Page URL:

Woman sues UK hospital over Huntington's inheritance

3 December 2018
Appeared in BioNews 978

A lawsuit brought against a London hospital by a woman whose father's doctors failed to inform her of her risk of Huntington's disease could result in major changes to the laws surrounding patient confidentiality.

The woman's father was diagnosed with the incurable hereditary disease in 2009 but refused to let doctors inform his family. His daughter did not find out about her father's condition – and therefore was not tested herself – until after she had given birth to her own daughter. The woman subsequently tested positive, and her daughter has a 50 percent chance of also being affected. She claims that she would not have become a mother if she had known, and believes the doctors had a duty of care to share the information, even though it was against her father's wishes. 

'This could really change the way we do medicine, because it is about the duty that doctors have to share genetic test results with relatives and whether the duty exists in law,' Dr Anna Middleton, head of society and ethics research at the Wellcome Genome Campus in Cambridge, told the Observer.

The case was 'struck out' (not permitted to proceed to trial) by the High Court in 2015, because of concerns that if doctors were required to disclose genetic information to a patient's family, it would undermine doctor-patient confidentiality. This decision was overturned by the Court of Appeal in 2017 (see BioNews 901), and a hearing date has now been set for November 2019.  

The case raises many questions about the responsibilities that doctors have and when it is appropriate to share genetic information with relatives.

A spokesman for the woman's lawyers, Fieldfisher, emphasised that this case is 'very important'. He asked: 'Should clinicians be legally obliged to consider the interests of anyone they are reasonably aware of who could be affected by genetic information – or is the protection afforded by current professional guidance enough?'

Mother To Sue Doctors For Failing To Reveal Her Father Had Huntington’s Disease
Huffington Post |  26 November 2018
Woman who inherited fatal illness to sue doctors in groundbreaking case
The Observer |  25 November 2018
2 March 2020 - by Professor Anneke Lucassen 
A long-awaited decision in the case of ABC v St George's and others was made public last week...
2 March 2020 - by Jen Willows 
A UK woman who sued her father's doctors because they did not inform her of her risk of Huntington's disease has lost her case...
9 July 2018 - by Dr Charlott Repschlager 
The latest event organised by the Progress Educational Trust, 'With great genomic data comes great responsibility', came at a perfect time...
19 February 2018 - by Dr Hannah Somers 
Researchers have discovered that the protein responsible for the development of Huntington's disease is highly toxic to cancer cells...
10 July 2017 - by Victoria Chico 
In ABC v St Georges NHS Trust, the daughter of a man with Huntington's disease sued the UK hospital caring for her father, claiming that they had a duty of care to share the father's diagnosis with her, even against his wishes...
22 May 2017 - by Jen Willows 
A woman whose father has Huntington’s disease has won the right to sue his doctors for negligence, for failing to tell her...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.