Page URL:

Petitions call for end to IVF discrimination and 'Postcode Lottery' in the UK

26 May 2009
Appeared in BioNews 509

Two separate online petitions are calling for a change to the way IVF services are provided under the UK's NHS. Janine Macallister, 27, of Newport, Shropshire and Richard Mackenzie, 29, from Whitney, Oxfordshire have each started a petition calling for their local PCTs to adhere to national guidelines on IVF funding thereby ending the so-called 'postcode lottery' of provision.

The Macallisters have been denied NHS-provided fertility treatment on the grounds that Jason Macallister has children from a previous relationship. Mrs Macallister said that she feels 'disgusted, angry and upset' when she was told that she couldn't have IVF treatment, and that if she found another partner, she would be treated 'straight away'.

The couple, who married three years ago, have been trying to have a baby for many years and say that their failed attempts to access fertility treatment have put enormous strain on their marriage. Mrs Macallister, who suffers from polycystic ovaries, says that in denying her treatment, her PCT regards she and her husband as one person: 'I am the one who has the problem, not my husband, and I am the one in need of treatment', she added.
Under national guidelines issued by the National Institute of Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) in 2004, women between the ages of 23 and 39 who have an identified cause for their infertility which has existed for three years, should have access to three cycles of IVF treatment on the NHS. However, the guidelines are not legally binding and allow individual trusts to make their own decisions on provision of treatment.

Telford and Wrekin PCT, which covers the Macallisters, has said that couples with existing children from current or previous relationships will not be allowed access to treatment. But this week a spokesman from the PCT has said that 'the policy regarding fertility treatment is currently under review' and that Mrs Macallister should be reassured that the provision policy will be discussed 'at our next priorities committee as soon as possible'. Susan Seenan, of the charity Infertility Network UK, said that it had heard from an increasing number of women who find themselves in a similar situation. 'These women are shocked and upset to hear they are being penalised because their partner had children in a previous relationship', she said, adding: 'we think it is terribly unfair, especially when there will be other PCTs which will have totally different criteria.'

In a similar case, Richard Mackenzie has called for the resignation of Oxfordshire PCT chief executive Andrea Young over the discriminatory distribution of IVF in his region. Mr Mackenzie and his partner, 26, who have been trying for a baby for six years were told that IVF was their only chance of conceiving, yet the trust will only pay for treatment for couples aged between 35 and 38.

After meeting with Ms Young this week, Mr Mackenzie said: 'I still feel we have been discriminated against, and as an Oxfordshire taxpayer I would like to call for the resignation of the person responsible'. He continued: 'We want to send a clear message showing how serious we are and it would be great to get somebody more pro-active who could take over and fight to make this discrimination come to an end.'

A statement from Oxfordshire PCT said that 'all nine PCTs across the NHS south central region have confirmed they would like the same policy in place' and that a report on proposed policy changes (reducing the age at which treatment can be provided to between 30 and 34) is being presented to the Oxfordshire health and overview scrutiny committee.

End the postcode lottery for Oxfordshire residents
Go Petition |  31 May 2009
End the postcode lottery for Shropshire residents
Go Petition |  10 May 2009
IVF protestors confront health chief
Oxford Mail |  14 May 2009
Trust chief 'should resign' over IVF policy
Oxford Mail |  13 May 2009
Woman calls for IVF rule change
BBC News Online |  12 May 2009
Woman denied fertility treatment because husband has children
The Daily Telegraph |  9 May 2009
8 March 2010 - by Maren Urner 
The UK supermarket chain Asda is to become the first to sell IVF drugs without profit, saving patients up to £820 per treatment cycle. The move is part of the retailer's bid to become the most competitive pharmacy in the UK....
23 November 2009 - by Ailsa Stevens 
The Lister Fertility Clinic in London is offering free fertility treatment to 21 couples to mark its 21st birthday and the opening of their newly expanded clinic. Mr Sam Abdalla, Medical Director of the clinic, said that the gesture was part of the clinic's 'duty to make treatment more accessible' and an ongoing commitment to offer a number of free cycles each year as part of the clinic's 'community programme.'...
29 October 2009 - by Ben Jones 
The Labour party is urging the Scottish parliament to take action to standardise IVF provision across Scotland, after Labour MSP Jackie Baillie discovered wide disparities in provision between the 11 Scottish NHS boards. Ms Baillie contacted all of the boards after having been approached by a constituent who was upset about the length of IVF waiting lists where they lived....
26 May 2009 - by Selene Kaye 
On 12 May, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and the Public Patent Foundation filed a lawsuit challenging the US government's practice of granting patents on human genes - specifically, the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes, which are associated with breast and ovarian cancer. In the last 20 or so years the...
5 May 2009 - by Dr Charlotte Maden 
The UK's National Health Service (NHS) announced last week that more state-funded IVF treatments are now available to couples in the east of England than anywhere else in the country. As of 1 May, the region will be the first in the UK to fund up to...
27 April 2009 - by Ailsa Stevens 
British couples at risk from passing on a serious genetic disorder to their children are being refused National Health Service (NHS) funding for treatment which could allow them to have a healthy child, medical experts have warned this week. The procedure, known as pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD...
12 January 2009 - by Sarah Pritchard 
Only one in five primary care trusts (PCTs) in England is providing the recommended number of NHS-funded IVF cycles, it was revealed at a fertility conference in Edinburgh last week. The results of a survey conducted by a team at St Bartholomew's Hospital in London show that...
26 August 2008 - by Dr Charlotte Maden 
The NHS has been advised to offer more fertility treatment cycles to infertile couples by a government advisory committee, in a bid to abolish the IVF postcode lottery that exists in the UK. The National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) recommends providing couples in which...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.