Page URL:

Genetic tests no better than medical check ups for predicting diabetes

24 November 2008
Appeared in BioNews 485

Genetic tests are no better at predicting an individual's risk of developing type-2 diabetes than conventional assessments based on family history and physical factors such as blood pressure and weight, according to a new study by US scientists.

The research team, led by Dr. James Meigs of the General Medical Division at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston, analyzed medical data from over 2,300 volunteers that had been followed over a 28-year period as part of a study into cardiovascular disease. Of these individuals, 255 developed type-2 diabetes during the study period. The researchers looked for the presence of 18 different gene variants associated with type-2 diabetes and scored each individual's likelihood of developing the disease based on the particular combination of genes they carry. They then compared this to a risk assessment based on the detailed medical records of each participant, which documented family history of diabetes, weight, cholesterol, blood pressure and blood sugar levels. They found that although their gene-scoring system was a good measure of the risk of diabetes, it was no more accurate or useful than traditional methods of physical examination.

These findings were supported by a second study carried out in Sweden and Finland, led by Dr. Valeriya Lyssenko of Lund University, Sweden, which followed nearly 19,000 participants, 2,201 of whom developed diabetes, over an average of 23 years. They compared the presence of 16 gene variants linked with diabetes with physical risk factors and reached a similar conclusion to the American researchers.

Type-2 diabetes is a major health burden worldwide, and affects around two million people in the UK. There are around 25 gene variants that are linked with an increased likelihood of developing the disease. A simple genetic test to identify those most at risk is an attractive prospect. However, the outcome of these two studies indicates that we do not yet have the understanding to implement such a test. Dr Meigs commented: 'With our current knowledge, the measurements your [doctor] makes in a standard check up tell you what you need to know about your type-2 diabetes risk, and genetics doesn't tell you much more'. Nonetheless, he remains hopeful for the future, adding: 'as additional risk genes are discovered, the value of genetic screening is likely to improve'.

Gene testing for diabetes risk is not useful
Los Angeles Times |  19 November 2008
Genetic screening may ID diabetes risk
WebMD |  19 November 2008
Genetic screening may only modestly improve detection of diabetes
Medscape |  19 November 2008
Genetic testing for diabetes type-2 still in infancy
Medical News Today |  20 November 2008
Genotype score in addition to common risk factors for predicting type-2 diabetes
New England Journal of Medicine |  20 November 2008
31 March 2008 - by Dr Jess Buxton 
US and European scientists have identified six more genes that play a role in Type 2 diabetes, bringing the total number of genetic variations associated with the disease to 16. The research, published in the journal Nature Genetics, combined the results of three earlier studies carried...
5 June 2007 - by MacKenna Roberts 
The US bill that would expand federal funding for human embryonic stem (ES) cell research appears to be poised for defeat. Republican President Bush has promised to veto the bill again, and Congress appears unable to garner enough votes to override the president's opposition. A year ago...
19 February 2007 - by Dr Laura Bell 
Recent research published online in the journal Nature has mapped the most important genes involved in increasing people's risk of developing type 2 diabetes. These genes could account for up to 70 per cent of the genetic risk of developing the disorder. Type 2 diabetes affects...
30 October 2006 - by Dr Jess Buxton 
British scientists have shown that a common genetic variation is linked to a two-fold increased risk of type 2 diabetes in UK men. A team based at University College London (UCL) says that carrying two copies of the TCF7L2 gene variant increases a person's risk of...
19 January 2006 - by BioNews 
Icelandic researchers have identified a gene they say could be involved in up to a fifth of all cases of type 2 diabetes. People who inherit a particular version of the gene have a significantly increased risk of developing the condition, say the scientists, who are based at the biotechnology...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.