Page URL:

Arizona woman cannot use frozen embryos against ex-husband's wishes

27 January 2020
Appeared in BioNews 1032

A woman cannot use her frozen embryos to have a baby following opposition from her ex-husband, the Arizona Supreme Court has ruled.

Ruby Torres had her eggs fertilised and the resulting embryos preserved in 2014 prior to cancer treatment that left her infertile. However, after the couple divorced in 2017, Torres' ex-husband John Terrell asked the courts to order the embryos be donated in accordance with the contract they signed at their fertility clinic.

'We are cognisant of the unavoidable emotional fall-out attendant to the disposition of the embryos here,' Justice Ann Scott Timmer wrote in the ruling, 'but the family court was required to enforce the parties' chosen disposition of the embryos as set forth in the Agreement.'

Initially, a trial court ruled that the contract allowed courts to determine whether the embryos were to be donated or implanted, stating Terrell's interest in not having children outweighed Torres' right to have a biological child. Torres took her case to the state's Court of Appeals, which overturned that ruling last March, agreeing the contract allowed courts to decide but that Torres' right to have a child prevailed over Terrell's right not to become a father.

The Arizona Supreme Court ruled that both the trial court and appellate judges were wrong in ruling that a contract clause allowed courts to determine the fate of the embryos. It agreed with Terrell, however, that the clause in question 'means that upon divorce or dissolution of the relationship, the parties chose to donate the embryos absent a contemporaneous agreement for use by one of them'.

'I haven't had a chance to speak to my client yet, but I know how she probably feels after what she's been through,' Torres' attorney Stanley Murray told AZCentral. 'It's disappointing, because we had gotten the Court of Appeals on our side.'

The Arizona Legislature changed the law in 2018 in response to Torres' case to allow a former spouse to use embryos against their former partner's wishes, but relieving the ex-spouse of parental responsibilities including the provision of child support. The change is not retroactive and does not apply to Torres' case.

Divorced woman can't use frozen embryos, court rules
CTV News |  23 January 2020
Terrell v Torres
Supreme Court of Arizona |  23 January 2020
Top Arizona court: Divorced woman can't use frozen embryos
Fox 10 |  23 January 2020
Woman can't use fertilized embryos without ex-husband's consent, Arizona Supreme Court rules
AZCentral |  23 January 2020
Woman left infertile after aggressive cancer treatment can't use her OWN fertilized embryos to get pregnant
Daily Mail |  23 January 2020
2 August 2021 - by Sarah Wood-Heath 
Since 1991, the number of IVF cycles has increased significantly with success rates also growing…
8 February 2021 - by Sylvie Armstrong 
A Louisiana federal judge has dismissed a custody claim by Sofia Vergara's former fiancé over their frozen embryos...
17 June 2019 - by Bernie Owusu-Yaw 
A woman in Sydney, Australia is seeking a court order for the destruction of 12 embryos that are not genetically linked to her...
6 August 2018 - by Jen Willows 
An Ontario Court has awarded a former couple's frozen embryo to the wife, who wishes to use it to try to establish a pregnancy, in the first case to denote an embryo as 'property'...
11 June 2018 - by Dr Mary Yarwood 
A New York Court has ordered that a former couple's last frozen embryo must be destroyed, per the husband's wishes, despite being the woman's last chance to have a biologically related child...
16 April 2018 - by Kathryn Ashe 
Arizona's Governor has signed into law a bill that dictates how a couple's frozen embryos can be used if they separate...
15 January 2018 - by Theofanis Michailidis 
A divorced couple's legal battle over their frozen embryos has reached the Colorado Supreme Court...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.