Page URL:

Womb scratching: common IVF add-on has no benefit

3 July 2018
By Shaoni Bhattacharya
Reporting from the European Society for Human Reproduction and Embryology's 2018 annual meeting in Barcelona
Appeared in BioNews 957

A common procedure, known as endometrial or womb 'scratching', as an add-on to IVF has been shown to have no effect on pregnancy or birth rates.

Researchers who carried out a large international randomised clinical trial on womb scratching say that the procedure should be abandoned by fertility clinics.

'Results from earlier studies have suggested a benefit from endometrial scratching in IVF, especially in women with previous implantation failure,' said Dr Sarah Lensen at the University of Auckland, New Zealand. 'However, many of these studies had a high risk of bias in their design or conduct and did not provide strong evidence.'

The study involved more than 1300 women undergoing IVF at 13 fertility centres in five countries, including the UK. One half was randomly assigned to have an endometrial scratch, while the other half had no add-on procedure.

Both groups showed a similar pregnancy rate of 31 percent, and the same proportion of women – 26.1 percent – eventually had a baby in both groups.

The practice of endometrial scratching has 'become very widely adopted in international and UK practice', according to Mr Stuart Lavery, a consultant gynaecologist at Hammersmith Hospital in London, who was not involved in the study.

In previous studies that suggested a benefit, it had been proposed that causing a small injury to the womb's lining would result in an inflammatory response conducive to an embryo transplanting.

'Other trials have not been as big or as rigorous as this trial,' said Mr Lavery. 'It's one trial – but I think people might now pause and consider this.'

He added that the procedure is painful. 'If you are putting yourself through that you might want it to be of some degree of benefit.'

However, Professor Nick Macklon at the University of Southampton, said that many patients in the trial did not have a history of difficulty conceiving. 'It doesn't completely answer the question of the role of womb scratching in IVF.'

He added that the next phase would be to go back and see if there were any subgroups of women who might benefit. 'We have to be careful that we don't just write off a potentially useful intervention.' 

However, he noted that the procedure 'probably has been overused'.

Dr Lensen presented the results of the trial at the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology annual conference in Barcelona, Spain.

31 August 2021 - by Javier Bautista 
Screening for a molecule that inhibits embryo implantation, and timing embryo transfer around this, could improve IVF success rates...
19 November 2018 - by Rikita Patel 
The Human Fertilisation Embryology Authority has signed a consensus statement calling for private IVF clinics to stop charging patients costly optional add-on treatments that are not proven to work...
16 July 2018 - by Rachel Siden 
The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority will require fertility clinics to give patients full information about any IVF 'add-on' services being offered to them...
2 July 2018 - by Shaoni Bhattacharya 
Scientists have successfully supported human follicles – the precursors of egg cells – on a bioengineered ovarian 'scaffold' for the first time. The work is an important proof-of-concept, which may pave the way for developing artificial ovaries for women undergoing cancer treatment...
19 March 2018 - by Richard Kennedy 
The global burden of infertility has been estimated as 48 million. As we approach the 40th anniversary of the birth of Louise Brown, the first child conceived following IVF, it is timely to reflect on the global revolution of assisted reproduction services...
to add a Comment.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions

Syndicate this story - click here to enquire about using this story.