Page URL:

Home DNA test kits should come with a warning, says HFEA

24 September 2018
Appeared in BioNews 968

The UK's Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) is urging companies that offer direct-to-consumer DNA testing to provide more comprehensive warnings to customers.

recent paper presented to the HFEA board, oulined how egg and sperm donors, as well as donor-conceived people, could be impacted by direct-to-consumer DNA testing and 'matching' services which offer to connect customers who are genetically related to each other. DNA testing services could reveal someone's unknown donor-conceived status, or uncover the identity of a donor who believed they had anonymity.

'Donors who think the anonymity can be protected are suddenly discovering they can't,' said Nina Barnsley, director of the Donor Conception Network. 'Even if you don't upload your DNA anywhere, you can still be found. It's a new world and we are all playing catch-up,' she told The Guardian newspaper.

While popular DNA testing companies such as 23andMe,, and can only 'match' users within their databases, customers could still use a single match to track down other relatives through social media or birth and marriage records. And while these companies may disclose that unexpected genetic information may be discovered 'in the small print', the HFEA paper argues that customers may not be adequately warned of the risks, nor offered any support.

'We found no DNA testing and matching services that mention that a need for professional emotional support may arise from relatedness matching, or via further inference from matching,' stated the HFEA paper. 'No service offers professional emotional support to users, nor signposts to other available support.'
While the HFEA does not have the authority to force companies to provide warnings, the HFEA paper outlines a response plan that includes raising awareness of these risks and providing information and support through the HFEA website and clinics, and reaching out to DNA testing companies to have a dialogue about why greater warning should be provided on their websites.

HFEA Chair Sally Cheshire has pledged that the websites will be contacted and that these issues will be discussed with the UK's Department of Health, The Guardian reported.

HFEA - Authority meeting 12 September 2018
HFEA |  12 September 2018
Warning over risks of DNA testing sites
Yahoo News UK |  18 September 2018
Watchdog calls for warnings on DNA testing sites
The Guardian |  18 September 2018
23 September 2019 - by Dr Alexander Ware 
Channel 4 News have recently produced two short films on genetic testing...
5 August 2019 - by Francesca Sowerbutts 
23andMe advertises itself on its website as a way to 'meet your genes'. You can send off a spit sample, and for $99-$199, a report based on your genetics will be emailed to you a few weeks later...
17 June 2019 - by Sarah Norcross 
This coming Wednesday evening (19 June), the Progress Educational Trust – the charity that publishes BioNews – is holding a free-to-attend public event in London discussing direct-to-consumer genetic testing in relation to donor anonymity...
4 February 2019 - by Martha Henriques 
A woman in Portland, Oregon, has been issued a warning from the sperm bank she used to conceive her child, after finding her donor's family via a 23andMe DNA test...
28 January 2019 - by Martha Henriques 
The US Food and Drug Administration has approved a direct-to-consumer genetic test for a hereditary form of colorectal cancer by 23andMe...
26 March 2018 - by Martha Henriques 
At-home genetic test results should be verified by medical professionals, researchers have warned, as a study reveals that 40 percent of the time DIY testing kits incorrectly identify genetic variants...
4 November 2013 - by Dr Naqash Raja 
A fertility test which allows men to check their sperm count in the comfort of their home - or wherever they feel is most suitable - has gone on sale in the UK...
7 November 2011 - by Julianna Photopoulos 
A PhD student at the University of Twente in the Netherlands has developed an at-home fertility test for men which counts sperm and measures their motility...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.