Reproduction and Fertility is an open-access, peer-reviewed journal
Page URL: https://www.bionews.org.uk/page_90124

Genes and behaviour research sparks controversy

14 August 2006
Appeared in BioNews 371

Comments made by a New Zealand scientist carrying out research into the effects of a genetic variation linked to addictive, risk-taking and aggressive behaviour have angered the country's indigenous Maori population. Rod Lea, a geneticist based at the Institute of Environmental Science and Research in Wellington, New Zealand, told delegates attending an international genetics conference in Brisbane, Australia, that Maori men were twice as likely as Europeans to carry a particular version of the monoamine oxidase A (MAOA) gene. He claimed that the research, aimed at understanding smoking behaviour, 'goes a long way to explaining some of the problems the Maori have'.

Previous studies have linked the MAOA gene to an inherited predisposition for aggressive behaviour, which, despite their inconclusive nature, have lead to it being dubbed the 'warrior gene'. Lea reportedly told the conference that the widespread presence of the MAOA variant in the Maori population meant that 'obviously, this means they are going to be more aggressive and violent and more likely to get involved in risk-taking behaviour like gambling'. However, he stressed that 'there are lots of lifestyle, upbringing-related exposures that could be relevant here, so obviously the gene won't automatically make you a criminal'.

Maori leaders have reacted angrily to Lea's comments, saying that they only serve to reinforce 'Once Were Warriors' cultural stereotypes - a reference to a book and film of the same name that portrayed domestic violence in poor Maori families. 'I've been asked by reporters whether this gene is the reason why we're a violent race, why we feature so highly in criminality rates, that we're predisposed towards aggression', said Maori Party co-leader Tariana Turia in a statement, adding 'once were gardeners, once were astronomers, once were philosophers, once were lovers'.

Nicola Poa, a researcher at Christchurch School of Medicine in New Zealand, has also condemned the 'warrior gene' label. 'It is pretty contentious to be tagging a gene, especially with that type of behaviour, to an ethnic race', she told the New Zealand Herald, adding 'I was appalled'. Lea has responded to his critics by stressing that the reason for his research is to find better ways to treat tobacco dependence using genetic information. One in five New Zealanders smoke, but this rate rises to 46 per cent in the Maori population - a difference that Lea thinks could be down to variations in genes that influence the way the body metabolises nicotine, of which MAOA is one.

Speaking on New Zealand national radio, Lea said that although the MAOA has been linked to different antisocial and risk-taking behaviour, 'the link that's been made is usually quite weak and often is only present in association with non-genetic factors'. A 2002 study carried out by researchers based at Otago University and King's College in London, UK, found that children were more likely to be aggressive if they inherited a particular version the MAOA gene. However, they also showed that a genetic predisposition to antisocial behaviour was heavily influenced by upbringing: children who inherited the MAOA variant behaved normally if they were parented well.

SOURCES & REFERENCES
Maori gene claim stirs NZ family violence debate
The Scotsman |  9 August 2006
Maori 'warrior gene' claims appalling, says geneticist
The New Zealand Herald |  10 August 2006
Row over 'warrior gene' findings
ABC News Online |  9 August 2006
Warrior gene theory sparks debate and highlights domestic violence in New Zealand
News-Medical.net |  9 August 2006
RELATED ARTICLES FROM THE BIONEWS ARCHIVE
28 October 2013 - by Simon Hazelwood-Smith 
At this Royal Institution discussion examining the role that genetics can play in our justice systems, all speakers were in broad agreement with one another...
8 November 2009 - by Nienke Korsten 
An Italian court has reduced the sentence of a convicted murderer by a year based on evidence that he carries genetic mutations linked to aggressive behaviour. This is the first time that genetics have been considered a mitigating factor in a European court sentencing....
1 October 2006 - by Dr Mairi Levitt 
We're not arguing that genes made him do it but if violent behaviour is genetic then it is probably treatable'. This comment by a US lawyer on behalf of his client (who was eventually executed for murder last year) sums up the hope invested in research into violent and antisocial...
26 May 2005 - by BioNews 
Antisocial behaviour in children is strongly influenced by genetic factors - but only when accompanied by psychopathic tendencies, say UK scientists. The researchers, based at the Institute of Psychiatry at King's College in London, studied twins to investigate the role of genes and other factors in behaviour. Their findings, published in...
22 July 2004 - by BioNews 
Good mothering can cancel out a genetic predisposition to aggressive behaviour in monkeys, a new US study suggests. Scientists at the National Institutes of Health say that a nurturing environment can curb antisocial behaviour in rhesus monkeys born with low levels of certain brain chemicals. Their findings, which will be...
HAVE YOUR SAY
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions


Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.