Page URL:

Genetic discrimination of people with family history of Huntington's disease

15 June 2009
Appeared in BioNews 512

A study by researchers at the University of British Columbia in Canada and published in the British Medical Journal has shown that individuals at risk of Huntington's disease (HD) are often discriminated against by insurance companies, and also by their own relatives and friends. They also found that this discrimination was based on family history of the disease rather than any genetic test results.

HD is an inherited neurodegenerative disease leading to personality changes, involuntary movements, cognitive decline and eventually death up to 20 years after diagnosis. Symptoms do not usually become apparent until middle age, which is often after the person has had children of their own.

Predictive genetic testing for this disease has been available since the late 1980s, but testing can be a sensitive issue in families as it increases the potential for genetic discrimination and there is currently no treatment or cure for people who carry the HD gene mutation.

To look at the prevalence of genetic discrimination in tested and untested individuals, the team surveyed 233 people who were at risk of developing HD, but who showed no symptoms. 167 underwent testing (approximately half carried the mutation and half did not) and 66 decided against testing. They found that 40 per cent experienced discrimination, mostly by insurance companies, but that the main reason for this discrimination was having a family history of the disease rather than having the genetic test. The authors add that many families fear not being able to cope with the results and that an individual's decision to undergo testing can cause disruptions within the family.

The authors concluded that 'ultimately asymptomatic individuals at genetic risk are at a similar risk for discrimination because their label of having a family history of disease'

Professor Aad Tibben, from Leiden University Medical Centre in the Netherlands, wrote of the advantages of testing in the accompanying editorial 'Genetic testing gives people at risk the opportunity to take more responsibility for their lives, their health and their future'. He added that 'in general, the test brings relief from uncertainty'. Genetic testing also enables patients to make informed reproductive decisions.

Jo-Anne Watton, who heads the Individual and Family Services for Huntington Society in Canada, told a Canadian newspaper that fears about discrimination reduce the number of individuals tested for the disease and, hence, those available to aid research into possible treatments.

Individuals with family history of genetic disease at risk of discrimination
GEN News |  9 June 2009
Study finds genetic discrimination by insurance
The Star (Canada) |  9 June 2009
22 November 2010 - by MacKenna Roberts 
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), responsible for enforcing federal anti-discrimination laws in the US, has issued its 'final rule' guidelines clarifying how federal laws should operate to prevent job discrimination on the basis of genetic information....
5 July 2010 - by Dr Jay Stone 
Two papers published in the Lancet have suggested that the number of people in the UK suffering with Huntington’s disease (HD) may be double original figures and that patients are failing to be diagnosed due to the stigma attached to the illness...
4 May 2010 - by Dr Vivienne Raper 
Huntington's Disease affects families as much as individuals; affected parents have a 50 per chance of passing it to their children. This fact makes this book describing the effects of Huntington's on an entire family such a thought-provoking read. And it's funny, chatty and uplifting too...
1 March 2010 - by MacKenna Roberts 
Canadians need better protection from genetic discrimination by insurers and employers, according to Winnipeg North MP Judy Wasylycia-Leis...
22 February 2010 - by Ben Jones 
An Australian insurance firm has become the subject of criticism after offering customers reduced price genetic tests while providing in the small print that the results are to be made available for consideration by life insurance providers should they desire them....
7 November 2005 - by Fiona Richards 
I would like to challenge a few points raised by Rony Duncan in her commentary 'Holding your breath: Predictive genetic testing in young people' (BioNews 330, 17 October 2005). Based on my 15 years' experience of pre- and post-test counselling of people at risk for Huntington disease (HD) who have...
17 October 2005 - by Rony Duncan 
When it comes to genetic tests, young people are treated differently from adults. If adults want to know if they will develop the genetic condition that runs in their family, they can have a predictive test to find out. However, if young people want to learn the same information about...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.