Page URL: https://www.bionews.org.uk/page_91070

Controversy over 'better' middle-class genes comment

17 May 2009
Appeared in BioNews 508

Chris Woodhead, the former UK Chief Inspector of Schools, has caused controversy by suggesting that middle-class children have 'better' genes when it comes to intellect and so will inevitably do better in school than children from lower socio-economic backgrounds.

Speaking in an interview with the Guardian newspaper, Mr Woodhead reflected on the current education system. He argued that in a strive for equality, the fact that some children are naturally less bright than others was being overlooked, and that this was to the detriment of all pupils regardless of their ability. He said: 'I've taught, and I can still remember trying to interest children who had no interest whatsoever in English. They didn't want to be in the classroom....They were disruptive to the children who did want to learn'. Instead, he proposed that 'if we had a system whereby those young people were able to follow practical educational courses that gave them a sense of worth, a sense that they weren't dull and less intelligent than others, it would [be] much better for them'.

Within this context, Mr Woodhead commented: 'the genes are likely to be better if your parents are teachers, academics, lawyers, whatever. And the nurture is likely to be better'. Although, he acknowledged that 'that doesn't mean there aren't going to be DH Lawrences', in reference to the celebrated writer whose father was a barely-literate miner.

The influence of genes and the environment on academic intelligence has been a much debated subject. In reality, it is very hard to distinguish between the effects of nurture and nature on a child's academic success. In response to Mr Woodhead's comments, the BBC News online referred to a study published in 2003 by Dr Leon Feinstein of the Institute of Education at the University of London.

Dr Feinstein examined data tracking the educational success of over 17,000 individuals from diverse social backgrounds all born in the same week in April 1970 and enrolled in the 1970 Birth Cohort Survey. The children completed educational tests at 22 months, 42 months, five years and ten years, and at 26 years, their lifetime achievements in public examinations were recorded.

Overall, he found that a child's performances in the pre-school tests were a strong indication of their later academic success. However, he also found that many children that performed badly early in life improved dramatically as they progressed through their education. Strikingly, early low achievers from higher socio-economic groups were considerably more likely to show improved intellectual aptitude later in their schooling than early low achievers from poorer backgrounds, indicating the importance of a child having a supportive environment in order to fulfil their academic potential.

SOURCES & REFERENCES
Don't say I was wrong
The Guardian |  12 May 2009
Middle-class children 'have better genes', says Chris Woodhead
The Daily Telegraph |  12 May 2009
Middle-class pupils have better genes, says Chris Woodhead
The Guardian |  11 May 2009
Nature, nurture, exam results
BBC News Online |  15 May 2009
RELATED ARTICLES FROM THE BIONEWS ARCHIVE
19 November 2012 - by George Frodsham 
Genetic mutations in thousands of genes that govern our intelligence are contributing to a 'dumbing down' of humanity, as claimed in a controversial new theory...
15 August 2011 - by Dr Zara Mahmoud 
Educational toys, brainy baby videos and flash cards – do these things help to develop intelligence? Or are the genes that you inherited from your parents the determining factor? The search for an 'intelligence gene' has intrigued scientists for decades. Now, an international team of scientists have added weight to the argument that intelligence does have a genetic basis, but that it comes from multiple genes working together...
16 June 2008 - by Stuart Scott 
Italian researchers, based at the University of Calabri, have found that a gene variant previously linked to high IQ also increases the likelihood of carriers surviving to an old age. The findings, published in New Scientist magazine, suggest that carriers of the SSADH gene variant may live...
3 December 2007 - by Ailsa Stevens 
New research aimed at uncovering some of the genetic variation which contributes to human intelligence has revealed that IQ is the result of interactions between many different genetic and environmental factors, according to a report published in the journal Genes, Brains and Behaviour last week. In the...
28 July 2005 - by BioNews 
Australian scientists have identified two regions of human genetic material which they believe harbour genes that influence a person's IQ. The team, based at the Queensland Institute of Medical Research, say that identifying the genes that affect intelligence could help research into disorders such as dyslexia, autism and attention deficit...
12 November 2001 - by BioNews 
Research has been published which suggests that there may be a genetic link to intelligence. The research, published in Nature Neuroscience, shows that the size of certain regions of the brain is genetically controlled and that there is a relationship between this size and intelligence. Using magnetic resonance imaging, Dr...
14 August 2000 - by BioNews 
A team of US researchers claims it has uncovered new evidence for several genes involved in the development of human intelligence. The National Institutes of Health (NIH) researchers say they have identified unique genetic differences in DNA from 200 of the cleverest children in America. The results are due to...
HAVE YOUR SAY
Log in to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions


Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.