Page URL:

Sperm donor implicated in multiple cases of child autism

23 September 2019
Appeared in BioNews 1016

A cluster of 12 children conceived from the same sperm donor all have autism spectrum disorders, prompting questions about the oversight of US sperm banks.

Danielle Rizzo from Illinois had two children in 2011 and 2012 using sperm donation. Both boys were subsequently diagnosed with autism, and after contacting other parents who had used the same donor, Rizzo discovered that almost all her sons' half-siblings are on the autistic spectrum. A genetic counsellor told Rizzo that the possibility of this happening by chance were extremely remote.

'There really needs to be regulation and oversight in this industry and that's why I'm coming forward,' Rizzo told CBS2. 'This needs to change.'

Rizzo and her partner selected donor H898 from sperm bank Idant in 2011. His profile said he had a Masters in Medical Photography and a clean bill of health. Rizzo called Idant before placing the order to check that they had verified the donor's background, and received assurances that they had. 

Both boys, now aged seven and eight, began showing signs of autism by age two. Unable to find childcare to meet her sons' needs, Rizzo had to leave her job, her relationship broke down and she lost her home. 

Rizzo has subsequently learned that at the time she verified the donor's information with Idant he did not have a degree of any kind. It also came to light that he had delayed speech as a child, and was diagnosed with ADHD, Pervasive Developmental Disorder (a form of autism spectrum disorder) and attended a school for children with learning difficulties. 

Rizzo contacted the FDA (Food and Drug Administration), and healthcare regulators in New York and California (where Idant claimed to be regulated) but none were able to help. She sued the sperm bank in 2017 and ultimately reached an out-of-court settlement in March 2019. 

Rizzo said she contacted several banks stocking H898's sperm and warned them about the autism cluster, but was told she had no proof. The Washington Post confirmed that some banks are still advertising H898's sperm for sale. 

For the last few years, Rizzo has been working with Dr Stephen Scherer at the University of Toronto in Canada who had been studying the genetics of autism for over 20 years. 

There is no genetic test for autism. Many factors are known to affect the likelihood of autism, including paternal age and pregnancy complications, as well as over 100 genes. However, Dr Scherer is researching a small subset of these genes which he calls 'high impact'. 

Two such mutations, MDB1 and SHANK1 are present in Rizzo's older son. His brother, and all seven of the half-siblings tested so far have at least one of these. Rizzo herself has neither.

Rizzo maintains that she did not sue because her sons are autistic but 'to right a wrong'. She wants regulators to impose stricter oversight of the sperm bank industry.

'If I knew then what I know now, I don't know if I would have ever used a sperm bank,' said Rizzo.

Single Sperm Donor Linked To Numerous Children With Autism, Other Disabilities
CBS Chicago |  18 September 2019
Sperm Donor Linked To Autism Cluster - Scientifically Fascinating, Legally Complicated
Above the Law |  18 September 2019
The children of Donor H898
Washington Post |  14 September 2019
16 August 2021 - by Dr Rachel Montgomery 
A recent study has found that as many as one in 15 men carry mutations in their sperm that could impact the health of their children...
2 August 2021 - by Semyon Bodian 
A number of rare inherited genetic mutations have been identified in families with children diagnosed with autism...
28 September 2020 - by Javier Bautista 
Adults conceived through sperm donation self-reported higher frequencies of immunological diseases compared with adults born through spontaneous conception, according to a new study...
27 January 2020 - by Alegria Vaz Mouyal 
Men should be permitted to donate their sperm after death in the same way they can donate organs, according to a new paper in the Journal of Medical Ethics...
2 December 2019 - by Dr Kimberley Bryon-Dodd 
The first sperm bank in the world for HIV positive donors has been launched in New Zealand...
30 November 2015 - by Antony Starza-Allen 
A woman is suing a fertility clinic in Australia for failing to detect that she was a carrier of a genetic mutation during pre-pregnancy testing, after her sons were later born with an inherited condition....
30 March 2015 - by Dr Charlotte Warren-Gash 
Children conceived with assisted reproductive technology may be twice as likely to develop autism...
7 July 2014 - by Alice Plein 
Children born to parents with fertility problems are more likely to develop psychiatric disorders, a large-scale population study suggests....
28 October 2013 - by María Victoria Rivas Llanos 
Sex selection in IVF as a method of avoiding autism has been approved for the first time by health authorities in Western Australia...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.