Page URL:

New telomere tests do not predict when you will die, but you may still want the information

20 June 2011
By Dr Susan Kelly
Senior Research Fellow, ESRC Centre for Genomics and Society (Egenis), University of Exeter
Appeared in BioNews 612

The world of genetically predicted futures has recently been joined by a test for what is advertised as 'biological age'. The test promises to provide information about the rate at which one is ageing – and knowing when you will die would make planning for the future so much easier!

My father, a great planner, was the first person I thought of when I read about recently announced plans to offer tests that measure crucial parts of an individual’s chromosomes. A Spanish group is planning to offer such tests over the counter, at a price of around €500.

The tests measure the length of telomeres, bits of material at the ends of the  chromosome strands in our cells that protect the strands from damage, which can break down and shorten each time the cell divides. A decrease in telomere length has long been associated with cell ageing. The telomere test will identify whether an individual's telomeres are very short, a danger sign that has been associated with diseases of ageing such as cardiovascular disease and certain types of cancer.

Although telomere shortening occurs as a natural process in cells, shorter than average telomeres have been associated with various life experiences including chronic stress, smoking, and even lower educational attainment. Given that my father, a non-smoker, already has lived into his 80s without signs of any common diseases of ageing, the test is not likely to be of much use to him. For some, however, it could provide a warning sign of an underlying biological state that may lead to onset of disease. But at present the test is unable to provide the kind of predictive information that a forward-looking planner such as my father, or a life insurance company for that matter, could usefully base decisions upon.

Research over the past decade has provided evidence that shorter telomeres are associated with shorter life span. However, that does not mean that an individual's mortality can be predicted in this way. Stressful experiences, such as childhood trauma or caring for a chronically ill child, have been found to be associated with shortened telomeres. Intriguingly, research found that mice engineered to lack a telomere-lengthening chemical normally produced by the body, called telomerase, experienced premature death relative to normal mice. Injections of telomerase appeared to restore them to normal ageing patterns. To be clear, medical repair of telomeres in humans is not currently a possibility but recent research has, however, identified telomere lengthening in some individuals. This suggests some earlier damage may be ameliorated by life style and behavioural choices.

So, while the science behind the telomere test is yielding important insights into processes of biological ageing and disease, it is not currently useful as a medical tool. Rather, it straddles medicine and lifestyle advice. No medical tests are currently available or recommended for diagnosing premature ageing. Rather, finding out that one has dangerously short telomeres might serve as a wakeup call to change one's life style – quit smoking, meditate, exercise more, and perhaps be more vigilant in screening for signs of some diseases. On a less helpful note, it might also motivate a person to investigate products that claim to lengthen telomeres, reverse ageing, and so forth, opening the door to a floodgate of dubious claims.

It is important consumers who access the tests be aware of the significant limits on what the results may tell them. The tests are currently not able to predict an individual's life span, because these include a wide range of factors beyond one’s control. You would need to weigh what you may know about your family history for diseases of ageing, and any specific genetic and lifestyle risks, against knowing whether the telomeres in your white blood cells are very short.

Telomere tests join a range of genetic tests offered to consumers that seek to capitalise on people's desire to predict and control their own future. Is such a test ready to leave the research realm? If it is not ready to be used as a clinical medical test, is offering it directly to consumers a way to bypass the question of clinical usefulness? Interestingly, a similar test developed by a group in the US is currently available through research participation. Or perhaps we should merely view this test as another route through which the planners among us can gather information to factor into their decision-making.

25 November 2013 - by Jamie Rickman 
The 2013 Schrödinger Lecture at Imperial College London was delivered by Dr Elizabeth Blackburn, an Australian-American biologist based in California...
23 September 2013 - by Dr Jess Buxton 
A US study proclaiming the health benefits of stress management, gentle exercise and a 'plant-based' diet grabbed the attention of the world's media last week, but what was novel about the findings, and are the life-extending claims justified?...
8 April 2013 - by Dr Greg Ball 
Genes that influence the so-called 'biological age' of cells may also influence susceptibility to many age-related diseases...
18 June 2012 - by Sarah Pritchard 
Children born to men who delay fatherhood may live longer, a US study has shown. The findings indicate that as men age, the telomeres in sperm appear to lengthen, offering a protective effect against the cell aging process - a benefit which could be passed on to future generations...
23 April 2012 - by Dr Victoria Burchell 
Chemical alterations in a group of genes affect how we age, scientists have discovered. These changes switch genes on or off in response to diet or environmental factors throughout our lives. Researchers found that four genes that are epigentically switched off in later life may have a bearing on how well we age...
23 May 2011 - by Mehmet Fidanboylu 
Scientists claim they have developed a blood test that can predict how fast a person is ageing. The test, developed in Spain, is set to be available in the UK soon....
15 February 2010 - by Ruth Pidsley 
Scientists have identified a genetic variant that may influence the rate at which a person will age. The finding, published in last week's edition of the journal Nature Genetics, could help identify which individuals are most susceptible to common age-related conditions, such as heart disease and Alzheimer's disease....
22 November 2009 - by Sarah Pritchard 
Scientists have discovered among a group of very elderly Jews that their longevity could be due to a mutant enzyme which stops cells ageing. Researchers at the Albert Einstein School of Medicine in the USA studied 86 Ashkenazi Jews with an average age of 97, as well as 175 of their children, and 93 'control' patients whose parents had had an average lifespan....
12 October 2009 - by Nienke Korsten 
Three US scientists have won this year's Nobel prize for Medicine or Physiology for their work on how DNA protects itself from degradation, the Nobel Assembly at Sweden's Karolinska Institute announced on 5 October. Their discoveries 'have added a new dimension to our understanding of the cell, shed light on disease mechanisms, and stimulated the development of potential new therapies', the Assembly said....
15 January 2007 - by Dr Laura Bell 
New research published in the Lancet medical journal last week shows a potential new way to identify people who have a higher risk of heart disease. Telomeres are the strands of DNA that cap and protect our chromosomes. They act as a kind of cellular clock...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.