Page URL:

Reduced sentence for murderer with 'genetic predisposition' to aggression

8 November 2009
Appeared in BioNews 533

An Italian court has reduced the sentence of a convicted murderer by a year based on evidence that he carries genetic mutations linked to aggressive behaviour. This is the first time that genetics have been considered a mitigating factor in a European court sentencing.

In March 2007, Abdelmalek Bayout admitted to stabbing Walter Felipe Novoa Perez to death because he had insulted Bayout over the eye make-up he wore for religious reasons. At his trial, his mental illness was taken into account and he was sentenced to nine years and two months imprisonment - three years less than he would have received otherwise. At an appeal hearing in May this year, the judge requested a new psychiatric report. Two independent neuroscientists performed tests on Bayout. They found abnormalities in brain scans, and five gene mutations previously associated with aggression. Based on their report, the judge reduced the sentence by another year in September.

The judge said that he was particularly compelled by the presence of mutations in the gene encoding the enzyme monoamine oxidase A (MAOA), which influences the creation of particular chemicals (neurotransmitters) responsible for passing on signals between brain cells. Low levels of MAOA have been linked to delinquency and aggression in young boys raised in abusive environments. The report concludes that Bayout is genetically predisposed to aggressive behaviour when provoked.

However, expert scientists in this field have questioned whether the scientific findings really support these conclusions, Nature reports. Professor Nita Farahany of Vanderbilt University in the US, an expert on ethical issues related to behavioural genetics and neuroscience, argues that the behaviour of a single individual cannot be explained by their genes alone as behaviour is always strongly dependent on environmental factors - such as child abuse for aggression in people with low MAOA levels. 'The point is that behavioural genetics is not there yet, we cannot explain individual behaviour, only large population statistics', she says. Professor Terrie Moffitt of King's College London, UK, who contributed to the original research identifying the link between MAOA and aggression, claims that the results could be unreliable depending on Bayout's ethnicity, which was not tested.

Professor Steve Jones, a geneticist at University College London, raises a point of principle beyond scientific reliability: does a genetic predisposition ever diminish an individual's responsibility for their behaviour? '90 per cent of all murders are committed by people with aY chromosome - males. Should we always give males a shorter sentence?' he told Nature, adding 'I have low MAOA activity but I don't go around attacking people'.
Lighter sentence for murderer with 'bad genes'
Nature |  30 November 2009
Murderer with 'aggression genes' gets sentence cut
New Scientist |  3 November 2009
Murderer With “Violent Genes” Gets Lighter Sentence in Italian Court
Discover |  3 November 2009
20 June 2011 - by Stevienna de Saille 
Arising from Dr Antoinette Rouvroy's doctoral research, Human Genes and Neoliberal Governance was originally published as a hardback in 2008, but has only recently become available in a paperback edition affordable to the general reader. In between those two dates much has happened in the field of genetics and governance, both globally and in the UK...
6 December 2010 - by Dr Lux Fatimathas 
American researchers suggest a genetic element to an individual's sexual behaviour. A genetic variant of the dopamine receptor gene, DRD4, was found to be more common in people displaying higher rates of sexual promiscuity and infidelity....
2 August 2010 - by Dr Aarathi Prasad 
Scientists have found evidence to support a relationship between genetic make-up and emotional response to childhood bullying....
1 October 2006 - by Dr Mairi Levitt 
We're not arguing that genes made him do it but if violent behaviour is genetic then it is probably treatable'. This comment by a US lawyer on behalf of his client (who was eventually executed for murder last year) sums up the hope invested in research into violent and antisocial...
14 August 2006 - by Dr Jess Buxton 
Comments made by a New Zealand scientist carrying out research into the effects of a genetic variation linked to addictive, risk-taking and aggressive behaviour have angered the country's indigenous Maori population. Rod Lea, a geneticist based at the Institute of Environmental Science and Research in Wellington...
26 May 2005 - by BioNews 
Antisocial behaviour in children is strongly influenced by genetic factors - but only when accompanied by psychopathic tendencies, say UK scientists. The researchers, based at the Institute of Psychiatry at King's College in London, studied twins to investigate the role of genes and other factors in behaviour. Their findings, published in...
22 July 2004 - by BioNews 
Good mothering can cancel out a genetic predisposition to aggressive behaviour in monkeys, a new US study suggests. Scientists at the National Institutes of Health say that a nurturing environment can curb antisocial behaviour in rhesus monkeys born with low levels of certain brain chemicals. Their findings, which will be...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.