Page URL: https://www.bionews.org.uk/page_90628

Catholic opposition to UK embryo bill mounts

17 March 2008
Appeared in BioNews 449

Catholic pressure to amend some of the provisions of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill 2007, currently passing through parliament in the UK, is increasing. Last week, the Vatican added the destruction of embryos to a new list of mortal sins and, according to the BBC, masses across the country are ending 'with a plea for parishioners to write to their MPs with a list of reservations' about the proposed new legislation. Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O'Connor, head of the Roman Catholic Church in England and Wales, is campaigning hard against the proposed legislation: 'many people of all faiths and none are deeply concerned by the moral questions raised by this Bill', he said, adding that 'now is the time for our voices to be heard'.

Catholics argue that the price to be paid if all the provisions of the Bill are implemented is too high and that any procedure which involves selecting embryos and destroying those which are unwanted or which have been used for research - for whatever end - is an affront to human life and dignity. However, many of the procedures that the Bill authorises are already currently legal - and there is little indication that this would change even with widespread opposition from Catholics, as the UK has established itself as a world leader in some of the scientific research in these areas. It is only very few things - such as the deliberate creation of 'hybrid' embryos, that are being newly brought into the law.

Recognising this, as well as the fact that some of the fertility procedures the Bill regulates have become almost 'commonplace' since the original legislation was passed in 1990, some Catholics are realistic about the Bill and the extensions it proposes - as well as what it will not allow. Professor David Jones, from the Catholic St Mary's University College, described some of the features of the Bill as 'positive', for example the proposed prohibition on the use of sex selection for non-medical purposes. While this is a 'good start', in his eyes, he would, however, like to see all sex selection prohibited. He also applauded the Bill for seeking to ensure 'that donor conceived children have a right to find out about their genetic heritage', while highlighting some of the problems: 'the human-animal hybrids are something which many people feel deep disquiet about', he said, adding 'and not just the Catholics'.

Because the Catholic Church feels that others share some of its reservations about the Bill, it is pushing for the establishment of a national panel which could keep some of the contentious areas under discussion, and be a 'transparent forum for debate'. Such a panel, it says, should be made up of both religious and secular lay members, as well as scientists, but would not simply be like the existing Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority which, as an arm of government, they see as 'simply not in the position to provide' such a forum.

One of the key issues that remain to be sorted out is whether MPs will be allowed a free vote on the bill. Currently Labour MPs have been told they may abstain, but not vote against it. Labour's Chief Whip, Geoff Hoon, has told three MPs who have threatened to vote against the Bill that they must not do so if they want to remain in their jobs. However, the three Cabinet members - Ruth Kelly, Des Browne and Paul Murphy - are now threatening to rebel. Last week more than 100 academics wrote to The Times newspaper urging the government to allow a 'conscience vote', as has previously been the case with such controversial legislation, and gaining a free vote remains a great hope of many Catholics. Helen Watt, director of the Linacre Centre, which studies health issues from a Catholic perspective, said that 'MPs of all parties should have the courage to vote against the Bill, and in favour of amendments to remove its most destructive aspects'. However, after clashes with the opposition leader in the House of Commons last week, the Prime Minister has now pledged a traditional free vote on a bid to lower the abortion limit, and for the first time suggested he may also give way to demands from Catholic ministers not to force them to compromise their religious beliefs over the rest of the Bill.

SOURCES & REFERENCES
Catholic Pressure on embryo bill increases
National Secular Society |  14 March 2008
Catholic pressure on fertility bill
BBC News Online |  11 March 2008
Embryology bill supporters upbeat ahead of key votes
Financial Times |  14 March 2008
Gordon Brown hints Catholic MPs will get free vote on Embryology Bill
The Daily Telegraph |  12 March 2008
RELATED ARTICLES FROM THE BIONEWS ARCHIVE
26 April 2010 - by Nishat Hyder 
The Vatican announced on Friday it is to finance research into the potential use of adult stem cells for therapeutic purposes. It has agreed to donate two million Euros to a research project led by the University of Maryland's School of Medicine in the US to investigate the use of intestinal adult stem cells for treating disease...
9 April 2008 - by Sheila AM McLean 
The Human Fertilisation and Embryology (HFE) Bill, currently making its way through the UK's Parliament, marks the first major re-think of the original Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act, passed in 1990. In the almost 20 years since the Act was passed, new medical developments and techniques have emerged which raise...
31 March 2008 - by MacKenna Roberts 
The head of Scotland's Catholic Church, Cardinal Keith O'Brien - who in his Easter Sunday sermon attacked the government's proposal to allow research using inter-species or human 'admixed' embryos, calling it 'government supported experiments of Frankenstein proportions' - said he would be 'only too happy' to attend a meeting...
25 March 2008 - by MacKenna Roberts 
Labour MPs are to be allowed a 'free vote' on three controversial aspects of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill currently before the House of Commons. MPs will be allowed to vote according to their conscience on: the use of animal eggs in embryo stem cell research...
10 March 2008 - by Dr Karen Devine 
The controversy sparked by the introduction of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill 2007, which is being debated in the UK House of Commons over the next few months, looks set to continue. The Daily Telegraph newspaper has reported that in an unusual move, Chef Whip Geoff...
5 March 2008 - by Dr Karen Devine 
This week, three Catholic Cabinet ministers in the UK have threatened to quit their posts following government proposals to allow the creation of hybrid embryos - embryos made using animal eggs that have their nuclei replaced with human genetic material, for use in stem cell research. The MPs...
26 February 2008 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
The Archbishop of Westminster, Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O'Connor, has sent a pastoral message urging Catholics to write to MPs in opposition to the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill, which will be debated in the House of Commons in the coming weeks. In his message, the cardinal wrote that...
HAVE YOUR SAY
Log in to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions


Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.