Reproduction and Fertility is an open-access, peer-reviewed journal
Page URL:

HFEA publishes long-awaited review of Taranissi affair

19 September 2011
Appeared in BioNews 625

The UK's fertility regulator, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA), has published a long-awaited review of its conduct in relation to IVF specialist Mohamed Taranissi and related legal proceedings.

In June 2009, the HFEA's chief executive Alan Doran asked its director of strategy and information Peter Thompson 'to review the adequacy of the Authority's revised governance arrangements in relation to the threshold between administrative enforcement of our powers and the sphere of criminal law'. Given that the Taranissi affair was widely thought to have reflected badly on the HFEA, and given subsequent changes in the governance of the HFEA, Doran wished to establish whether 'the changes we have made would be sufficient in the (admittedly rare) eventuality that similar decisions needed to be made in future'. Thompson's report, 'Doing the Right Things the Right Way: A Review of Governance at the HFEA', was finally presented to the HFEA on 14 September 2011 and has been published on the HFEA website.

The review presents five recommendations to the HFEA, in order to address outstanding areas of concern. These recommendations are: 'bespoke legal training focusing on the limitations of the powers to revoke, vary or suspend a licence'; 'criteria on the issues to take into account when deciding to seek a warrant'; 'a memorandum of understanding with the Association of Chief Police Officers setting out the respective roles of the Authority and the police'; 'a new standard operating procedure for media handling'; and new 'guidance on information access, to address the interplay between formal statutory access regimes and media enquiries'.

The review also examines the events surrounding the HFEA's dealings with Taranissi. Thompson neither endorses nor questions any previous findings of HFEA Licence Committees, nor the outcome of legal proceedings relating to the Taranissi affair. Rather, he passes judgement on the adequacy of governance and practice at a time when 'the HFEA departed from its usual regulatory practice into uncharted waters'. Most of the aspects of past governance and practice that he examines are found to be inadequate. By contrast, Thompson finds most aspects of current and recent HFEA governance and practice to be adequate.

Problems highlighted by Thompson in relation to the Taranissi affair include 'the potential impact of the shifting Licence Committee membership'; 'an inadequate separation between the regulatory functions and the licensing functions of the Authority'; uncertainty over 'how to manage the tension between informal contact and the formal aspects of the licensing process' and over 'the process to be followed when seeking a warrant, or the issues to be considered when making that judgement'; and the fact that 'there was no procedure in place at the time for registering a crime or setting out the respective roles which the HFEA and the police would need to play in order to undertake a criminal investigation'.

Doing the Right Things the Right Way: A Review of Governance at the HFEA (.pdf 944KB)
Peter Thompson, Director of Strategy and Information, Human Fertilisation & Embryology Authority |  14 September 2011
21 February 2011 - by James Lawford Davies 
On the morning of 15 January 2007, I attended a meeting about hybrid embryo research in the UK Parliament. Halfway through, I received a message from a journalist that fertility regulator the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) had announced there would be a press conference that lunchtime about a London IVF clinic, the Assisted Reproduction and Gynaecology Centre (ARGC). As I left the meeting, I was called and asked to go to the ARGC urgently...
31 January 2011 - by Dr John Gillott 
The presentation of a public consensus and common purpose between regulator and scientists needs critical scrutiny. In reality, some of the claims made to support this consensus are vigorously contested...
18 January 2010 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
The UK's Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) is conducting an internal investigation into its own failings when investigating Mohamed Taranissi, the 'person responsible' for the Assisted Reproduction and Gynaecology Centre (ARGC), London, in 2007 concerning allegations that he was operating without a licence, The Times newspaper has reported....
15 June 2009 - by MacKenna Roberts 
The BBC will be paying a steep legal bill, estimated between one and six million pounds, after settling a libel case with Dr Mohamed Taranissi, who is considered to be one of Britain's most successful fertility specialists....
3 November 2008 - by Ailsa Stevens 
Disciplinary proceedings against one of the UK's top fertility experts, Mohamed Taranissi, relating to allegations brought by two of his former patients, collapsed this week after the General Medical Council (GMC) ruled that there was insufficient evidence to support the charges. Mr Taranissi was accused of failing...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.