Page URL:

Controversial publication of bird flu studies reveal virus' potential

25 June 2012
Appeared in BioNews 662

Controversial research showing how the H5N1 'bird flu' virus can be altered to make it transmissible between mammals through the air has been published, nine months after it was first presented at a conference.

Two different research teams have identified a number of mutations that are required to change the H5N1 virus strain found in nature into one that can be transmitted airborne between mammals. These mutations, which alter the physical traits of the H5N1 virus, could potentially cause a deadly flu pandemic.

One team, led by Professor Ron Fouchier from the Erasmus Medical Centre in the Netherlands, artificially engineered the virus to be able to infect the upper airways of ferrets. They then allowed the virus to undergo its natural life cycle before artificially transferring it to another ferret. After several transfers the virus evolved the ability to be transmitted between ferrets through coughs and sneezes. The second team, led by Professor Yoshihiro Kawaoka at the University of Wisconsin-Madison in the USA, combined the H5N1 virus with the highly transmissible H1N1 flu strain to produce a similar result.

Identification of these traits is useful, as scientists can now look out for them arising in the wild H5N1 virus. 'Now we know what changes in the behaviour of the virus can make it transmissible, we can watch for any mutations with those effects - not just our particular ones', says Professor Fouchier. 'In principle, H5N1 can become airborne. The critical question is whether it will'.

Another research group, led by Professor Derek Smith at the University of Cambridge, has sought to answer this question. The researchers sequenced a large number of wild H5N1 genomes and found that many were only two to four mutations away from the ones identified by Professors Fouchier and Kawaoka. However it is still not known whether different combinations of mutations will result in airborne H5N1. If it were likely for H5N1 naturally acquire the traits to become airborne, it would have done so already, commentators point out.

Fears that the research could have negative consequences, either through insufficient containment allowing the virus to escape from the laboratory, or use of the knowledge to produce a bioterrorist weapon, had led the US Government's National Science Advisory Board for Biosecurity to block publication of the results. However scientists have successfully argued the benefit of publication outweighed this. Disclosure of the research would aid development of a vaccine and public health strategies to prevent spread of a transmissible H5N1 virus, they said.

Scientists are keen to carry out further work looking into how deadly the transmissible virus might be, with the results in ferrets suggesting reduction in deadliness when the virus became transmissible. However there is now a moratorium on research into boosting H5N1 virulence and transmission, and this could spark a wider debate on policy towards 'dual-use research' that can have both positive and negative consequences.

Bird flu 'could mutate to cause deadly human pandemic'
BBC |  21 June 2012
H5N1: Bird Flu Pandemic May Be Closer than Thought, Study Finds  
Time Healthland |  21 June 2012
H5N1 Special
Science |  21 June 2012
Influenza: Five questions on H5N1
Nature |  21 June 2012
New Bird-Flu Study Shows Virus's Pandemic Potential
Wall Street Journal |  21 June 2012
Publication of flu study reveals full nature of threat
New Scientist |  21 June 2012
Study shows how easily pandemic H5N1 bird flu could evolve
Guardian |  21 June 2012
19 June 2017 - by Dr Helen Robertson 
Scientists have identified three potential genetic mutations that could allow a dangerous strain of avian influenza to spread between humans...
23 March 2015 - by Fiona Ibanichuka 
A dispute has arisen between US scientists and Indian health officials over the virulence of the H1N1 swine flu virus...
23 September 2013 - by Lanay Tierney 
Middle East Respiratory Syndrome, a potentially lethal respiratory virus first identified last year in Saudi Arabia, may be transmitted by jumping repeatedly from animals to humans, DNA sequencing suggests...
12 August 2013 - by Lanay Tierney 
Two scientists behind a controversial H5N1 avian flu publication last year, which deliberately modified the virus to become more transmissible to humans, hope to perform similar experiments on a new flu strain...
3 June 2013 - by Dr Anna Cauldwell 
A gene therapy technique can protect mammals from lethal strains of influenza, according to US researchers...
15 May 2012 - by Dr Daniel Grimes 
Watching Stephen Sackur interview renowned scientist Sir John Sulston on HARDtalk, it comes as a surprise to discover that Sulston's current interests lie in human population control. This from the scientist whose pioneering work on the basic cell biology of the nematode worm led him to Stockholm in 2002, where he was jointly awarded the Nobel Prize....
8 May 2012 - by Sarah Norcross and Sandy Starr 
The conference 'Genomics in Society: Facts, Fictions and Cultures' marked the 10th anniversary of the Economic and Social Research Council's Genomics Network, and also the passing of nearly ten years since the completion of the Human Genome Project...
2 April 2012 - by Dr Nadeem Shaikh 
Differences in the severity of people's flu symptoms may be due to a genetic variant, according to scientists...
20 February 2012 - by Oliver Timmis 
What time of day it is could influence whether or not we get an infection. A protein known to be involved in the immune system may be influenced by the body's circadian rhythm, according to researchers at Yale University...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.