Page URL:

Gay couple file lawsuit against US state department after baby denied citizenship

5 August 2019
Appeared in BioNews 1009

A married couple has been told that their daughter is ineligible for US citizenship despite the fact that they are both American citizens.

James Mize was born and raised in the US, while Jonathan Gregg was born in the UK to an American mother and a British father, and has dual citizenship. Gregg moved from the UK to the US in 2014, the couple married in 2015 and now reside in Atlanta, Georgia. 

Their daughter Simone was born in England in July 2018 following a gestational surrogacy arrangement with a friend and was conceived with a donated egg and Gregg's sperm

Following the birth of their daughter, Gregg and Mize discovered that it would be more difficult for them to obtain US citizenship for their daughter because only one of them was biologically connected to Simone.

Since Mize was not biologically related to Simone, her birth was designated as 'out of wedlock' by US State Department, triggering stricter qualifying criteria relating to Gregg's length of residence in the US. As Gregg had lived in the US for under five years prior to their application, he did not meet the qualifying threshold, and Simone's citizenship application was denied. 

Simone is now living in the US under a travel visa, which Gregg and Mize must regularly return to the UK to renew. 

The couple has filed a discrimination claim in federal court in Atlanta against the Secretary of State, Mike Pompeo. Their lawyers argue that the State Department's policy unfairly impacts same-sex couples who have had fertility treatment overseas. 

Children born outside of the US to married couples who are both citizens are automatically granted US citizenship if one parent has lived in the US. However, since Mize and Gregg are not both biologically related to Simone, the 'out of wedlock' criteria effectively invalidates their marriage for the purposes of their application, imposing more stringent residency requirements. 

The State Department argues that the law is not discriminatory as it applies to all couples who use surrogacy or donor gametes to conceive outside the US.  But in practice, the couple's lawyers have argued, heterosexual couples do not come under the same level of scrutiny and are not usually asked to prove genetic relatedness to their child. 

Talking to NBC News about their experience at the US embassy in London where the couple was denied a US passport for Simone, Mize said: 'In that moment, every anxiety I'd ever had in my life about being gay and different came into my body and I just wanted to cry.'

Gay couple sues over U.S. refusal to recognize child as citizen
NBC News |  24 July 2019
Gay U.S. Couple Sues State Dept. for Denying Their Baby Citizenship
The New York Times |  23 July 2019
This Baby’s Parents Are Both U.S. Citizens, But The U.S. Government Says She Isn’t One
Above the Law |  31 July 2019
22 November 2021 - by James Moore 
Same-sex couples in Switzerland will be able to marry from July 2022 and will have the same access to assisted reproduction as heterosexual couples...
25 October 2021 - by Ruth Retassie 
The Namibian High Court has granted citizenship to the child of a same-sex couple born via surrogacy...
24 May 2021 - by Sylvie Armstrong 
The USA will now grant citizenship to more babies born abroad via surrogacy...
15 July 2019 - by Professor Sonia Suter 
The State Department's citizenship policies for children born abroad through assisted reproductive technologies, however, are out of touch, leading to devastating denials of US citizenship for children born to American citizens in same-sex marriages...
17 June 2019 - by Suzi Denton 
A bill that proposes to lift the ban on commercial surrogacy in New York State was passed by the State Senate last week...
14 January 2019 - by Suzi Denton 
A single father whose twin girls were born through gestational surrogacy in Kenya has been allowed to return home to Canada with his children...
14 January 2019 - by Kulraj Singh Bhangra 
The Lok Sabha, India's lower house, has passed a bill that bans commercial surrogacy...
5 November 2018 - by Jen Willows 
Israel's parliament, the Knesset has rejected a bill to allow single men and gay couples equal access to surrogacy...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.