Reproduction and Fertility is an open-access, peer-reviewed journal
Page URL:

Victoria to consider assisted reproduction law reform

11 June 2007
Appeared in BioNews 411

The Victorian Law Reform Commission (VLRC) has published its final report on Assisted Reproductive Technology and Adoption. The report will now be considered by the Victorian State Government; a formal response is expected by the end of 2007. Assisted reproduction is governed in the Australian state by the Infertility Treatment Act 1995 and is regulated by the Infertility Treatment Authority (ITA).

The VLRC was commissioned to review the law surrounding assisted reproduction by the Victorian Government. Current legislation is considered outdated by developments in reproductive technology and demands for equal reproductive rights for same-sex couples. For example, currently only clinically infertile married couples, or de facto married couples, are eligible for fertility treatment. This requirement was challenged in the Federal Court in 2000; the Court found that the current legislation was inconsistent with Federal anti-discrimination laws and was therefore invalid. Despite this, women without male partners must be clinically infertile or at risk of conveying a genetic disorder, in order to be eligible for treatment in Victoria.

The report issued 130 recommendations to the Victorian Government; key proposals include:
- The welfare of the child should govern all decision-making.
- Reasons other than clinical infertility should be part of the eligibility criteria for access to assisted reproduction.
- The law should recognise the non-biological mother in a lesbian relationship as a legal parent.
- Same-sex couples and single people should be allowed to adopt.
- People who arrange legal surrogacy should be recognised as the parents of the child, including being named on the birth certificate.
- An agency with responsibility for managing donor registers should be established.
- Complex and new treatment decisions should be made by an ITA ethics committee, rather than governed by primary legislation.

The State Government has acknowledged that there are anomalies in the current law, but has declined to comment on the recommendations. It is likely that there will be political opposition to any reforms granting equal reproductive rights to same-sex couples. According the Melbourne Age, a number of politicians across Australia, led by the Prime Minister, John Howard, are opposed to gay couples becoming parents. The Victorian State opposition leader, Ted Baillieu has made it clear that he thinks IVF 'ought to be for heterosexual couples'. A full list of the recommendations can be found at the VLRC's website, the link for which is given below.

Gays, singles may get more IVF help
The Age |  8 June 2007
Victoria Law Reform Commission: Assisted Reproductive Technology and Adoption, Final Report
VLRC |  7 June 2007
13 November 2006 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
Australian Senator Stephen Conroy and his wife may be forced to leave their home in Victoria, Australia, to escape state laws that do not recognise them as legal parents of their child, which was born to a surrogate. The Victorian Law Reform Commission said that the state's...
30 April 2006 - by BioNews 
A lesbian woman, from California, US, is appealing a court decision that upheld a decision made by her doctors to withhold fertility treatment from her on religious grounds. Her case will be heard in the California Supreme Court, the highest court in the state, after having been heard in various...
28 November 2005 - by BioNews 
The Victorian Law Reform Commission has released recommendations suggesting how the state's 'confusing and contradictory state laws about altruistic surrogacy' can be clarified. The Commission, an independent statutory authority that reports to the state government on options for law reform in Australia's second largest state, is currently enquiring and reporting...
22 November 2004 - by BioNews 
Research has shown that teenage children raised by lesbian mothers have no developmental differences compared to children of the same age raised by heterosexual parents. Researchers Stephen Russell from the University of Arizona, in Tuscon, US, and Charlotte Patterson and Jennifer Wainwright, from the University of Virginia in Charlottesville, studied...
6 September 1999 - by BioNews 
A millionaire gay couple have been condemned for fathering twins using in vitro fertilisation and a surrogate mother from the US. Barrie Drewitt, 30, and Tony Barlow, 35, have spent £200,000 to bypass UK laws and become biological fathers when the surrogate gives birth to a boy and a girl...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.