a single home from which your ancestors came?...
6 May 2014 - by Matthew Thomas 
Geneticists claim to have developed a way of finding where in the world a person's DNA originated...
4 March 2013 - by Reuben Harwood 
If asked to describe Eddie Izzard, your reply may include the words actor, comedian, transvestite and marathon runner. Well, now you can add 'part Neanderthal' to the list...
18 June 2012 - by Ruth Retassie 
Hungary's Medical Research Council has begun investigations into a company that provided a politician with a certificate characterising his 'racial purity'...
8 May 2012 - by Sarah Norcross and Sandy Starr 
The conference 'Genomics in Society: Facts, Fictions and Cultures' marked the 10th anniversary of the Economic and Social Research Council's Genomics Network, and also the passing of nearly ten years since the completion of the Human Genome Project...
2 April 2012 - by Ruth Saunders 
Last week the Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology (POST) released a POST Note - a guide for MPs and other parliamentarians on science and technology issues - on consumer genetic testing...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.