Subscribe to the BioNews newsletter for free

Login
Advanced Search

Search for
BioNews

Like the Progress Educational Trust on Facebook


 


 

Private cord blood collection and cerebral palsy –  is there a connection?

22 November 2010

By Dr Karen Devine

Appeared in BioNews 585
In April 2008, a Los Angeles Times article posed the question: 'Can a child's umbilical cord blood be used to treat his own cerebral palsy?' (1) The article referred to the extraordinary improvement in health of a little boy in the US, Dallas Hextell, who has the motor neurone disease, cerebral palsy. This neurological condition impairs muscle control, affecting a person's ability to move and their sense of balance.

The article recalled how doctors had reinfused Dallas' own umbilical cord blood (UCB) cells. His parents had them saved at birth and stored in a private cord blood bank 'just in case' they were needed. It appears they were right to do so - Dallas transformed from being unable to crawl, sit, walk or suck to walking, reaching and saying 'moma' within five days of the treatment. This remarkable achievement prompted his parents to call cord blood stem cells 'liquid gold' (2).

Dallas - it seems - is not alone. This week, the media reported on a British girl, Sasha Browne, who also suffers from cerebral palsy. Her stem cells were banked at birth with private company Smart Cells and - like Dallas - had her cells reintroduced into her body. Sasha, it is reported, has also shown signs of improvement to her motor skills. Her physiotherapist reportedly declared her progress 'had been faster than that of her other patients with the condition' (3).

A quick search in Google reveals many more children with similar stories - Ryan Schneider, Chloe Levine, Abby Pell, Jack Abernathy, Antony Orjuela and Hayleigh Cox to name but a few. Many grace the websites of private cord blood companies eager to tell their story to other families. But what these children have in common - besides having their cord blood saved at birth - is they all have cerebral palsy or anoxic brain injury. This begs the question: 'Is there a connection between saving a child's cord blood and developing neurological problems?'

To save the optimum cord blood volume for reinfusement, the baby's umbilical cord must be clamped before the cord has ceased pulsating (4) (5). Early clamping, however, can prevent full placental transfusion. This transfer of fetal blood from the placenta at birth provides the baby with up to 30 percent more blood volume and up to 60 percent more red blood cells (6).

An animal study has revealed blood loss at birth could result in harm (7). In the study, 25 percent of the blood volume of newborn rats was removed. At only three hours old, proinflammatory cytokines, indicating tissue damage, were detected in the lungs and liver of the rats whose blood was removed. No proinflammatory cytokines were detected in rats subject to no intervention at birth. The researchers concluded removing the rat pups' blood had damaged their vital organs.

These results show early cord clamping to procure cord blood may interfere with placental transfusion, which may deny the human infant of up to 30 percent of its total blood volume. Given the effects of blood removal in animals, any denial of blood volume can present a risk to the health of the baby.

Dr Judith Mercer from the University of Rhode Island says about immediate clamping: 'In our well-intended haste to transfer an infant to the paediatric staff, we may be denying the infant a significant part of his vital blood supply' (8). A study published in 1998 further showed high quantities of proinflammatory cytokines were present in early blood samples taken from newborn infants who later developed cerebral palsy (9). Their presence suggests early clamping for UCB collection may pose health problems for the baby.

The risk of Intraventricular Haemorrhage (IVH) (10) in preterm infants is also a reported complication of early cord clamping. IVH is a serious condition, which can ultimately lead to brain damage. A study of 38 women who had preterm deliveries in South Africa in 1988 (11) found 78 percent of those whose cords were clamped early experienced IVH compared to 35 percent of those delayed for up to one minute.

The principal investigators in the South African study suggested IVH occurs due to the sudden increase in pressure to the arteries caused by immediate clamping, which prematurely cuts off the blood supply (12). The research, however, has attracted criticisms due to the sample size, the study location and the fact its participants were not candidates for cord blood collection (13).

Only scientific statistical information can link the timing of cord clamping with the possible risks saving cord blood may generate. The dearth of valid data adds to the uncertainties of the risks involved. While cerebral palsy and birth-related brain injury can be caused by several different factors, the time has come to conclusively exclude cord blood collection as a potential cause. We owe this to parents desperate to safeguard their children's future health, but who may be placing them at greater risk.

If nothing else, awareness must be raised for those who do participate in cord blood collection. We need to ensure their private cord blood provider adopts the delayed cord clamping method as advocated by public cord blood banks and those who collect for at-risk families.

I'll leave the final word to consultant obstetrician and gynaecologist, David Hutcheon, who said: 'Cord blood collection must not be allowed to restrict the [delayed cord clamping] practice. The value of delayed cord clamping has been shown whereas the value of commercial cord blood banking is still hypothetical at present' (14).

SOURCES & REFERENCES
Los Angeles Times | 07 April 2008
 
02) The Dallas Hextell Foundation
Dallas Hextell Foundation | 13 November 2010
 
Daily Mail | 08 November 2010
 
04) Ende, N. 'Cord blood collection: Effects of newborns (Medical-Legal)
Blood 12 | 1995
 
05) Levy, T. and Blickstein, I. 'Timing of cord clamping revisited'
Journal of Perinatal Medicine 34 (4) | 2006
 
06) Mercer, J.S. 'Current best evidence: a review of the literature on umbilical cord blood clamping'
Journal of Midwifery and Women's Health 46 (6),402. | 2001
 
07) Rajnik, M., Salkowski, C., Li, Y., Thomas, K., Rollwagen, F. and S. Volges 'Early cytokine expression induced by hemorrhagic shock in a non-resuscitated rat model'
Pediatric Research 49, 4S and 44A | 2001
 
08) Mercer (n. 6)
| 
 
09) Nelson, K.B., Dambrosia, J.M., Grether, J.K., and Phillips T.M. 'Neonatal cytokines and coagulation factors in children with cerebral palsy'
Annals of Neurology 44(4), 665 | 1998
 
10) Bleeding within the brain, which places pressure on the nerve cells and can cause brain damage
| 
 
11) Hofmeyr, G.J., Bolton, K.D., Bowen, D.C., Govan, J.J. 'Periventricular/intraventricular haemorrhage and umbilical cord clamping. Findings and Hypothesis'
South African Medical Journal 73 (2), 104 | 1988
 
12) Hofmeyer, G.J., Bex, P.J.M., Skapinker, R. and Delahunt T. 'Hasty clamping of the umbilical cord may initiate neonatal intraventricular hemorrhage'
Medical Hypotheses 29 (1), 5 | 1989
 
13) Bertolini, F. 'Response of Bertolini to Ende (Letter) Cord blood collection: effects on newborns (Medical-Legal)
Blood 86 (12), 4699 | 1995
 
14) Hutcheon, D.J.R, ' Commercial cord blood banking - Immediate cord clamping is not safe'
British Medical Journal (Letter) 333, 919 | 2006
 

RELATED ARTICLES FROM THE BIONEWS ARCHIVE

10 August 2015 - by Dr Nicola Davis 
A Canadian study has found that as many as ten percent of cerebral palsy cases have a genetic cause...
06 June 2012 - by Holly Rogers 
Stem cells will be harvested and stored at an umbilical cord donor centre at the Birmingham Women's Hospital, UK, according to a BBC report...
06 February 2012 - by Dr Mary Yarwood 
The All Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Stem Cell Transplantation last week called for more facilities in the UK to increase the collection and banking of valuable cord blood....

23 August 2010 - by Chris Chatterton 
Scottish researchers have taken a major step towards the 'holy grail' of haematology - the ability to produce a limitless supply of artificial blood cells. The team successfully produced significant amounts of red blood cells from stem cells harvested from spare IVF embryos...
28 May 2010 - by Rosemary Paxman 
Delaying the clamping of the umbilical cord after birth by several minutes could bring future health benefits to newborns, according to new research....
16 March 2010 - by Dr Karen Devine 
Back in 2002, I recall a story in Red magazine about a father who had allegedly collected the stem cells from his newborn baby's umbilical cord in the delivering hospital's car park. It said he had been handed the placenta - wrapped in newspaper - by the midwife and told that if he wanted to save the cord blood, it would have to be done outside. You might say that this is rather a strange place to procure such precious cells that have the ability to treat a range of blood cancers and disorder...

HAVE YOUR SAY
Be the first to have your say.

You need to or  to add comments.

By posting a comment you agree to abide by the BioNews terms and conditions


- click here to enquire about using this story.

Published by the Progress Educational Trust

CROSSING FRONTIERS

Public Conference
London
8 December 2017

Speakers include

Professor Azim Surani

Professor Magdalena Zernicka-Goetz

Professor Robin Lovell-Badge

Sally Cheshire

Professor Guido Pennings

Katherine Littler

Professor Allan Pacey

Dr Sue Avery

Professor Richard Anderson

Dr Elizabeth Garner

Dr Andy Greenfield

Dr Anna Smajdor

Dr Henry Malter

Vivienne Parry

Dr Helen O'Neill

Dr César Palacios-González

Philippa Taylor

Fiona Fox

Sarah Norcross

Sandy Starr


BOOK HERE

Good Fundraising Code

Become a Friend of PET HERE and give the Progress Educational Trust a regular donation