Page URL: https://www.bionews.org.uk/page_93088

Dead father granted parenthood in surrogacy case

8 August 2011
Appeared in BioNews 619

The UK's High Court has awarded legal parenthood to a deceased father of a child born through a surrogacy arrangement in India.

Mr A and Mrs A, who cannot be named for legal reasons, sought an order granting legal parenthood and to be recognised as the child's mother and father on the birth certificate. Sadly, Mr A was diagnosed with cancer and died five months after the application was submitted, before an order was granted. The court had to decide on whether to grant a parental order, which in the UK can only be applied for by couples, to Mrs A and her deceased husband.

The baby boy, known as B, was born in April last year to an Indian surrogate. It was clear Mr A, who provided his sperm for the procedure, was the biological father, although there remained uncertainty over whether Mrs A or an anonymous donor was the biological mother - as both women's fertilised eggs were implanted. However, under UK law it was the surrogate and her husband who were recognised as the child's parents, not Mr and Mrs A.

In granting the order, Mrs Justice Theis said the court's paramount consideration was B's welfare. She explained it was at the discretion of the court to make an order, so long as the requirements for parenting orders set out in Section 54 of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology (HFE) Act 2008 were met. 'The evidence clearly demonstrates that B's welfare needs are met by the making of a parental order, which is the order I shall make', she ruled.

In the UK only couples can apply for parenting orders and the court had to consider whether the word 'applicants' in the HFE Act 2008 could be construed so as to require two people to make the application but not require that there be two living applicants at the time of the making of the order. The court heard how Parliament did not envisage a situation where one of the applicants had died before an order could be granted.

Commenting on the case, fertility lawyer Natalie Gamble said: 'The High Court is repeatedly having to stretch the legislation in order to secure the status of vulnerable children born through surrogacy, and the emotional and financial cost of this for the family involved is significant'.

'The case shows how dangerously outdated our surrogacy laws are... This has always been an accident waiting to happen, and the restrictiveness of the current law is leaving children vulnerable and unprotected', she added, asking: 'What would have happened if either of the parents had died earlier, perhaps during the pregnancy?'

Mrs Justice Theis sought to emphasise the legal difficulties overseas surrogacy arrangements can create. 'Although the circumstances that have arisen in this case are extremely rare, they bring into sharp focus again, the difficulties that can arise in international surrogacy arrangements', she said.

The court also considered the issue of payments to surrogates, which, if more than expenses reasonably incurred, are prohibited in the UK unless authorised by the courts. Mrs Justice Theis said it was 'more likely than not' that the payment made by Mr and Mrs A to the surrogate exceeded this threshold but nonetheless ratified the payment.

SOURCES & REFERENCES
A & Anor v P & Ors [2011] EWHC 1738 (Fam)
England and Wales High Court (Family Division) Decisions |  8 July 2011
RELATED ARTICLES FROM THE BIONEWS ARCHIVE
13 November 2017 - by Sean Byrne 
A woman has been denied legal parenthood of her surrogate-born child because she is single, despite being the genetic mother...
9 March 2015 - by Antony Blackburn-Starza 
A single father has adopted his biological child born to his mother in a surrogacy arrangement using donor eggs...
8 October 2012 - by Ruth Retassie 
A male couple in the UK has been awarded legal parenthood over twins born through an Indian surrogacy arrangement without the consent of the mother....
9 January 2012 - by Annabel Christie 
A new surrogacy law in South Africa suggests a way to improve those in the UK – by making surrogacy agreements enforceable. In the UK, commissioning parents can only find out after the child is born if they can become the legal parents...
12 December 2011 - by Antony Blackburn-Starza 
The UK's High Court has granted parental orders to a couple over two children born through an international surrogacy arrangement, ruling that payments made to the Indian surrogates were not 'disproportionate'...
30 August 2011 - by Daniel Malynn 
The documentary 'I'm Pregnant with Their Baby' shows three women's experience of UK surrogacy. They are among a rare group who became surrogate mothers for altruistic reasons...
22 August 2011 - by Oliver Timmis 
An Australian court has ruled that a lesbian couple can have the name of the sperm donor removed from their child's birth certificate....
15 August 2011 - by Ayesha Ahmad 
An Israeli court has granted permission for a family to extract and freeze eggs from their deceased daughter's ovaries...
31 May 2011 - by Natalie Gamble 
More people are crossing borders to build their families than ever before. Prospective parents can easily access information about treatment options in countries where regulations permit treatments outlawed in the UK or where there is little or no regulation at all. But where surrogacy is involved, going abroad raises very difficult legal issues....
9 May 2011 - by Nisha Satkunarajah 
A child born to a surrogate mother in India has been refused German citizenship despite the intending German parents being named on the birth certificate....
21 February 2011 - by Nishat Hyder 
Uncertainty has arisen over the procedures followed by an Indian surrogacy clinic following the birth of twins to a gay couple from Spain. The couple used a donated egg, which was then artificially fertilised and implanted in a surrogate....
HAVE YOUR SAY
Log in to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions


Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.