Save 20% on your next Cambridge Bioethics and Law online purchase
Page URL: https://www.bionews.org.uk/page_148138

UK Government adviser resigns over eugenics remarks

24 February 2020
Appeared in BioNews 1036

A recently appointed adviser to the UK government, Andrew Sabisky, has resigned following widespread criticism of his views on topics including genetics and reproduction.

The episode has also led to the government's chief special adviser, Dominic Cummings, being criticised for Sabisky's appointment. The appointment followed a call by Cummings for 'misfits with odd skills' and 'super-talented weirdos' to apply for jobs with government.

Sabisky is a self-described 'superforecaster' – a term defined, in research initiated by US intelligence agencies, as a person 'exceptionally skilled at assigning realistic probabilities to possible outcomes – even on topics outside their primary subject-matter training'. Cummings had previously called for government to use superforecasters, complaining that 'Whitehall has ignored this entire research programme'.

After Sabisky was appointed, he became the subject of intense criticism for remarks he had made in previous years – when interviewed by an education publication, and also in various comments posted online – about eugenics, IVF, embryo selection, race, intelligence and cognitive enhancement. A comment posted by Sabisky under a 2014 blogpost by Cummings proved especially controversial.

In the blogpost, Cummings had reported on a conference at Google's California headquarters where topics discussed included the genetics of intelligence, the selection of embryos and CRISPR genome editing. In a comment beneath the blogpost, Sabisky speculated about the likelihood and desirability of 'global embryo selection' and of mandatory contraception being introduced as a way to 'get around the problems of unplanned pregnancies creating a permanent underclass'.

Another participant in the 2014 conference attended by Cummings was the physicist and entrepreneur Stephen Hsu, who went on to become one of Cummings' friends and supporters. Hsu has founded a company which claims to be able to assess the intelligence potential of preimplantation IVF embryos, although this has been challenged on both scientific and ethical grounds (see BioNews 976 and 1025).

Cummings' interest in genetics first attracted attention when he was a senior policy adviser to the government's education secretary. A wide-ranging thesis that Cummings wrote for internal government use, which discussed genetics in relation to educational achievement, was leaked to the Guardian newspaper in 2013 (see BioNews 727).

SOURCES & REFERENCES
Andrew Sabisky: No 10 adviser resigns over alleged race comments
BBC News |  18 February 2020
Andrew Sabisky, political forecaster
Schools Week |  5 July 2016
Standin' by the window, where the light is strong
Dominic Cummings |  19 August 2014
'Two hands are a lot' - we're hiring data scientists, project managers, policy experts, assorted weirdos
Dominic Cummings |  2 January 2020
RELATED ARTICLES FROM THE BIONEWS ARCHIVE
25 November 2019 - by Eleanor Lynam 
'Designer babies' created via IVF and selected on the basis of genetic combinations for intelligence or height are unlikely to become reality, according to a recent study...
19 November 2018 - by Ruth Retassie 
A polygenic test to assess embryos for intelligence has been launched and several US IVF clinics are considering offering it to patients...
28 October 2013 - by Dr John Gillott 
Dominic Cummings and Robert Plomin are claiming a great deal about the effect of genetics on intelligence, some of which is sound, some of which is not and some of which is very speculative...
21 October 2013 - by Sandy Starr 
An adviser to the UK Government has provoked an outcry by arguing that there is a significant genetic basis for children's educational achievement...
HAVE YOUR SAY
Log in to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions


Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.