Page URL:

IVF error discovered after 13 years

25 August 2003
By BioNews
Appeared in BioNews 222

A UK newspaper has reported that a 13-year old boy has grown up thinking the wrong man was his father after an IVF mix-up. The Sun reports that sperm from the wrong man was used during his mother's fertility treatment at the private Wellington Hospital clinic in London in 1988. The news comes following a court-ordered DNA test of the boy and his mother's first husband, who had at the time provided sperm for the IVF procedure. The boy and his mother had wanted a test to confirm suspicions that the man was not in fact the biological father.

The Sun reports that after 80 secret hearings, held over a period of six years, the Family Division of the High Court ordered this year that the boy's social father must supply a saliva sample for DNA paternity testing. The boy, who has not been named, told The Sun 'I am relieved to know the truth at last, but I have no wish to know who my real father is'. The boy's mother, who has since married again, said 'if the judge had ordered the DNA test all those years ago, when I first requested it, I might have been able to find out who [my son's] real father is'.

The Wellington Hospital no longer carries out IVF and the medical records relating to the case cannot now be found. The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA), which licenses all IVF clinics in the UK, had not been established in 1988. At that time, clinics were working under a Voluntary Licensing Authority (VLA), established in the absence of legislation. Following a case last year in which a white woman gave birth to mixed race twins after the wrong sperm was used in IVF, the HFEA introduced 'standard operating procedures' in order that every stage of the IVF treatment is double-checked. The authority says that 'cross checking and witnessing should minimise the risk of the 'wrong' sperm, eggs or embryos being used'.

Angela McNab, Chief Executive of the HFEA, said 'whilst the chance of any error occurring is extremely small because of the witnessing procedures now in place, the HFEA continuously assesses even 'near miss' incidents in order to improve safety across all licensed IVF clinics'. Professor Alison Murdoch, chair of the British Fertility Society, said the new checking system means that the potential for similar errors to occur in IVF these days is 'extremely slight'.

Boy had 'wrong dad' after IVF mix-up
BBC News Online |  22 August 2003
Boy 'had wrong father' after IVF mix-up
Ananova |  22 August 2003
How likely are IVF blunders?
BBC News Online |  22 August 2003
I always knew he wasn't my dad
The Sun |  22 August 2003
4 February 2013 - by Ari Haque 
Ottawa fertility doctor Norman Barwin has been suspended from practising medicine for two months after artificially inseminating women with the wrong sperm. Five women were involved in four incidents of receiving the wrong sperm between 1986 and 2007....
30 April 2012 - by Jessica Ware 
Two German gynaecologists will have to pay child support for twins after they artificially inseminated the mother without obtaining the father's permission to use his sperm, which he had asked to be destroyed two years earlier...
31 May 2006 - by Dr Kirsty Horsey 
A British couple have spoken to the press about the 'nightmare' they have gone through since a mistake was made during treatment they received at a Leeds fertility clinic six years ago. This is the first time the couple have spoken publicly about their situation, despite...
9 August 2004 - by BioNews 
An American woman who had the wrong embryo transferred to her uterus during IVF treatment has agreed to compensation of $1 million with the doctor who performed the procedure. Susan Buchweitz had the IVF treatment at Fertility Associates of the Bay Area clinic in San Francisco, California in 2000, which...
26 August 2003 - by Dr Kirsty Horsey 
This week's BioNews reports on an unnamed 13-year old boy who, after six years of legal action, has discovered the 'truth' about his parenthood. Confirming suspicions that he has supposedly harboured since he was aged five, a court-ordered DNA test has proved that the man he has grown up...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.