Page URL: https://www.bionews.org.uk/page_91665

Not a time for procrastination, let's sort out the problems with sperm donation

12 December 2008
By Helen Clarke
a Clinical Embryologist at the Assisted Conception Unit, Jessop Wing, Sheffield
Appeared in BioNews 488
The British Fertility Society (BFS) recently published its report on sperm donation services in the UK (1), in which various suggestions were put forward for overcoming the current shortfall of sperm donors. These included increasing the number of families to be treated per donor and changing thresholds for acceptance of donors. The BFS also proposed a concept of hub and spoke services for sperm donors which, ultimately, may well be the way forward to overcome the current problems. In the meantime, however, clinics are still faced with increasing lists of patients awaiting treatment with donor sperm.

When the regulations regarding anonymity changed, donor sperm did become more difficult to obtain. Anecdotal evidence suggests that fewer clinics now recruit donors compared to 15-20 years ago. Also, it suggests that some of these clinics stopped recruiting donors on the assumption that fewer men were willing to become sperm donors because they would not want to be identified in the future, and that the process would therefore be too difficult and too expensive. Maybe this assumption was wrong. Perhaps there are plenty of men out there willing to be donors and we just have to make sure we recruit them

At a time when donor sperm was becoming increasingly difficult to source, our unit was receiving phone calls from men unable to find a local clinic at which to donate sperm. We soon reached the conclusion that if we were to continue to offer donor sperm treatments to our patients then we would have to take on the responsibility and recruit these men to be donors of our own. 

Over just a few months, with a great deal of help and advice from staff at another recruiting clinic, we were able to establish our own sperm donor program. This sharing of information and experience was a key factor in us being able to set up our successful program in a relatively short space of time, and this level of altruism is as essential for the reproductive health workers as it is for the donors we hope to recruit. 

Advertising has traditionally been the greatest expense in recruiting donors and perhaps this cost acts as a deterrent to many clinics. We have never paid for advertising for donors, but we follow up all unsolicited contact from men interested in donation. Many of these men respond to articles in the news (an example is that in two weeks we had 10 enquiries from men following the media publicity sparked by the BFS publication) and they easily locate us through the excellent NGDT (National Gamete Donation Trust) website (2). Because we now have the necessary protocols in place we are able to capitalise on this and we do not have to turn these men away. If recruitment rates remain at the current steady levels then we project that within two years we will no longer have a waiting list for patients in our clinic requiring donor sperm.

We cannot simply assume that there are now fewer men in the population that are prepared to be sperm donors. A national approach of recruitment, co-ordination and deployment of donor sperm may well be the future solution to the current problems of donor sperm supply. In the meantime, instead of compromising on donor sperm quality or accepting that an increase in the number of families per donor is acceptable, we should take on the responsibility of recruiting sperm donors to treat the patients on our own waiting lists before their fertility is beyond our help.

SOURCES & REFERENCES
1) British Fertility Society (2008) Working party on sperm donation services in the UK. Human Fertility 11:147-58.
|  25 November 2020
2) National Gamete Donation Trust
|  25 November 2020
RELATED ARTICLES FROM THE BIONEWS ARCHIVE
11 January 2010 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
A British woman has travelled to Denmark to undergo donor insemination after the fertility clinic where she had been receiving treatment in the UK ran out of sperm, BBC News reports. Single and 41, Abby, who is using a pseudonym, made the decision after three unsuccessful insemination attempts in the UK using donated sperm. Once the clinic informed her there was no more sperm available she contacted the Danish clinic. Following treatment there she gave birth to a...
12 January 2009 - by Ben Jones 
The British Fertility Society (BFS) has announced a substantial reworking of guidelines for the donation of gametes and embryos for assisted reproduction so as to increase safety for recipients of donated reproductive material. The guidelines, which replace the BFS's 2000 guidelines for egg and embryo donations and...
24 November 2008 - by Professor Eric Blyth and Dr Marilyn Crawshaw 
The report of the British Fertility Society's (BFS) Working Party on Sperm Donation Services in the UK (1) recently hit the headlines, following an associated editorial in the British Medical Journal (2). However, the report's proposals for a fundamental overhaul of the current arrangements for organising donor recruitment were considered...
17 November 2008 - by MacKenna Roberts 
Sperm donation services require infrastructural reorganisation, 'sperm-sharing' incentive schemes and regulatory reforms to overcome the severe shortage presently causing 'anguish' to thousands of infertile couples in the UK each year and to the health professionals unable to provide treatment to their patients, according to fertility experts writing...
HAVE YOUR SAY
Log in to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions


Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.