Page URL:

Parents warned over speculative cord blood banking

18 June 2006
Appeared in BioNews 363

The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG) has issued an updated version of its Scientific Opinion Paper on Umbilical Cord Blood Banking. The report finds that there is little evidence to recommend the practice whereby private companies collect and store umbilical cord blood for up to twenty years - at a charge of up to £1500 - for possible future use. The NHS currently collects cord blood from selected centres in the UK, where women are approached during the maternity period and offered the opportunity to donate.

Cord blood stem cells have been useful in the treatment of cancers such as leukaemia. The NHS public bank collects 1700 to 2000 samples each year which may be accessed by those in need. Cord blood storage is also offered to families affected by specific genetic disorders that may be treatable with a transplant, for example Fanconi anaemia. Critics say that private companies play on parents fears, with the offer of future speculative treatments for many conditions not currently treatable with cord blood. Professor Peter Braude, head of the Department of Women's Health at King's College London and chair of the RCOG expert group commented, 'The likelihood of use is extremely small and some of the uses are extremely speculative'. Professor Braude went on to say that, 'Most people are unaware there is an NHS cord blood bank and most transplants are done with bone marrow'.

The RCOG committee called for increased funding into the NHS bank so that more samples could be collected and those in need could have better access. They warned that there is currently 'insufficient evidence' to recommend private collection and storage. Demand for private cord blood banks has increased recently with around 11,000 British couples opting to store their child's blood using companies such as the UK Cord Blood Bank, Smart Cells and Future Health. Susan Bewley, chairwoman of the RCOG ethics committee and a consultant obstetrician said, 'Being born is inherently quite dangerous. We meddle and fiddle with that at our peril'. The college recommends that each hospital trust needs to develop its own policy on how to deal with cord blood storage requests. Blood should only be extracted once the placenta is out of the womb and collection should be by a trained third party, not by the attending obstetrician or midwife whose care should be focused on the mother and child.

'Babies at risk' from umbilical blood business
The Times |  14 June 2006
Elixir of life' claims of cord cell storage firms speculative, mothers-to-be warned
The Guardian |  14 June 2006
Umbilical cell harvest is 'risky'
The Daily Telegraph |  13 June 2006
Warning over cord blood banking
BBC News Online |  13 June 2006
18 February 2008 - by Dr Karen Devine 
After two months of treatment for a rare form of cancer known as Neuroblastoma, two-year old Caden Ledbetter came home from hospital in Dallas, Texas, this week, cancer-free. Neuroblastoma is a fast-growing cancer, which affects the nervous system. Sporting a surgical mask and clutching a teddy bear...
18 November 2007 - by Dr Karen Devine 
As a consumerist society, we are fast becoming familiar with the idea that for a price, we can bank our stem cells in case they are needed in the future to potentially fight disease, grow replacement body parts and help develop clinical therapeutic options. First came the commercial cord blood...
18 November 2007 - by Dr Karen Devine 
The storage of stem cells as a 'biological insurance' for the future is once again hitting the headlines of the popular press. This week, American based company, Cryo-Cell, announced the launch of their new stem cell storage initiative - the opportunity for women to bank their menstrual blood...
23 October 2007 - by Dr Karen Devine 
The prospect of being able to store your own stem cells as a form of future 'biological insurance' is for many, very tempting. Since the late 1990s, and in spite of the reportedly low odds that they will ever be used, parents have seized the opportunity to...
13 March 2007 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
A hospital in the US has teamed up with a biotechnology company to allow pregnant women to bank their baby's cord blood and placental stem cells in what is thought to be the first official programme to encourage stem cell banking in the country. The Saint Barnabas...
15 June 2006 - by Dr Karen Devine 
This week saw the long awaited report from the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG), which stated its latest position on the public and private banking of umbilical cord blood stem cells. Essentially, their stance remains unchanged from the one taken in their previous opinion paper published in 2001...
26 November 2001 - by BioNews 
The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG) warned parents in the UK last week against banking the cord blood and umbilical cells from their babies in order to have 'insurance' against future diseases in their children. Scientists and doctors have said that the procedure cannot be justified on scientific...
Log in to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.