Page URL:

HFEA to change its mind on 'saviour siblings'?

19 July 2004
By BioNews
Appeared in BioNews 267

The UK's Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) is reported to be considering changing its policy on 'saviour siblings' - babies who are able to provide genetically matched cord blood for an existing sick child. The news follows a recent request from the Fletcher family, who are seeking permission to conceive a baby who could help treat their son Joshua. Mohammed Taranissi, of the Assisted Reproduction and Gynaecology Centre in London, was invited by the HFEA to submit a test case licence application for the family. Earlier this year, he said that he would challenge the authority in court, should the application prove unsuccessful. However, the HFEA is expected to approve the family's treatment following its meeting this Wednesday, Taranissi has revealed.

Two-year old Joshua Fletcher has Diamond Blackfan anaemia (DBA), a rare condition that could be cured with a blood stem cell transplant from a tissue-matched donor. His parents, Joe and Julie Fletcher, want to use PGD (preimplantation genetic diagnosis) to conceive an IVF baby who would be able to provide Joshua with compatible umbilical cord blood. Some cases of DBA are caused by a mutation in a gene called RPS19, but for most, the trigger remains unknown. In 2002, the HFEA turned down a request from the Whitaker family, who were also seeking to use PGD to conceive a tissue-matched baby to help a sibling with DBA. Michelle and Jayson Whitaker later travelled to Chicago to conceive their son James, born in June 2003, whose umbilical cord blood will be used to help treat their affected son Charlie.

PGD involves carrying out a genetic test on embryos created in IVF, usually to select those unaffected by a particular disease, which are then returned to the woman's womb. The HFEA refused the Whitakers permission to have the treatment in Britain because the cause of five-year-old Charlie's illness is unknown. This means the Whitakers, like the Fletchers, could only use PGD to establish tissue type, and not to find out whether an embryo was disease-free. The authority has, however, allowed families with children affected by beta thalassaemia to have similar treatment, since a genetic test for this blood disorder is available. The first of these couples, Raj and Shahana Hashmi, recently stopped IVF treatment after six unsuccessful attempts at conceiving a baby to save the life of their son Zain.

The HFEA is now expected to relax its rules over saviour siblings, to allow families in the same situation as the Whitakers and Fletchers to have the treatment. 'The HFEA operates in a fast moving area of science so it is important that it continues to keep all its policies under constant review', Suzi Leather, chair of the HFEA, told BBC News Online. But Josephine Quintavelle of the pressure group CORE, which mounted an unsuccessful legal challenge to the HFEA's decision on the Hashmis, described the treatment as 'unethical and unnecessary'. She told the BBC that 'the HFEA should not be making these decisions. They should be made by the public and parliament'.

IVF expert Simon Fishel told the Observer newspaper that the rule changes could benefit hundreds of couples and save the health service hundreds of millions of pounds a year. He said that as well as helping couples to save the lives of children with rare blood diseases like DBA, saviour siblings could also be conceived to help children with leukaemia. 'The public think this is about designer babies; in fact, the technique offers enormous potential', he added.

'Designer baby' rules may be relaxed to help save lives
The Independent |  18 July 2004
'Designer baby' rules up for debate
BBC News Online |  17 July 2004
Doctors plead for 'saviour siblings'
The Observer |  18 July 2004
Watchdog to review designer baby ban
The Daily Telegraph |  17 July 2004
5 May 2006 - by Dr Jess Buxton 
Another UK couple has received permission to try and conceive a 'saviour sibling' to provide cord blood stem cells to help treat their seriously ill child. Charlie and Catherine Mariethoz, from Leicester, have been granted a licence from the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) to...
8 August 2005 - by BioNews 
Three-week old Jodie Fletcher, the first 'saviour sibling' conceived in the UK, is a perfect genetic match for her three-year old brother, Joshua, who suffers from Diamond Blackfan anaemia (DBA), an incurable blood disorder. In September 2004, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) granted Joe and Julie Fletcher permission...
18 July 2005 - by BioNews 
A Belfast woman has given birth to the first 'saviour sibling' conceived in the UK: a baby girl who could help treat her seriously ill three-year-old brother. In September 2004, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) granted Joe and Julie Fletcher permission to have a tissue-matched baby to help...
28 April 2005 - by BioNews 
The UK's House of Lords has ruled that the decision taken by the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) to allow the Hashmi family to try to create a 'saviour sibling' was lawful. The highest court in the UK heard the appeal case of Quintavalle (On behalf of Comment on...
7 March 2005 - by BioNews 
The UK's House of Lords is being asked to decide whether a decision taken by the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA), which allowed the Hashmi family to try to create a 'saviour sibling', was wrong. The highest court in the UK has today listened to the first day of...
9 July 2004 - by BioNews 
Raj and Shahana Hashmi, the couple who fought for the right to have a tissue-matched IVF baby to save the life of their son Zain, are stopping treatment after six unsuccessful attempts. The couple's doctors are now reluctant to continue because of Shahana's age (40), and because of the stressful...
13 April 2004 - by BioNews 
A UK fertility doctor says he is prepared to launch a legal challenge on behalf of a couple who want to conceive a 'saviour sibling' for their ill son. Two-year old Joshua Fletcher has Diamond Blackfan anaemia, a rare condition that could be cured with a blood stem cell transplant...
8 July 2003 - by Josephine Quintavalle 
What was described by the media as either the 'designer baby' or the 'Hashmi' case was, in effect, neither. The legal arguments in the courts were directed exclusively at the governance of policy making in assisted reproduction. Comment on Reproductive Ethics (CORE) argued that, in 1990, Parliament did not give...
19 May 2003 - by BioNews 
The UK Court of Appeal gave detailed reasons last week for its decision in April to allow Raj and Shahana Hashmi to proceed with IVF treatment with embryo tissue typing in order to attempt to have a child who could save their existing son, Zain. Zain has thalassaemia, an inherited...
15 April 2003 - by Dr Colin Gavaghan 
A] defeat for society at large and certainly an overwhelming defeat for Parliamentary democracy.' So read the response from Josephine Quintavalle, Director of CORE (Comment on Reproductive Ethics), to April's UK Court of Appeal decision concerning tissue typing. The Court had reversed an earlier decision, in which a judge had...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.