Page URL:

Canadian man gets surrogate-born twins back after immigration row

14 January 2019
Appeared in BioNews 982

A single father whose twin girls were born through gestational surrogacy in Kenya has been allowed to return home to Canada with his children. 

Joseph Tito's twins, Stella and Mia, were born in Mombasa, Kenya, in November 2018. Tito was making arrangements to return to Canada with his children in December when he was told by the Canadian High Commission that due to a quirk in Canadian immigration law, the twins did not automatically qualify for Canadian citizenship. He would therefore not be able to take them home until their citizenship status had been resolved.

The 'one generation' rule, which came into force in Canada in 2015 when the Citizenship Act was amended, means that Canadian citizens who are born outside of the country are not able to pass on their citizenship to their children if their children are also born outside of Canada. As Tito was born in Italy to a Canadian mother, his children did not automatically become Canadian citizens at birth. 

Tito has called for the rule to be changed: 'I think it needs to be amended for people who live in Canada and who are Canadian,' he told Global News.

There followed a period of uncertainty for Tito and his new family, as he was told that he may be facing a wait of between six and 12 months before he would be able to return home with his children, while the twins' applications for permanent Canadian residency were being processed.

Tito began the permanent residency application process in late December, sponsoring the applications using his citizenship status. He then discovered that he could apply for temporary resident visas for the twins, which enabled him to travel home while the permanent applications were pending. 

Tito's situation attracted international media attention, and according to CityNews, he believes this is why the situation was resolved quickly. On his return to Canada, he told CityNews: 'I think it's surreal. I still can't believe I'm here after all this time.'  

Immigration attorney Joel Sandaluk agrees that the rule is 'problematic'. He told CBC News: 'It creates two separate classes of Canadian citizenship – one which is inherently more valuable than the other.'

Sandaluk also described the rule as 'arbitrary', as 'Certain Canadian citizens are able to pass along their citizenship to their children if they're born outside of Canada whereas other Canadian citizens are not', he told CBC News.

Tito offered advice to others who are considering embarking on an international surrogacy arrangement. He told Global News: 'Just research everything. Research whatever country you're in, research their laws, research our laws.' 

Canadian surrogate dad brings twin girls home from Kenya
Global News Canada |  9 January 2019
Single father of twin girls returns to Canada after surrogacy ordeal
CBC News |  9 January 2019
Toronto man returns home with twin girls after clearing citizenship hurdle
Toronto City News |  9 January 2019
13 July 2020 - by Emma Bunting 
The Supreme Court of Canada has ruled to uphold a federal law forbidding third parties from demanding people's genetic information...
5 August 2019 - by Suzi Denton 
A married couple has been told that their daughter is ineligible for US citizenship despite the fact that they are both American citizens...
7 May 2019 - by Bernie Owusu-Yaw 
The USA's Department of Homeland Security is expected to initiate a DNA testing pilot programme this week at the US-Mexico border, in efforts to verify genetic relationships within families entering the USA...
4 February 2019 - by Martha Henriques 
A woman in Portland, Oregon, has been issued a warning from the sperm bank she used to conceive her child, after finding her donor's family via a 23andMe DNA test...
7 January 2019 - by Suzi Denton 
A Canadian man whose twin girls were born via gestational surrogacy in Kenya is currently unable to bring his children home due to Canadian citizenship laws...
26 November 2018 - by Vanessa Gruben 
In Canada, the purchase of human sperm and eggs is currently illegal under the Assisted Human Reproduction Act. Yet there are many commercial transactions involving sperm and eggs occurring across the border. Indeed, importers such as Can-Am Cryoservices run a thriving business importing sperm and eggs from sperm and egg banks outside of Canada, like Fairfax Egg Bank in the United States...
5 November 2018 - by Nina Chohan 
The Canadian government has proposed updates to existing assisted reproduction law, including payment of expenses to gamete donors and surrogates...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.