Page URL:

UN report calls for worldwide ban on human cloning

19 November 2007
Appeared in BioNews 434

The United Nation's Institute of Advanced Studies has issued a report containing a stark warning to the rest of the world: introduce global legislation to prohibit reproductive cloning or prepare to consider laws that protect cloned individuals from potential discrimination, prejudice and abuse. The report, entitled 'Is Human Reproductive Cloning Inevitable: Future Options for UN Governance' was compiled by legal experts and concludes that in the absence of regulation it is only a matter of time before the first human individual is cloned. 'Whichever path the international community chooses it will have to act soon - either to prevent reproductive cloning or to defend the human rights of cloned individuals', said A.H. Zakri, head of the Institute, which is based in Japan.

In 2005, the UN adopted a non-binding declaration that prohibits 'all forms of human cloning inasmuch as they are incompatible with human dignity and the protection of human life'. Dispute arose over whether the ban covered therapeutic cloning in which a cloned human embryo may be created using DNA taken from cells of a human individual in a process called SCNT (somatic cell nuclear transfer) and some countries, including the UK, refused to vote in favour.

It is believed that SCNT may be employed in stem cell research to aid scientists in establishing cures or treatments for conditions such as diabetes, Parkinson's and Alzheimer's disease. However, if a cloned embryo is inserted into a womb then this constitutes reproductive cloning, which is widely held to be unlawful. 'Therapeutic cloning' research is legal in several countries, including the UK and the US but almost all countries have spoken out against reproductive cloning and many Governments have legislated to prohibit the technique. Reproductive cloning is illegal in the UK under the Human Reproductive Cloning Act, passed in November 2001, which carries a maximum of ten years imprisonment.

The authors of the UN report highlight that despite the near universal opposition to reproductive cloning, 140 members of the UN are yet to introduce laws to prohibit it. They raise the concern that some scientists may proceed to conduct reproductive cloning in regulatory vacuums if a global ban is not adopted. 'China has guidelines on human reproductive cloning but no law as such, while there are many African countries that don't have any legislation in place', said Chamundeeswari Kuppuswamy, one of the co-authors of the report. The report does not advocate the prohibition of therapeutic cloning.

Others feel that whilst a ban may not necessarily be the correct course of action, a strict regulatory environment in which to conduct the research is. Professor Alison Murdoch, part of the team at Newcastle University who cloned the UK's first human embryo, said 'we shouldn't be afraid of the idea of having two individuals with genetically identical material, although I cannot see a good clinical need for that. The risk you run by trying to ban cloning outright is that it may send those scientists who want to do that kind of research to countries where it is completely unregulated'.

The technology involved in human reproductive cloning is not yet perfected and safety concerns currently form the grounds for unanimous opposition. However, if this obstacle is overcome, the ethical debate surrounding human cloning may become immediately more complex. For the time being, a sense of fear of a future in which human clones exist appears to drive the movement for prohibition. As Brendan Tobin, who co-authored the report, warns, a 'failure to outlaw reproductive cloning means it is just a matter of time until cloned individuals share the planet'.

Outlaw human cloning or protect rights of future clones: UN official
AFP |  12 November 2007
UN: don't clone people
Nature |  12 November 2007
UN report demands ban on human cloning
The Daily Telegraph |  11 November 2007
World faces choice on human cloning: U.N. study
Reuters |  12 November 2007
27 August 2013 - by Dr Anna Cauldwell 
Canadian dentist Michael Zuk, who spent almost £20,000 on one of John Lennon's rotten molars at an auction in 2011, now plans to sequence Lennon's DNA in the hope of cloning him....
10 October 2011 - by Dr Louisa Petchey 
US scientists have for the first time created 'personalised' human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) using a form of cloning. The result is a significant milestone on the route to using stem cell-based therapies but the researchers stress more work is to be done as genetic errors in the cells means they are not yet suitable for therapeutic use....
10 March 2005 - by BioNews 
The United Nations (UN) has adopted a non-binding declaration that prohibits 'all forms of human cloning inasmuch as they are incompatible with human dignity and the protection of human life'. The ban was passed by the general assembly on Tuesday, by 84 votes to 34 with 37 abstentions. Many countries...
21 February 2005 - by BioNews 
The United Nations (UN) has approved a declaration calling for a ban on human cloning for both reproductive and research purposes. The assembly's legal committee voted 71 to 35 in favour of the non-binding statement, backed by the Bush administration, with 43 abstentions. The declaration will now pass to the...
21 February 2005 - by Dr Jess Buxton 
In this week's BioNews, we report on the latest instalment in the ongoing saga of the United Nation (UN)'s deliberations on cloning. What started out, in 2001, as a proposed treaty to ban human reproductive cloning has ended up as a non-binding declaration calling on nations to ban all...
22 November 2004 - by BioNews 
The Legal Committee of the General Assembly of the United Nations (UN) last week abandoned proposals to adopt an international convention on human cloning. A proposal led by the US and Costa Rica, which would have meant an international treaty banning all forms of human cloning, including for medical research...
25 October 2004 - by Dr Jess Buxton 
Last week, the much anticipated debate on cloning began again at the General Assembly of the United Nations (UN). A year after it last discussed global regulation of human cloning technology, the UN appears no closer to reaching any conclusions on this controversial issue. In fact, at the time of...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.