Page URL: https://www.bionews.org.uk/page_92047

Fertility watchdog to review donation rules

14 December 2009
Appeared in BioNews 538

The UK's fertility watchdog - the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) - agreed at an open Authority meeting last week to review a range of its sperm, egg and embryo donation (SEED) policies during 2010.

The current guidelines regarding reimbursement of donors have been in place for two years and Professor Lisa Jardine, Chair of the HFEA, has said that the policy is one which could, 'usefully be re-visited in light of what we have learned over those two years.' A huge shortage of donors, particularly egg donors, and a concern over the safety and regulation of fertility treatment many British women travel abroad to receive are thought to be two of the main motivations behind the review.

Issues which will be included in the review include the current age limits for egg and sperm donation, the ten-family limit for an individual donor, reimbursement of donors for expenses and loss of earnings and 'egg sharing' schemes. HFEA members will also consider intra-familial and inter-generational donation, cross border treatment and whether donors should be allowed to restrict their donations to particular patient groups. Some of the issues raised in detail at the HFEA meeting on 9 December were ways to deal with patients who only want donations from a particular race or faith, and donors themselves who restrict their donations to certain groups.

Additionally, the authority discussed the possibility of lowering the current age limit for sperm donation from 45 to 40 years old, in line with professional guidance and, conversely, raising the current minimum age limit for egg donation from 18 years because of the physical and emotional risks of the procedure.

Some campaigners have already expressed their reservations regarding the implications of a possible payment system for donors: 'Our main concern is that this will induce women who are in financial need to take significant risks with their health - it is not acceptable to create a situation in which poorer women are disproportionately induced to take such risks,' say a group of feminists campaigning under the name 'No2eggsploitation'. At present, women can only claim compensation up to £250 plus expenses for egg donation, however, some European countries allow compensation for 'inconvenience', and to reflect the significant consequences of the decision to donate a gamete.

Donna Dickenson, emeritus professor of medical ethics and humanities at the University of London believes that such payment amounts to a market in body parts and questions the ethical distinction between paying for an egg donation, and paying for an organ such as a kidney. However, Dr Tony Rutherford, head of the British Fertility Society believes that egg donation is an entirely different matter. 'We really have to be clear about this,' said Dr Rutherford. 'Unlike kidneys, eggs have a finite lifespan. Once they have formed after 10-15 days, they would just die. We are rescuing eggs which would otherwise have gone to waste.'

'Egg sharing' schemes are currently available in some centres in the UK and these will also be under discussion next year. Egg sharing acts as a way to redress some of the balance for women who might otherwise be financially unable to meet the demands of their own IVF; women are offered the option of donating their eggs in exchange for discounted or sometimes free treatment for themselves. The scheme works well, HFEA members noted, though its benefits do not outweigh the current high demand for donations.

SOURCES & REFERENCES
Egg and sperm donor rules reviewed
Press Association |  9 December 2009
Expenses row over fertility payment
Nursing in practice |  10 December 2009
Is it right to pay women for their eggs?
BBC News |  9 December 2009
Leading article: Fertility for sale?
The Independent |  10 December 2009
Statement regarding Authority decision to review sperm, egg and embryo donation policies
HFEA |  9 December 2009
Women may be paid for eggs: fertility watchdog
The Telegraph |  9 December 2009
RELATED ARTICLES FROM THE BIONEWS ARCHIVE
14 September 2015 - by Daniel Malynn 
This documentary short film produced by the California-based Centre for Bioethics and Culture (CBC) is a sequel to their 2010 film 'Eggsploitation'. My heartfelt congratulations for an obvious but nonetheless awesome pun. But, sadly, that is where my congratulations end for this film...
4 April 2011 - by Professor Brian Lieberman 
Human eggs are in short supply. Whilst the first reaction to the concept of payment for eggs may evoke the 'yuk' response, is this response rational? However, significant differences of opinion, ethical conduct and attitudes prevail. Yet, it can be argued that payment in one form or another is justified not only to try to meet this need, but also to reduce exploitation of the women who require donated eggs and those who have specifically been recruited into the egg trading market from...
15 March 2010 - by Ailsa Stevens 
A donated human egg will be raffled on Wednesday to mark the launch of a new IVF service which helps UK women to access egg donation services in America. The new service, offered by the Bridge Centre in London, will allow patients to select egg donors on the basis of characteristics such as racial background, health, education and appearance....
HAVE YOUR SAY
Log in to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions


Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.