Page URL:

Niece became surrogate to help aunt with fertility problems

11 April 2011
Appeared in BioNews 603

A British woman has given birth to her cousin, as part of a surrogacy arrangement to help her aunt. The 29-year-old mother of three became pregnant from sperm donated by her aunt's husband, to whom she was not related by blood. This resulted in the birth of a baby girl who is both her biological daughter and cousin.

The baby's mother, Mrs Sandra Barlow, the aunt of the surrogate Mrs Emma Vaughan said: 'Surrogacy seemed like our only hope. I did some research and looked at a surrogacy agency website. I was in awe that people did these amazing things for complete strangers but I wanted to do it within the family'. 

Barlow had been attempting to conceive with her husband, Chris, for 15 years. IVF had not proven successful, with Barlow having two miscarriages. Further investigation into Barlow's fertility problems revealed that her fallopian tubes had closed up and needed to be removed, leaving her unable to conceive naturally. The couple then sought other alternatives, including surrogacy.

'We decided to use Emma's egg as by the time we started I was almost 40. Generally the egg condition of a woman in her 40s is not as good as someone in their 20s. Emma also wasn't keen on taking the drugs she would need if my eggs were used', said Barlow.

The use of Vaughan's eggs and Mr Barlow's sperm meant that the baby girl would genetically be both Vaughan's daughter and cousin. This is allowed under the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act and does not contravene UK incest laws. In England and Wales, upon birth of the baby, the legal mother is the surrogate until a parental order is applied for and approved by the courts. Barlow therefore only gained legal parental rights over the baby following this procedure.

'The surrogate mother is the legal mother, and is free to keep the child until a parental order is made. The attraction of using a relative as the surrogate is that she is less likely to change her mind - and of course it maintains the family link', said family law specialist Harjit Sarang. Barlow is now legally the mother of baby girl, Maia Barlow.

Brit woman gives birth to own cousin after becoming surrogate for aunt
Daily India |  7 April 2011
Surrogate gives birth to her own cousin to help her infertile aunt end 15-year fertility struggle
Daily Mail |  7 April 2011
Surrogate mum gives birth to her own cousin
Daily Mirror |  7 April 2011
30 August 2011 - by Daniel Malynn 
The documentary 'I'm Pregnant with Their Baby' shows three women's experience of UK surrogacy. They are among a rare group who became surrogate mothers for altruistic reasons...
21 February 2011 - by Leo Perfect 
A 61-year-old woman gave birth to her grandson in February because her daughter couldn't maintain a pregnancy. Kristine Casey, who may be the oldest woman to give birth to her grandson, volunteered to act as a surrogate after her daughter, Sara Connell, failed to bring two IVF pregnancies to term...
15 November 2010 - by Rosie Beauchamp 
The London Women's Clinic (LWC) has reportedly received an application for fertility treatment by two gay men wanting to raise a child who wish to use one of the couple's sister as a surrogate....
23 April 2007 - by Katy Sinclair 
A Canadian woman has frozen her eggs in the hope that her daughter may use them in later life. Lawyer Melanie Bolvin's decision has instigated a fierce ethical debate on the nature of egg donation, particularly as the result could mean that her daughter, Flavie, will one...
3 October 2005 - by BioNews 
A 53-year-old UK woman has given birth to a child she was carrying for her daughter, leading many in the media to exclaim that she 'has given birth to her own grandchild'. Annie Casserley acted as a surrogate for her daughter, 35-year old Emma Hattersley, who has a...
2 February 2004 - by BioNews 
A 43-year old grandmother has given birth to her own daughter's IVF twins. Lata Nagla, a 26-year old Indian woman living in the UK with her husband, has Rokitansky syndrome, a rare congenital condition where the uterus does not develop normally. This meant that she was unable to...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.