Page URL:

Dumbing down: mutations make modern man mindless, says academic

19 November 2012
Appeared in BioNews 682

Mutations in thousands of genes that govern our intelligence are contributing to a 'dumbing down' of humanity, as claimed in a controversial new theory. It is argued that the development of civilisation has eliminated the natural selection that would have prevented these intellectually harmful mutations from being passed down through the generations.

'I would wager that if an average citizen from Athens of 1,000 BC were to appear suddenly among us, he or she would be among the brightest and more intellectually alive of our colleagues and companions, with a good memory, a broad range of ideas, and a clear-sighted view of important issues' said study author Professor Gerald Crabtree, developmental biologist at Stanford University.

Professor Crabtree's theory is derived from calculations on how often harmful genetic mutations occur and his estimation that as many as 2,000 to 5,000 genes contribute to our intellectual and emotional abilities. The theory estimates all humans have undergone at least two mutations that are harmful to our intellectual or emotional abilities in the last 3,000 years. In the past, when humans were still hunter-gatherers, Professor Crabtree posits that such a mutation could have been fatal.

'A hunter-gatherer who did not correctly conceive a solution to providing food or shelter probably died, along with his or her progeny, whereas a modern Wall Street executive that made a similar conceptual mistake would receive a substantial bonus and be a more attractive mate. Clearly, extreme selection is a thing of the past'.

Not everyone is convinced by this theory, however. Professor Robin Dunbar, an anthropologist at the University of Oxford told the Daily Telegraph that 'in reality what has driven human and primate brain evolution is the complexity of our social world [and] that complex world is not going to go away. Doing things like deciding who to have as a mate or how best to rear your children will be with us forever'.

Professor Steve Jones, a geneticist at University College London, also pointed out to The Independent that the article is based on educated guesswork. 'Never mind the hypothesis, give me the data, and there aren't any. I could just as well argue that mutations have reduced our aggression, our depression and our penis length, but no journal would publish that. Why do they publish this?'.

Professor Crabtree asserts that by the time these mutations arise scientific methods will have been developed to counteract their harmful effects.

'I think we will know each of the millions of human mutations that can compromise our intellectual function and how each of these mutations interact with each other and other processes as well as environmental influences. At that time, we may be able to magically correct any mutation that has occurred in all cells of any organism at any developmental stage'.

The study was published in the journal Trends in Genetics.

Are we getting more stupid? Researchers claim our intelligence is diminishing as we no longer need it to survive
Mail Online |  12 November 2012
Civilisation is making humanity less intelligent, study claims
Daily Telegraph |  12 November 2012
Human Beings Are Getting Dumber, Says Study
Time |  15 November 2012
Human intelligence 'peaked thousands of years ago and we've been on an intellectual and emotional decline ever since'
Independent |  12 November 2012
Our fragile intellect. Part I
Trends in Genetics |  13 November 2012
Research suggests that humans are slowly but surely losing intellectual and emotional abilities
EurekAlert! (press release) |  12 November 2012
31 March 2014 - by Dr Linda Wijlaars 
Children with a common gene variant and lower thyroid hormone levels are four times more likely to have a low IQ, researchers have discovered...
22 July 2013 - by Simon Hazelwood-Smith 
Perhaps we are not so different from chimps? Not so, Professor Roberts says; it is us who are experimenting on them, putting them in enclosures and making TV programmes about them...
17 June 2013 - by Dr Lucy Spain 
Men's preference for younger partners has led to the development of the menopause in women, according to a recently published theory in PLOS Computational Biology....
23 April 2012 - by Helen Brooks 
Two genes that influence brain size, and accordingly intelligence and possibly susceptibility to Alzheimer's disease, have been discovered by scientists...
23 January 2012 - by Dr Kimberley Bryon-Dodd 
What does it mean to be human in an increasingly technology-driven world? This is the question that Steve Fuller, a philosopher turned sociology professor, discusses in his latest book Humanity 2.0...
15 August 2011 - by Dr Zara Mahmoud 
Educational toys, brainy baby videos and flash cards – do these things help to develop intelligence? Or are the genes that you inherited from your parents the determining factor? The search for an 'intelligence gene' has intrigued scientists for decades. Now, an international team of scientists have added weight to the argument that intelligence does have a genetic basis, but that it comes from multiple genes working together...
17 May 2009 - by Dr Rebecca Robey 
Chris Woodhead, the former UK Chief Inspector of Schools, has caused controversy by suggesting that middle-class children have 'better' genes when it comes to intellect and so will inevitably do better in school than children from lower socio-economic backgrounds. Speaking in an interview with the Guardian newspaper...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.